[QueenBLadyG]

Originally posted by Vin

What about Mariah Carey?



...Vin

True. Don't forget Mimi!

[UnusualBoy]

Originally posted by okiam

Britney Stans are always trying to find some way to beat other stan bases down. Get a life really.

Go watch XFactor where your fave is an employee

It clearly seems that you don't know the Beyhive and the Monsters, so sit!

[Deemy]

Originally posted by okiam

He did not say that Rihanna is NOT BLACK he said that She is not the first black anything.

Which is true.

Deuces said she isnt Black.

Black Power said she doesnt defy "black female artist". I mean not to toot a bitch;s horns but who's THE BIGGEST BLACK musician currently? ok.

[Kang.]

I changed my mind. There ARE Beyoncé stans who make everything about race too often.

[Callisto.]

Excuse me but are yall not the same people
Who bring up Beyonces race everyday?
Calling her a white woman & says she bleaches her skin
Because she hates being black?
Save that "Oh NIE they cry black too much"
Not when yall are crying white.

[G4L]

Originally posted by BnPac

Right they can't mention that because she rarely even achieves something another black woman hasn't. Don't they remember the multiple threads about her being the first black female singer to sing at the country awards? The fact they even have the nerve to step here is mind blowing.

The whole point being that you guys do it all the time lol. We did it that one time because it's significant, since most country artists are white so for her to be featured there is significant.

[BadBitch]

Originally posted by Deemy

So Rihanna's not black because she isnt American? Im from the Caribbean just like her. We might be a mixed race but we are all classified Black.

!!!!!
The ignorance.

[zombaland]

Originally posted by Deuces.

Well Rihanna isn't black so she has no struggles.

asdfg uhhhh killing me in here.


YOU SERIOUS?

[Midnight]

Please don't lump us all together. Generalizations are just plain wrong...

[KB.]

Originally posted by okiam

He did not say that Rihanna is NOT BLACK he said that She is not the first black anything.

Which is true.

She's the first black Madonna.

[CaptainMusic]

Originally posted by Mr Telephone Man

Britney stans racist?

Completely overlooking the fact that a good number of them on ATRL are minorities themselves, myself included. Just because you don't agree with pulling the race card, doesn't mean you aren't a minority yourself.

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



And DEATH @ these people tryna say Rihanna's not black.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by CaptainMusic

Let me just clarify this once again, i'm not trying to diminish all of her achievements where race is concerned (like her being the first black person to headline Glastonbury - that's impressive) but there are limits........

How are you not responding to the legitimate replies people like Satellites are putting forth?

[okiam]

Originally posted by chanel

Oh the ignorance. MJ was nothing but black ALL THEOUGHTOUT his career. When he was breaking down barriers he was still brown skinned because his vitiligo hadn't taken over yet

Honey, save it. I have vitiligo. If you think that it's the real reason Michael Jackson turned ghost white then your response is invalid.

[KliFF]

Originally posted by okiam

He did not say that Rihanna is NOT BLACK he said that She is not the first black anything.

Which is true.

But she is

Rihanna holds a ton of records. People just don't mention she's the first black female to do so. I personally do not know about the Beyhive, so I don't really care, but to say she is just following in other peoples footsteps and not breaking records is a lie.

[chanel]

Originally posted by KΔΥ.ΒΣΣ

I'm saying though does it have more to do with race or the fact that blacks generally make music that's more accessible to the black race?

Sound is a factor. But ask yourself, why are black artist boxed into the R&B genre???
That alone has to do with race.

[rocketinthesky]

Currently browsing: 62 members (‎rocketinthesky, ‎Rated R, ‎zombaland, ‎Ace Reject, ‎fortheloveofmusic, ‎Mr Telephone Man, ‎Midnight, ‎Deemy, ‎CaptainMusic, ‎Mr. Yoso, ‎HaHa2011, ‎QueenBLadyG, ‎The Ri-son!, ‎Willy., ‎castrobabytiger, ‎dman4life, ‎okiam, ‎Monceau, ‎chanel, ‎KliFF, ‎TheRealKii, ‎Blur, ‎hmellmell, ‎SarahWalker, ‎Travis Bickle, ‎RoryBaby, ‎Underdogs, ‎Praise Mariallah, ‎Poisonous, ‎itsrooben, ‎Lasers, ‎ElevateHigher), 39 guests.

This thread has been reported to the ATRL moderators. If it is found to be inaccurate, fake, already posted, off topic, or hateful, then it will be closed.

[primo.]

Originally posted by KΔΥ.ΒΣΣ

She's the first black Madonna.

!!!

I don't know why they keep forgetting that.

[MrBeyonceFan]

Originally posted by iBeyoncé.

Excuse me but are yall not the same people
Who bring up Beyonces race everyday?
Calling her a white woman & says she bleaches her skin
Because she hates being black?
Save that "Oh NIE they cry black too much"
Not when yall are crying white.

Get They ass Together.

[BLaCKPoWeR]

Originally posted by Deemy

Deuces said she isnt Black.

Black Power said she doesnt defy "black female artist". I mean not to toot a bitch;s horns but who's THE BIGGEST BLACK musician currently? ok.

Rihanna's success is totally irrelevant. That doesn't mean anything.

[QueenBLadyG]

Originally posted by Mr Telephone Man

Britney stans racist?

Completely overlooking the fact that a good number of them on ATRL are minorities themselves, myself included. Just because you don't agree with pulling the race card, doesn't mean you aren't a minority yourself.

This doesn't make sense since minorities are racist towards each other ALL THE TIME... wth....