[BASS]

Such a big catalog of producers can't wait to hear to album

[Xalric]

Originally posted by *****haus of Gaga

Why would she work with David Guetta just as a composer? I didn't know he was a lyrical genius
It's obvious that he also produced.

When he first started he wrote and or co-wrote his 3 first albums which are way better than One Love & Nothing But The Beats (which he also co wrote a whole bunch of it also).

[toanythingtaboo]

Originally posted by Vanitas

Why are you all having meltdowns for Guetta listed on 1 song. For all we know, he could be listed as a simple cowriter or something

Exactly.

Considering there's Guetta and his frequent collaborator Giorgio Tuinfort on the credits, it's entirely possible that the song features the remnants of another demo or a melody from something they worked with Will.I.Am on.

[Nii.]

Wait what ever happened with her and Fernando Garibay....

[Fanik]

Gaga coming for her own right now slay

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

Why is this reported tho?

[IamCY]

Originally posted by Nii.

Wait what ever happened with her and Fernando Garibay....

You literally just beat me to it. I don't mind producers THAT much because it'll still be her singing/co-producing but I feel like this needs more diversity there's too much DJWS, he's even on the only RedOne track

Will.i.am AND David Guetta on one track? GP friendly bop I guess

[Gui Blackout]

OH?

[giskard]

Gaga always has given her producers part of the songwriting credits as compensation for their work, that is why they get listed as co-writers. Producers do not make royalties from song sales, song writers do. It's a procedural thing. This was confirmed by Garibay years ago as posted by someone else previously. That doesn't mean that Gaga isn't writing nearly 100% of the lyrics.

[ShineOverShadow]

Originally posted by Katy V.!

Guetta and Will.i.am. Kii

Still better than Dr. Luke.

And they're only on 1 song, anyway, not the vast majority of the album. Kii

[nky0411]

Originally posted by IamCY

You literally just beat me to it. I don't mind producers THAT much because it'll still be her singing/co-producing but I feel like this needs more diversity there's too much DJWS, he's even on the only RedOne track

Will.i.am AND David Guetta on one track? GP friendly bop I guess

fernando was on almost every single track of BTW and we know how those songs turned out.
lets hope DJWS gave the magical touch instead of making them overproduced

[Damien M]

Good
He's more talented + has better songs than the lame crew she usually works with etc

[Raiden]

Originally posted by *****haus of Gaga

Why would she work with David Guetta just as a composer?

Exactly.

All this "writer/composer" talk is bull****.

I didn't know he was a lyrical genius
It's obvious that he also produced.

Duh! Obviously it's a co-production.

The big news for me though is the fact that whiteshadow seems to be some sort of overall "master DJ" of the album (silly me - I'd thought that was Zedd).

[IconicFlop]

So. Many. Djws. Produced. Songs.

[ShineOverShadow]

Originally posted by IconicFlop

So. Many. Djws. Produced. Songs.

He only produced like 7 or 8, the rest he only helped write.

[Canonical Ensemble]

I doubt it's a Will & Guetta collab though. Fashion! looks like a multiple-reworked piece of filler.

[IamCY]

Originally posted by nky0411

fernando was on almost every single track of BTW and we know how those songs turned out.
lets hope DJWS gave the magical touch instead of making them overproduced

Yeah, I mean that diversity lessens the chances of hit-or-miss albums even though I personally liked the BTW tracks. TF/M=RedOne, BTW=Garibay, ARTPOP=DJWS

[Poe Dameron]

Originally posted by IconicFlop

So. Many. Djws. Produced. Songs.

DJWS is the most diverse producer Gaga has worked with, you can sit

[GreasyBruce]

Originally posted by giskard

Gaga always has given her producers part of the songwriting credits as compensation for their work, that is why they get listed as co-writers. Producers do not make royalties from song sales, song writers do. It's a procedural thing. This was confirmed by Garibay years ago as posted by someone else previously. That doesn't mean that Gaga isn't writing nearly 100% of the lyrics.

Songwriting doesn't just refer to lyrics. We know Gaga writes her lyrics, what her producers do have a huge hand in writing are the musical elements of the track and anyone who contributes to the melody, harmonies or any part of the instrumental is also a songwriter.

[Retro]

I see people are already overreacting.

Slay them, Gaga!