[Penny.]

4

[Alchemist]

1+1
I Care
Drunk in Love
BTINH
No Angel
Partition
Start Over
Rocket
Countdown
EOT
Flawless
RTW
Heaven
Schoolin Life
DFY

4 wins

[c0caine]

1 + 1 vs Pretty Hurts
I Care vs Haunted
I Miss You vs Drunk In Love
Best Thing I Never Had vs Blow
Party vs No Angel
Rather Die Young vs Partition
Start Over vs Jealous
Love on Top vs Rocket
Countdown vs Mine
End of Time vs XO
I Was Here vs Flawless
Run the World (Girls) vs Superpower
Lay Up Under Me vs Heaven
Schoolin' Life vs Blue
Dance for You vs Grown Woman

BEYONCÉ - 9
4 - 1
Tie - 5

[popstar]

1 + 1 vs Pretty Hurts
I Care vs Haunted
I Miss You vs Drunk In Love
Best Thing I Never Had vs Blow
Party vs No Angel
Rather Die Young vs Partition
Start Over vs Jealous
Love on Top vs Rocket
Countdown vs Mine
End of Time vs XO
I Was Here vs Flawless
Run the World (Girls) vs Superpower
Lay Up Under Me vs Heaven
Schoolin' Life vs Blue
Dance for You vs Grown Woman


11/4

4 Wins.

[skwonderfactory]

BEYONCÉ

[Blueberry Mary]

1 + 1 vs Pretty Hurts
I Care vs Haunted
I Miss You vs Drunk In Love
Best Thing I Never Had vs Blow
Party vs No Angel
Rather Die Young vs Partition
Start Over vs Jealous
Love on Top vs Rocket
Countdown vs Mine
End of Time vs XO
I Was Here vs Flawless
Run the World (Girls) vs Superpower
Lay Up Under Me vs Heaven
Schoolin' Life vs Blue
Dance for You vs Grown Woman

5 v 10

s/t obv wins

[Cain]

1 + 1 vs Pretty Hurts
I Care vs Haunted
I Miss You vs Drunk In Love
Best Thing I Never Had vs Blow
Party vs No Angel
Rather Die Young vs Partition
Start Over vs Jealous
Love on Top vs Rocket
Countdown vs Mine
End of Time vs XO
I Was Here vs Flawless
Run the World (Girls) vs Superpower
Lay Up Under Me vs Heaven
Schoolin' Life vs Blue
Dance for You vs Grown Woman

9 vs 10, oop.
Close call, both are her best albums.

[SIMon1120]

Beyonce

[Homebrand]

1 + 1 vs Pretty Hurts
I Care vs Haunted
I Miss You vs Drunk In Love
Best Thing I Never Had vs Blow
Party vs No Angel
Rather Die Young vs Partition
Start Over vs Jealous
Love on Top vs Rocket
Countdown vs Mine
End of Time vs XO
I Was Here vs Flawless
Run the World (Girls) vs Superpower
Lay Up Under Me vs Heaven
Schoolin' Life vs Blue
Dance for You vs Grown Woman

4: 8
Beyonce: 7

[Brooke-lynn]

1 + 1 vs Pretty Hurts
I Care vs Haunted
I Miss You vs Drunk In Love
Best Thing I Never Had vs Blow
Party vs No Angel
Rather Die Young vs Partition
Start Over vs Jealous
Love on Top vs Rocket
Countdown vs Mine
End of Time vs XO
I Was Here vs Flawless
Run the World (Girls) vs Superpower
Lay Up Under Me vs Heaven
Schoolin' Life vs Blue
Dance for You vs Grown Woman


BEYONCÉ - 11
4 - 8
Tie - 4

[gloamingtheplain]

4, easily.
4 is such a Beyonce record from start to finish, and is easily more enjoyable to listen too. It's also more cohesive in sound as a whole.

