Dessy – This is ugly and Troye looks like a hobbit. Like Troye’s outreach to the gay community, Hillary did it better.
vergeofobscene – I wanted this to work, but, alas, the days where you could succeed with an unflattering picture of a fat woman are long past us. If this was maybe half its size it would work better.
Jackson – Kitt was slaying even as a baby. This also could’ve benefitted from being a little smaller, just crop the part of her carseat at the bottom. While this wasn’t a PNG (because you’re an illiterate loser who didn’t read the challenge!!!), it still works very, very well.
XL – I’m so impressed that Katy was able to overcome her addiction, these pre-rehab photos are a testament to her strength and drive. This isn’t good as a PNG because I’m not sure what it’s expressing. She’s just looking at something.
Rian – The PNG deserved better examples than you gave it, but the fact that the PNG itself was passable puts you ahead of most other entries.
Kitt – I knew DOMINO was skinny but DAMN. This was an ace entry from my favorite elitist, and the examples sealed it. Crown it.
Urban – URBESE is my favorite incarnation of you. I had seen this cat before I read the entries, which is a hallmark of a good, viral ATRL trend. The examples left something to be desired; I think this PNG works best as a singular response to drama as opposed to being accompanied with text
Speezy – Bitch this is a GIF. And an UGLY one, too.
MARN – This is like Dessy’s entry, but less ****able. This read like one of your Webkinz entries, which isn’t good. Also, where were the examples?
Luke – This was good! I liked the usage I saw in RT, and your examples didn’t harm your entry. Keep it up.
Gospel – StonedSoulPicnic gonna drag you for stealing his avi, I assume. This didn’t work too well, though, in concept, I love using an older image. You just didn’t quite pull it off this round.
Legend E – Hm. This could’ve been really great if we had Xtina’s full head cut out as just a PNG of her laughing face. As a close up it looks too much like a troll avatar from a Britney stan, not that the Army wastes their time thinking of someone Britney passed years ago. It must suck to have peaked in 2001 and just spend your days mentoring singers to pass you. That’s sad, huh.
Clueless – Just when I think you’re a one-trick pony, you give me this. This isn’t great because it doesn’t work well with any post. But damn if this don’t show NERVE. I have no idea when or where I would use this, but seeing it each time makes me scream. Not only do I want more of this, I want you to play Drag Race Season 03 and give Tymps a run for his money.
Diarrhoea – This is like a cheaper version of the still-awful Donna PNG that Jackson tried to make popular once. It has limited appeal because BeyRih has a folder of them. Solid example work elevates this entry, though.
Witch – Look at you slaying the second half of the entries! This was one of only four entries that I had seen prior to judging, showing that you picked a good one. Mariah is the shadiest, and this PNG is rough but cut well enough that it doesn’t distract. Ugh, I love this.
