[KK_Lover]

Originally posted by J a y

Gaga is able to do everything Lana can do, and more. That includes play the guitar and many other instruments.

Both can sing, both can act, and both can write and produce. Lana cannot dance. Gaga can, she's not perfect, but she can.

The answer is not worth debating.

Does it really matter for a singer dancing ? for an entertainer for sure but not for a singer

[ElleDriver]

Lana by far. She's effortless and shes a visionary. Gaga is a terrible lyricist and musician.

[SadGirl]

Originally posted by DouglasBooth

well if they can afford it? why not?

as long as they dont buy all of her tour tickets only to have Gaga perfoming in as sold out empty stadium then im okay with it

Can I ask you something honestly? Why do you hate Lana so much? Is it because you never got over So Legit? Does it make you feel better with yourself?

[DouglasBooth]

Originally posted by ItalianAvenger

Does it really matter for a singer dancing ? for an entertainer for sure but not for a singer

Poll: More talented? Lana Del Rey vs Lady Gaga

in this thread? yes

if you want to change the thread to only vocal talent you should make a different one

[Kankuro]

Originally posted by ElleDriver

Lana by far. She's effortless and shes a visionary. Gaga is a terrible lyricist and musician.

Please let's not make like Lana is a great lyricist pleasee.

I'm being serious "soft ice-cream" "dark blue" "red party dress"

I love both but I'm being honest, neither of them are "Great" songwriters

[lickmycody]

Originally posted by J a y

Gaga is able to do everything Lana can do, and more. That includes play the guitar and many other instruments.

Both can sing, both can act, and both can write and produce. Lana cannot dance. Gaga can, she's not perfect, but she can.

The answer is not worth debating.

I do have love for gaga but she just doesn't have emotion in her voice when she sings. It's like she is too busy worrying about what she is singing vs how the lyrics make her feel. That's something you can't buy or teach. That my friends is called soul.

[J a y]

Originally posted by ItalianAvenger

Does it really matter for a singer dancing ? for an entertainer for sure but not for a singer

I think you'll find the question was which artist was more talented, not the most talented singer.

More talented? Lana Del Rey vs Lady Gaga

Furthermore, as you insisted I judge them for singing abilities only (why I have no idea, but let's play it your way):

Vocal Range: B2 - E5 - D6 (Eb6)
Voice Type: Dugazon (3 octaves 1 note and a semi-tone)

Range: F#2 - G5 - C6 (E7)
Vocal Type: Mezzo-Soprano, though Contralto is a common perception. (3 Octaves and 3 notes)

I know I don't need to label which vocal range belongs to which artist because we all have ears.

[KK_Lover]

Originally posted by DouglasBooth

in this thread? yes

if you want to change the thread to only vocal talent you should make a different one

I'm talking for a singer sis singers supposed to sing not to dance!

[DouglasBooth]

Originally posted by SadGirl

Can I ask you something honestly? Why do you hate Lana so much? Is it because you never got over So Legit? Does it make you feel better with yourself?

i don't hate lana. I have all of her albums. i just really dislike how Lana stans make lana to be some sort of Musical Genuis who started the alternative trend + they are the very passive aggresive not only towards Gaga but everybody tbh

[KK_Lover]

Originally posted by J a y

I think you'll find the question was which artist was more talented, not the most talented singer.



Furthermore, as you insisted I judge them for singing abilities only (why I have no idea, but let's play it your way):

Vocal Range: B2 - E5 - D6 (Eb6)
Voice Type: Dugazon (3 octaves 1 note and a semi-tone)

Range: F#2 - G5 - C6 (E7)
Vocal Type: Mezzo-Soprano, though Contralto is a common perception. (3 Octaves and 3 notes)

I know I don't need to label which vocal range belongs to which artist because we all have ears.

LoooL that was just tacky i didn't ask for this!

[SadGirl]

Originally posted by DouglasBooth

i don't hate lana. I have all of her albums. i just really dislike how Lana stans make lana to be some sort of Musical Genuis who started the alternative trend + they are the very passive aggresive not only towards Gaga but everybody tbh

I have to agree with you
Gaga fans' are not much better and you know it

[RyanYuno]

Originally posted by lickmycody

I do have love for gaga but she just doesn't have emotion in her voice when she sings. It's like she is too busy worrying about what she is singing vs how the lyrics make her feel. That's something you can't buy or teach. That my friends is called soul.

Both Lana and Gaga have 'soul'

[Chyene]

I don't believe in ranking talent against talent because it's an argument involving opinions and can't come to a factual conclusion.

[lickmycody]

Originally posted by RyanYuno

Both Lana and Gaga have 'soul'

Not in my opinion. Lady Gaga is so contrived. She's an ESFP.

[DouglasBooth]

Originally posted by ItalianAvenger

I'm talking for a singer sis singers supposed to sing not to dance!

yes, since dancing can convey stronger emotions specially when put altogether. you can search p!nks performances for examples

[KK_Lover]

Originally posted by DouglasBooth

yes, since dancing can convey stronger emotions specially when put altogether. you can search p!nks performances for examples

Thank God Lana doesn't need that

[DouglasBooth]

Originally posted by SadGirl

I have to agree with you
Gaga fans' are not much better and you know it

yeah but monsters have been dragged for it and deservingly so

[Shinning]

Lady Gaga

[DouglasBooth]

Originally posted by ItalianAvenger

Thank God Lana doesn't need that

i disagree but ok!

[Chyene]

Originally posted by ItalianAvenger

Thank God Lana doesn't need that

You need to stop trying to hard to drag Gaga. It's really cringeworthy and I see you do it so often.