[Jessie Mulay]

Originally posted by Blatboy

Grace can't be the killer!!! Why yall overlooking her accusing Gigi! Gigi tried to get her dad to commit her to a mental ward!!

We aren't? Grace could have been a devil on her own. After the accusation Gigi could have went to her offscreen and told her everything and recruited her

[jgorny]

I would like to see Christina Ricci join the cast next season. She would be a good addition

[heretoslay]

Originally posted by jgorny

I would like to see Christina Ricci join the cast next season. She would be a good addiction.

Yassssss!!!

AND

omg just rewatched the first episode and it's so obvious lollll it's like right in your face Grace

The excitement when giving motives, the looks that Pete gives her when they're first introduced at the coffee shop. Her hearing the plan to prank Mrs. Bean. Oh yeah and her lying that she was talking to Pete in the Thanksgiving episode when they hadn't even met yet. All the other confounding evidence, her not being around when Deaf taylor swift's head was mowed off, not being attacked by the RD, Boone knowing that Oakland nachos were Zayday's favorite food and asking her if she'd talked to her yet during the Ghost Stories episode. .

[Nasty Nas]

Oh God.
For the last time Pete is the killer.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

For Christ's sake, why are we even arguing about this? The killer is OBVIOUSLY Chanel #2

[Nasty Nas]

Grace has been one of my top suspects for awhile tho. So I wouldn't be upset if she ended up being the killer.

[Nasty Nas]

Originally posted by RudeBoyy

My killer guesses )that I've stuck with for more than 3 seconds anyway) have been

Chanel #3 -Earl - Chanel #3 - Hester - Chanel #5 - Hester

I've said multiple times I wanted Grace to be the killer since it'd be shocking and make her less of a basic Nancy Drew girl next door bitch though so I support that ending tbh. I didn't think it'd actually be a possibility though

Mine has always been:

Wes - Pete - Grace - Earl - Grace - #3 - Pete

[Jessie Mulay]

I've always been Jennifer

[XtinaPanicGodney]

Remember the anagram thing she did for Zayday Williams? She spelled it out as "I may slay Liz Daw", remember?!?

Her real name is Libby Putney. If you anagram that, it's "Tub by Lye Pin"! Don't you see?

Her mother was found dead in the "tub", she was buried "by" her sisters, whom all share a "pin", and when they buried her, probably used "Lye" to decompose the body in the grave!

IMDB needs to stop.

[Nein]

What if the killer is Denise ha self

[$AVE DAT MONEY]

i just realized, and this is most likely a reach but, grace gardener is graces full name. the first letter of her first and last name are g, or GG like Gigi, the original red devil.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

I'm THROUGH with these name hints

[P!nk Forever]

Denise Hemphil herself will expose the last red devil. Mark my words!

[Jessie Mulay]

Originally posted by XtinaPanicGodney

IMDB needs to stop.

What is this mess? How did they make that jump

[Phoenixstar]

I am glad yall are having good time. But lemme reminds you that OP have not been updated for long time

@X/O/X/O you should make the gif of chanel saying "You will not shut me up this time", it would slay, tho

[antoine_]

Originally posted by heretoslay

Yassssss!!!

AND

omg just rewatched the first episode and it's so obvious lollll it's like right in your face Grace

The excitement when giving motives, the looks that Pete gives her when they're first introduced at the coffee shop. Her hearing the plan to prank Mrs. Bean. Oh yeah and her lying that she was talking to Pete in the Thanksgiving episode when they hadn't even met yet. All the other confounding evidence, her not being around when Deaf taylor swift's head was mowed off, not being attacked by the RD, Boone knowing that Oakland nachos were Zayday's favorite food and asking her if she'd talked to her yet during the Ghost Stories episode. .

LOL Obvi not,it just cant be,good points,but no

[genetic fail]

Yall need stop with yalls theories. Each one is dumber than the last

[Pretty Lady]

I'm actually fine with Grace being the Red Devil. Grace's character is so annoying and boring, being the killer would give her character some interest.

[Brunette Ambition]

pretty sure those theories are ironic. like my ''zayday is faking her race and is actualy boones sister'' theory some pages ago

[Shinning]

It's definitely between Grace and Pete
But if it turns out to be Denise