[TheEdgeOfGaga]

Originally posted by fridayteenage

My friend's friend was on the Lizzie McGuire Show and said she was a cold, unpleasant diva. I'm not particularly mad at her, but still.

when she was...what 15? if this story is to be believed.

[private radio]

Originally posted by Golden

ahhhhhhh my 'friend's friend' stories flkfjfkfl;;;

[BeBeMint]

Originally posted by pika

There's a huge cloud of nostalgia blocking everyone's judgement since she was a 'Disney Queen' and all that junk. They have to pay back all those writers on her album (seeing as she wrote less than 40%), producers, her live performances, sending her songs for adds, music videos, etc. not to mention a chunk of the $$$ they made in these sales goes to the distributors.

Basically the consensus is, "She flopped, but hey, she didn't flop as hard we thought." What a way to be congratulated.

Wow Hilary has you pressed I dont even like the girl but she hasn't released music in 8 years and none of her singles have had more than 5 mil AI on radio this era. That looks like Selena Gomez in your avi, and Hilarys album is outselling For You's debut week and Selena had a huge radio single.

[OnlyManInTheWorld]

This is sad, deep inside i knew she would not do more but i really wanted her to pull 50k

[Golden]

Originally posted by Artemisia

What does that have to do with Pika's argument? We know the Hilary stans were conservative with their estimations, but that doesn't change the fact that this is quite a poor showing for her.

It has everything to do with his argument because he's trying to make it seem as if we were expecting her to open with Taylor Swift numbers. He's also insinuating that RCA Records assumed she would be able to sell big first week and have smash hit singles when that was obviously never the case.

Mind you that she's selling boxsets that cost over 50$. RCA Records IS making money off her, no matter y'all trying to twist and turn that fact.

[GrownBoy92]

Originally posted by Grumpy Gills

Why can't y'all just leave the tinder queen alone it's not like she did Nelly F numbers. Hell she didn't even do ciara numbers

how much did Nelly F and Ciara sell?

[Azealia Banks]

The numbers are good for her lol

[eduardolevit]

Hilary is gonna sell more. Michael and Kelly is airing tomorrow and The View is happening this Friday. Great numbers after taking a break for 8 years and not succeeding with 3 singles.

[NewRihannaStan]

I don't know why we are surprised . Although it's funny she is doing the same numbers as Jason Derulo and he had a smash hit and Hilary doesn't

[private radio]

Haters are so transparent. A few months ago according to them she's lucky to hit 20k because her singles are flops, AND NOW she did, she had 3 singles and had several performances so to them it's = big promo.

[BlooRiverAnimal]

Originally posted by NewRihannaStan

I don't know why we are surprised . Although it's funny she is doing the same numbers as Jason Derulo and he had a smash hit and Hilary doesn't

Ki.

Lemme steal this & drag Sinister, his fave.

[Retro]

Taylor probably #2 again.

[CannibalMonster]

@ some people dragging Hilary. Those numbers a perfectly fine. Y'all acting like she was supposed to sell over 100k

[Phil]

What, Adam will sell more than Hilary?
Based on the itunes positions, I wasn't exepcting that at all!

[Attitude]

I predicted Ciara numbers so this is amazing.

[musicfan09]

Hilary's numbers

She couldn't even get #1

[Attitude]

Originally posted by GrownBoy92

how much did Nelly F and Ciara sell?

Nelly did like 7 k and Ci did 19k I believe.

[4seldemari]

Originally posted by BeBeMint

Wow Hilary has you pressed I dont even like the girl but she hasn't released music in 8 years and none of her singles have had more than 5 mil AI on radio this era. That looks like Selena Gomez in your avi, and Hilarys album is outselling For You's debut week and Selena had a huge radio single.

I honestly expected higher for Hilary just because she was an album seller (around 60-70k)

For You opened with 38k SPS its debut week by the way.

[private radio]

Originally posted by PhoebeBuffay

Geez, Kelly and Michael and The View havent even aired yet, as if small radio stations interviews makes ppl buy albums, her video on Target didn't went viral or smt so you tried

These trolls acting like these morning shows are award shows & that Target video is a legitimate promo.

Of course I wanted Hilary to do better, and sell more than Adam , but Adam has been active, been promoting, and had pre-orders. Some people don't even think Hilary Duff is still making music. This is common sense.

[Grumpy Gills]

Originally posted by GrownBoy92

how much did Nelly F and Ciara sell?

Nelly did 6k and Cici did 19k