[conatus]

Originally posted by Vilppu

Hard Candy - 2.71

I endorse this.

[Subomie]

ew you guys dont understand the concept of fun

[HonourableVomit]

Originally posted by tylerlscwv

You now have exactly 1 month to complete your rates.

Your preview bit for today: only 3 songs currently have averages of 9 or above (1 from Bedtime Stories, 1 from Ray of Light, and 1 from MDNA)

Love Spent or Gang Bang for sure.

MDNSLAY is coming like Light Years came for the Kylie rate.

Originally posted by Vilppu

Hard Candy - 2.71

Brutal. Lemme do my avgs.

[Petty Bourgeoisie]

Sent.

[HonourableVomit]

WOW, my averages really surprised me. Maybe I was a bit too harsh on our good sis.

Madonna - 5.7
Virgin - 6.5
True Blue - 3.2 omg
Prayer - 5.8
Breathless - 4.7
Erotica - 6.4
Stories - 6.9
Ray - 6.3 (This is shocking, my fave album! I don't like the unreleased though)
Music - 5.8
Life - 6.1
Confessions - 6.6
Candy - 4.8
MDNA - 6.4 (It beat Ray Of Light I'm cackling)
Rebel - 6.1


Which would suggest that my favourite albums (plus unreleased, sans singles obviously) would be:

1. Bedtime Stories (I like it, but not best)
2. Confessions (Yes it is my second favourite)
3. Like A Virgin (goodBYE)
4. MDNA / Erotica (they are not on the same level, sorry MDNAged)
5. Ray Of Light ( )

[Eeveelution]

Wow, Bedtime Stories really is her most consistent album. Consistently mediocre.

[enxe]

I'm going to start working on this soon!

[Sanctuary]

Breathless is such a pointless album.

At least it gave us Vogue and Something To Remember. For that reason I can't bring myself to drag it.

[Subomie]

Originally posted by Eeveelution

Wow, Bedtime Stories really is her most consistent album. Consistently mediocre.

do you like any of her albums

[Eeveelution]

Originally posted by Subomie

do you like any of her albums

No

[Subomie]

me neither

[That Bad Eartha]

Originally posted by Eeveelution

Wow, Bedtime Stories really is her most consistent album. Consistently mediocre.

Ima try to be a quasi-neutral host, but I do not tolerate Bedtime Stories shade

[That Bad Eartha]

While you are working on your rates (or if you feel so compelled if you are already finished with them), I'd love it if people would send in commentary for some songs. Obviously I'll do commentary for every song, but I think it would be fun if people with really passionate opinions to be included to. So do it if you have a lot to say, pick tracks that you passionately love or hate. Then I'll include your drags/praises with that track during the reveal once that starts up in October.


Also, this time next week I'll probably start sending out PM reminders to people who said they would complete the rate.

[Humoresque]

Good idea, I'll send some in this week.

[Phunk]

I'll for sure do this.

[Vilppu]

I'll work on some commentary but I think I'll do it only for my 0/1s and 11/10s.

[That Bad Eartha]

Originally posted by Vilppu

I'll work on some commentary but I think I'll do it only for my 0/1s and 11/10s.

That is pretty much what I was thinking people could do. I want people to focus on really spilling the tea on their faves/least faves. I don't need a bunch of comments of "meh" for their 5s/6s .

[HonourableVomit]

I can't wait to see the comments and 0s on I'm Going Bananas.

[That Bad Eartha]

Originally posted by HonourableVomit

I can't wait to see the comments and 0s on I'm Going Bananas.

You might be surprised, that song currently has 5 ratings of 5 or above....

[HonourableVomit]

Originally posted by tylerlscwv

You might be surprised, that song currently has 5 ratings of 5 or above....

How.

Like... How I bet B'Day Song will get dragged harder than it and that's not right.