I don't like her.
I kinda give her props for what she is doing, but she is too fake and too girly for my taste. I think she is also TOO overrated and her costumes are stupid. I don't find her voice special, it is good and that's it. Her music, bleh, I like Government Hooker, Bad Romance (great song), Paparazzi and The Edge Of Glory. Her music videos are awful and boring most of the time. What kind of cheap mess was that Born This Way video? Looking at her at the Fame era and looking at her now is like looking at two different persons. Changed and manufactured for fame. Also I think her fanbase is the worst.
BUT
I give her mad props for treating the fans the way she treats them. I know it means more money for her but I still feel that is one of few genuine parts of her. Also some of her songs have great lyrics (my fav is Judas).
There is my answer.