Member Since: 2/13/2012
Posts: 62,082
|
A T R L ' s
H O L Y T R I N I T Y
J U D G E C O M M E N T S
Astraeius
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Collin
You relied on imagery a bit much in this trinity. I like that you got creative with the interpretation, but the audio should be able to speak for itself. Maybe the audio you chose was a bit "dark", but... not that much. I'd call it more downtempo and sorta melancholy, but I don't come close to getting shivers from these songs.
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Emmy Del Rey
Oh how very interesting, using two TV intros for entries. I like it, and then ending with a movie theme. I like everything about this, good job.
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Katie
What a unique spin! I really enjoyed a theme within a theme. I've never seen these programs but I can get a sense of their darkness just from these songs.
|
Sebas
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Collin
Sister, I'm not so sure about this one. Gaga, Eminem and Radiohead have like 500 better choices for "dark" songs (less Gaga, so/so Eminem, most Radiohead)  I sorta liked the write-up you did but it didn't seem to tie into the round exactly, and seemed a bit unnecessary  |
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Emmy Del Rey
It was cute, um, for the most part. I just didn't feel anything, it was a bit like "okay lets get to the next song" but not much excitement doing so, you know?
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Katie
I never realized Gaga only said Bloody Mary 3 times. Everything in your trinity worked really well! I liked the cohesion and the explanations definitely made it easier.
|
TheSeenScene
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Collin
Very, very interesting take on "dark", Scene. The "dark" I get from this is a sad summer day where you feel especially alone and empty. It's a "light" type of "dark", if you will. For some odd reason it works, even though it wasn't what I was expecting for the round. It also must be understood, however, that truer "dark" trinities will come on top of this.
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Emmy Del Rey
Your entries always give me one surprise, and I think that's what I like about them. You pick something that isn't something most people would think of, but works FANTASTIC.
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Katie
When pop girls go dark, I'd say. Everything fit well together but it still might have been too soft for this week's theme.
|
holyground
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Collin
This was rather nice. I like how you used covers, I think that was really effective. Not blown away by your trinity, admittedly, but it was enjoyable (and even if I drag you I'm sure Katie will love it  ) |
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Emmy Del Rey
Yasssss for Once Upon A Dream, best song for this challenge imo, and I'm not just saying that because Lana is my mother. Yes to ALL of this though, everything consistent, fits perfectly. To die!
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Katie
Your trinity was probably the closest to what I had in mind for the theme. The songs were dark, mysterious, and everything you mentioned. The last one is a little iffy but I can see it with your explanation.
|
Tymps.
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Collin
As usual, amazing trinity and amazing themes. Don't know what you were worrying about. My favorite has to be the Fiona Apple cut, just because it makes moderate light of such a dark situation and is caked between two very, very "dark" feeling songs (and not fake dark, either). Gets my stamp of approval.
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Emmy Del Rey
Very dark, very interesting, very I guess.
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Katie
Jesus, Adem, when did you get so ****ing dark? This one may have been too much. My Barbie soul cannot take this. I guess that means you win the round completely.
|
Musickid203
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Collin
This trinity crawled under my skin. So, so great. More and more impressed with you each round.
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Emmy Del Rey
Didn't you already use monster  Repeats aren't fun, boo. I want some more versatility from you. |
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Katie
It has that very familiar Musickid203 touch that we know so well. I'm not sure what your definition of 'dark' would be, and these songs don't illuminate that very well.
|
Kyle.
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Collin
Did you know "mer" means sea? I read that somewhere once ('Mer Girl' is one of my favorite songs of all time). Not sure why you adopted a water theme for this round, but it's rather interesting and seems to work rather well - does it possibly stem from an underlying fear of water? Very enjoyable and exceptional trinity.
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Emmy Del Rey
Oh this is very interesting actually. You did a good job of keeping attention, being consistent, and versatile. Good job.
|
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Katie
omg PJ Harvey was a nice addition. Your songs were in typical dark fashion but that's fine by me. I liked the overall cohesion of the trinity.
|
R A N K I N G S
holyground
Collin ▲ #5
Katie ▲ #1
Emmy Del Rey ▲ #2 |
TheSeenScene
Collin ▲ #4
Katie ▲ #6
Emmy Del Rey ▲ #1 |
Kyle.
Collin ▲ #3
Katie ▲ #4
Emmy Del Rey ▲ #4 |
Tymps.
Collin ▲ #2
Katie ▲ #5
Emmy Del Rey ▲ #5 |
Note - - - Tymps. is still at risk for elimination IF and ONLY IF the
Golden Trinity decides to eliminate him as the optional second choice for elimination this round
Astraeius
Collin ▲ #7
Katie ▲ #2
Emmy Del Rey ▲ #3 |
Musickid203
Collin ▲ #1
Katie ▲ #7
Emmy Del Rey ▲ #7 |
Sebas
Collin ▲ #6
Katie ▲ #3
Emmy Del Rey ▲ #6 |
The Golden Trinity shall soon speak... and OH shall they speak.
|
|
|
|
Coming sometime today, now for a while though...
(hint-edy hint hint)
