Exactly. I don't know why they're so offended when I called one of the greatest voice of this generation. I was obviously not denying her talent, but having an amazing voice doesn't make everything you do better automatically. I'm a big fan of a singer in my country and she never had the greatest voice but the woman sang with so many feelings that everybody loves her work til today even though she died in the 60's people still remember her.
but everyone has their opinion remember? for some people it is automatically better if you can actually sing.
No offense, but don't fool yourself into thinking that you have the more "credible" opinion because you prefer Beyonce's version. I never denied that that Beyonce is a better vocalist but I prefer Britney's style IN THIS INSTANCE.
Even at the time critics liked it
Exmp 1
Quote:
Originally posted by Entertainment Weekly
it seems she actually sang live, instead of singing to tape. Again, the quality here isn’t great, but it looks like she rocked it. What better way to silence the critics than to step up to the mic, say to hell with it all, and spew some of that bile. Hot, confident Britney, live vocals, a dash of rebellion…hey Brit, how about breaking off for a few surprise shows at intimate clubs? I’d be down for that.
and said Britney should sing more and a lot of Alanis's fans liked it as well
But there is a difference between: l like Britney's version better
&
Britney version is better by far
Dont you think??
When bey stans say they like beyonce's version of 'still in love kissin you better' than Des'ree,the same people say we think B is better than everybody.
Which one did it better for you?
That means is a personal opinion!! you guys should learn to tolerate because we all have the right to chose different things. There's no correct answer in this thread and you guys are acting like it does. Y'all are the only ones complaining because someone doesn't pick yall fave.
But there is a difference between: l like Britney's version better
&
Britney version is better by far
Dont you think??
When bey stans say they like beyonce's version of 'still in love kissin you better' than Des'ree,the same people say we think B is better than everybody.
well I agree with you there is a difference... But i guess there's nothing we can do with any stans saying that.
[QUOTE=Kisuke;7951765]Are you really attempting to shade Beyonce her vocal ability [/QUOTE
i know tht u all think tht she's sum kind of vocal god but in this case her vocals were way over the top...shouthin n screamin to no ends...just my humble opinion....
I remember when I heard it I thought she was singing it to KFed lol
