[@michael]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

After Take It Off's ends.

I think you're really going to appreciate my graphics

[genetic fail]

What do you guys think of a Disney Damsels Rate?

When the Sun Goes Down v. Unbroken v. Can't Be Tamed (her next album)

whaddaya think?

[Nait Phoenix]

Originally posted by genetic fail

What do you guys think of a Disney Damsels Rate?

When the Sun Goes Down v. Unbroken v. Can't Be Tamed (her next album)

whaddaya think?

add "This Is My Time" and "Dignity" to make it complete...

[supaspaz]

What about a clash between the biggest and best from this decade's urban R&B girls? Maybe Aaliyah vs. Afrodisiac vs. Ciara: The Evolution?

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by supaspaz

What about a clash between the biggest and best from this decade's urban R&B girls? Maybe Aaliyah vs. Afrodisiac vs. Ciara: The Evolution?

I was about to get my Aaliyah stanning out of the closet and say ... I don't like her being sullied by/them. And I love those two!

How about a The Boy is Mine/Never Say Never/One in a Million rate?

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

I was about to get my Aaliyah stanning out of the closet and say ... I don't like her being sullied by/them. And I love those two!

How about a The Boy is Mine/Never Say Never/One in a Million rate?

Well, Aaliyah and Afrodisiac are probably two of my favorite albums from the last decade, so I kind of wanted to get more people listening to them. (I find it so sad that most of this forum doesn't realize that Aaliyah and Brandy once had great recording careers.) I figured throwing Ciara in there was a good way to ensure a bit more interest from the general ATRL population.

We could do it '90s style, but I have a feeling it would struggle harder than Venus' rate is right now.

[Venus]

The X Factor - Rebecca Ferguson vs. Diana Vickers vs. Cher Lloyd.

[Nait Phoenix]

This just came to me.

Sibling Sophomores - Ashlee Simpson (I Am Me) vs. Solange (Sol-Angel and the Hadley Street Dreams) vs. Ray J (Raydiation) vs. Nick Jonas and the Administration (Who I Am)

I know we're (I'm) swarming you with all these suggestions, but they're just suggestions. I just want you to think about it.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Nait Phoenix

Sibling Sophomores - Ashlee Simpson (I Am Me) vs. Solange (Sol-Angel and the Hadley Street Dreams) vs. Ray J (Raydiation) vs. Nick Jonas and the Administration (Who I Am)

Who would willingly put themselves through that?

[Nait Phoenix]

Originally posted by supaspaz

Who would willingly put themselves through that?

I can't say much about NJ, but the other three are amazing albums...

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Nait Phoenix

This just came to me.

Sibling Sophomores - Ashlee Simpson (I Am Me) vs. Solange (Sol-Angel and the Hadley Street Dreams) vs. Ray J (Raydiation) vs. Nick Jonas and the Administration (Who I Am)

I know we're (I'm) swarming you with all these suggestions, but they're just suggestions. I just want you to think about it.

I've actually heard two of those albums!

@michael - I think I'm going to take the 2010 Mega Rate Fall Edition and add Body Talk.

Picture it.

Body Talk. Cannibal. Speak Now. Pink Friday.

Yes. YES. YES?

[waryofothers]

Wait, how does this work? I'm kind of interested.

[@michael]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

I've actually heard two of those albums!

@michael - I think I'm going to take the 2010 Mega Rate Fall Edition and add Body Talk.

Picture it.

Body Talk. Cannibal. Speak Now. Pink Friday.

Yes. YES. YES?

YES.

So much variety in this rate, but still all-pop. We have hipster pop, commercial pop, country pop, rap pop. Brilliant!

And you're hosting it?

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by @michael.

YES.

So much variety in this rate, but still all-pop. We have hipster pop, commercial pop, country pop, rap pop. Brilliant!

And you're hosting it?

Yes.

Going into the new year, we're also going to start artist rates.

Which artists should go first?

[@michael]

What's that, where we rate an artist's entire discography?

Let's start with a bang and do Madge? The girls need an education on her music, with her new album coming out so soon.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by @michael.

What's that, where we rate an artist's entire discography?

Let's start with a bang and do Madge? The girls need an education on her music, with her new album coming out so soon.

You know these girls can't handle album tracks.

SINGLES. We'll be rating artists singles, unless they've only released two or three albums.

[@michael]

Still, Madge is the first option

Then Whitney or something.

I need people to respect our HISTORY. But nobody is here for anything before 1998. Example Number One.

[genetic fail]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Yes.

Going into the new year, we're also going to start artist rates.

Which artists should go first?

The ones with the most.

Britney, Rihanna & Beyonce.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by @michael.

Still, Madge is the first option

Then Whitney or something.

I need people to respect our HISTORY. But nobody is here for anything before 1998. Example Number One.

I think asking people for albums has proven to be too much, especially as most of these kids haven't downloaded Spotify yet.

Originally posted by genetic fail

The ones with the most.

Britney, Rihanna & Beyonce.

I do think that many of the old girls - Madonna, Mariah, Janet, Kylie - would do well with singles rates.

Whitney would not. She's not talked about here.

[@michael]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

I think asking people for albums has proven to be too much, especially as most of these kids haven't downloaded Spotify yet.

I even put youtube links!! And the albums are two hours COMBINED. This is a simple task. I blame Cyndi.