ST is a great album, but I often feel like she's been heavily influenced by the people she's worked with, and each producer had no idea what the album was supposed to be as a whole, and you can easily hear the shift from producer from track to track, rather than it flow nicely and you can hear the overall vision for the album.
The only vision for the album is that Beyonce had idea's for the videos, rather than an idea for the entire record.

[MusicTalker]

1 + 1 vs Pretty Hurts
I Care vs Haunted
I Miss You vs Drunk In Love
Best Thing I Never Had vs Blow
Party vs No Angel
Rather Die Young vs Partition
Start Over vs Jealous
Love on Top vs Rocket
Countdown vs Mine
End of Time vs XO
I Was Here vs Flawless
Run the World (Girls) vs Superpower
Lay Up Under Me vs Heaven
Schoolin' Life vs Blue
Dance for You vs Grown Woman

[Simplyvirtue]

Self-Titled is definitely the superior album! 4 is horrible!!!

[BTrisc]

Self Titled is overrated and mostly a snoozefest. If you could merge the best moments from both records, you'd have one hell of an album.

[Unusualyou]

1+1
Haunted
drunk in love
blow
party
partition
Start over
love on top
countdown
Xo
flawless
run the world
heaven
schoolin life
dance for you

4

[LoveMe4Me]

1 + 1 vs Pretty Hurts
I Care vs Haunted
I Miss You vs Drunk In Love
Best Thing I Never Had vs Blow
Party vs No Angel
Rather Die Young vs Partition
Start Over vs Jealous
Love on Top vs Rocket
Countdown vs Mine
End of Time vs XO
I Was Here vs Flawless
Run the World (Girls) vs Superpower
Lay Up Under Me vs Heaven
Schoolin' Life vs Blue
Dance for You vs Grown Woman


4: 7
BEYONCÉ: 7
Tie: 1

I like BEYONCÉ as a better overall album tho.

[Bounce]

1 + 1 vs Pretty Hurts
I Care vs Haunted
I Miss You vs Drunk In Love
Best Thing I Never Had vs Blow
Party vs No Angel
Rather Die Young vs Partition
Start Over vs Jealous
Love on Top vs Rocket
Countdown vs Mine
End of Time vs XO
I Was Here vs Flawless
Run the World (Girls) vs Superpower
Lay Up Under Me vs Heaven
Schoolin' Life vs Blue
Dance for You vs Grown Woman

Tie but I like BEYONCÉ overall

[RideOrDie]

1 + 1 vs Pretty Hurts
I Care vs Haunted
I Miss You vs Drunk In Love
Best Thing I Never Had vs Blow
Party vs No Angel
Rather Die Young vs Partition
Start Over vs Jealous
Love on Top vs Rocket
Countdown vs Mine
End of Time vs XO
I Was Here vs Flawless I CAN'T.
Run the World (Girls) vs Superpower
Lay Up Under Me vs Heaven
Schoolin' Life vs Blue
Dance for You vs Grown Woman

Six 4, eight BEYONCÉ.

[SpaceOddity]

1 + 1 vs Pretty Hurts
I Care vs Haunted
I Miss You vs Drunk In Love
Best Thing I Never Had vs Blow
Party vs No Angel
Rather Die Young vs Partition
Start Over vs Jealous
Love on Top vs Rocket
Countdown vs Mine
End of Time vs XO
I Was Here vs Flawless
Run the World (Girls) vs Superpower
Lay Up Under Me vs Heaven
Schoolin' Life vs Blue
Dance for You vs Grown Woman

[Playa Playa]

1 + 1 vs Pretty Hurts
I Care vs Haunted
I Miss You vs Drunk In Love
Best Thing I Never Had vs Blow
Party vs No Angel
Rather Die Young vs Partition
Start Over vs Jealous
Love on Top vs Rocket
Countdown vs Mine
End of Time vs XO
I Was Here vs Flawless
Run the World (Girls) vs Superpower
Lay Up Under Me vs Heaven
Schoolin' Life vs Blue
Dance for You vs Grown Woman

9 for BEYONCE, 6 for 4