[ImpressiveInstant]

Originally posted by madonnas

In the next set.

We will see:

-ImpressiveInstant's favorite Ray of Light non-single
-Madonna's most controversial single
-Madonna's biggest lyrical nightmare
-A gay rights anthem
-A gigantic signature song.

Among others.


I can't do it at the same time tomorrow, so you'll have to be flexible and wait for me!

It's made the list too?! OMG

[Kang.]

Kewl... The only 2 of mine that are gone are Runaway Lover and Lucky Star. (I didn't vote for Sorry, did I?)

I don't know how many of my songs are left though.

[ImpressiveInstant]

Originally posted by True Skarlet

Who has bad taste now, bitch!!!!!!!!!?

Shut up, I'll Remember Such Slayage is probably in the Top 3 of her ballads. So amazing

Critics agree with me:

Author Christopher Feldman in his book, Billboard book of number 2 singles, described the song as a "tender ballad." Billboard music editor Timothy White called the song as lilting and one of Madonna's classics in his book Music to my ears: the Billboard essays : portraits of popular music in the '90s An owl book. He also complimented the song for talking about a dead relationship. Author Rikky Rooksby called the song as one of Madonna's biggest ever singles and a stronger cut. Sal Cinquemani of Slant Magazine called the song as a "soundtrack gem". Author J. Randy Taraborrelli in his biography of Madonna called the song a beautiful one. According to him, "it sounds like a flick theme too, equipped with smart chords and big emotion. It is reminiscent of another movie theme of Madonna's, 'Live to Tell' (1986)." Music critique Peter Buckley noted that the song was atmospheric and one of Madonna's best works, showing her ability to stay in touch with and adapt to musical developments. "I'll Remember" earned nominations for "Best Song Written Specifically for a Motion Picture or for Television" at the 37th Grammy Awards and "Best Original Song" at the 52nd Golden Globe Awards.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Muggwa

Kewl... The only 2 of mine that are gone are Runaway Lover and Lucky Star. (I didn't vote for Sorry, did I?)

I don't know how many of my songs are left though.

You have a few left!

[Icing]

At half of Till Death Do Us Part's points coming from me. Like I said, 50 points well spent.



And it's my first song to go.

[mariska]

Did all of my songs make the list, Madonnas?

[True Skarlet]

Originally posted by ImpressiveInstant

Shut up, I'll Remember Such Slayage is probably in the Top 3 of her ballads. So amazing

Critics agree with me:

Did you not see how I was one of many to give it points!?

I was referring to the fact that you said I had bad taste earlier but I gave points to one of your (and my) favorite Madonna songs.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by mariska

Did all of my songs make the list, Madonnas?

No

[ImpressiveInstant]

Originally posted by True Skarlet

Did you not see how I was one of many to give it points!?

I was referring to the fact that you said I had bad taste earlier but I gave points to one of your (and my) favorite Madonna songs.

Oh. I thought you were referring to madonnas.

Your taste is awesome again then.

[mariska]

Originally posted by madonnas

No

Probably Oh Father and Love Song.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by mariska

Probably Oh Father and Love Song.

Oh Father was #32

[mariska]

Originally posted by madonnas

Oh Father was #32

OH

[Drowned_World]

Only two songs from my list are already out.

[DrownedWorld]

From my list, so far I Deserve It made it in the top 50. I don't think Love Tried To Welcome Me or Wheres The Party will make it. Skin might.

[mariska]

Originally posted by DrownedWorld

From my list, so far I Deserve It made it in the top 50. I don't think Love Tried To Welcome Me or Wheres The Party will make it. Skin might.

I voted for Skin.

[DrownedWorld]

Originally posted by mariska

I voted for Skin.

Good choice.

[Von]

YAS, I voted for Skin too.

[mariska]

I also voted for Drowned World/Substitute for Love and Swim.

Actually, I have three songs from Erotica, three from Ray of Light, 2 from Like a Prayer, 1 from MDNA and 1 from Bedtime Stories.

[ImpressiveInstant]

All my songs made the Top 50

Oh ****, mariska voted for Skin, DrownedWorld did, Von did and probably madonnas did too. I'm not liking this...

[Eric.]

Holiday -
Waiting - Love this.
Lucky Star -
Sorry - A predictable choice, but you can't deny the riff and groove is irresistible.
Die Another Day -
Nothing Really Matters - I'm glad this made the list. The bridge is one of Ray Of Light's finest moments.
Till Death Do Us Part - Cute song, but extremely climatic at the same time.
Where Life Begins - Excellent song. Madonna's voice really fits this jazz/trip-hop fantasy.
Oh Father - Madonna's most beautiful ballad next to "Promise To Try."
I'll Remember - The song might be a bit bland, but there's a hidden energy that makes all the way better. And she sings so beautifully in it.

So far only "White Heat" and "I'll Remember" have made it from my list.

I suppose I was not the only one who voted for "Drowned World".