I've listened to the album four times today, and I believe that I finally have my final ratings:
1. "Marry the Night" -
10/10
2. "Born This Way" - 3/10
3. "Government Hooker" - 9/10
4. "Judas" - 8/10 - it's been alternating between 7 and 8 but I'll be generous
5. "Americano" - 7/10
6. "Hair" - 9/10
7. "Scheisse" -
10/10
8. "Bloody Mary" - 8/10
9. "Bad Kids" - 6/10
10. "Highway Unicorn (Road to Love)" - 9/10
11. "Heavy Metal Lover" -
10/10
12. "Electric Chapel" - 9/10
13. "You and I" - 4/10
14. "The Edge of Glory" - 9/10
Overall: 8/10 (about)
It's a good album, yes, but did it come anywhere near delivering on its hype and anticipation? Absolutely not.