[conatus]

Originally posted by Bloomers

I was planning on not being so nice to a couple of those, especially Irreplaceable, that song needs to be tossed in a garbage can to the left.

Originally posted by Truth Teller

Rooting for Irreplaceable to absolutely flop. If it wasn't for Bey's vocals (and the video), it'd be just another indistinguishable piece of radio friendly r&b of the Ne-Yo mini era.

This rate bringing us all together like this.

[Tom Vercetti]

Irreplaceable, Halo, Best Thing I never Had. All gross lol.

[holocene]

Crazy in Love - no
Drunk in Love - meh
End of Time
Countdown
Partition
Love on Top - meh
***Flawless
Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It) - Lol!
XO
Irreplaceable - absolutely not

[Doogle]

Irreplaceable is a cute song and reminds me of happy memories of almost 10 (?!) years ago, but yeah it's bad by her standards.

I won't be giving it a high score given that the scoring is based on Beyoncé only and she has much better.

[Robyn]

Me Myself & I or Upgrade U should win

but are all of those really singles?

whew lord

[conatus]

I pity those who don't lose their **** over Diva.

I know you read the paper,
The one that they call a queen!
Every radio round the world know me 'cause that's where I be!



Poor ***Flawless.

[Truth Teller]

Um, y'all are starting to do too much on Best Minor Hit I Never Had.

"I bet it sucks to be you right now" and Babyface's genius arrangement >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

And yeah, it's obviously not a 10, but it's not a 0 either

[BnPac]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

I don't think ANYONE on ATRL underrates it. Should have led the album, and I fully expect it in the top five.

In fact, I think the top ten will be:

Crazy in Love
Drunk in Love
End of Time
Countdown
Partition
Love on Top
***Flawless
Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)
XO
Irreplaceable

Wooo. I guess I owe it to 1+1 and M,M&I to at least try to push them top 10.

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by Truth Teller

Ryan Tedder was actually right when he said XO would be better than Halo.

A shame he kinda got dragged for it when XO underperformed

!
And not here for everyone hating on the ballads. Seems like I know where to give my 10+ scores to.

[Soda Pop Queen]

Sent mine.

[conatus]

Best Thing I Always Skip can make itself comfortable in the bottom 10 thank you very much.

[Tom Vercetti]

Originally posted by Robyn

Me Myself & I or Upgrade U should win

but are all of those really singles?

whew lord

I'm giving Upgrade U a little boost tbh. That along with Deja Vu are the best from B'day.

[Soda Pop Queen]

Originally posted by conatus

Best Thing I Always Skip can make itself comfortable in the bottom 10 thank you very much.

[Doogle]

Originally posted by conatus

I pity those who don't lose their **** over Diva.

I know you read the paper,
The one that they call a queen!
Every radio round the world know me 'cause that's where I be!



Poor ***Flawless.

Diva is so tame, it's very of its time. Flawless is her in full king of the illuminati mind-controlling a generation of teenagers stage. It's just more POWERFUL.

Originally posted by Truth Teller

Um, y'all are starting to do too much on Best Minor Hit I Never Had.

"I bet it sucks to be you right now" and Babyface's genius arrangement >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

And yeah, it's obviously not a 10, but it's not a 0 either

I agree, it's not horrendous. It's a mediocre song with a couple nice parts.

[conatus]

Put It In A Love Song is an actual thing that happened and it pains me.

[Vilppu]

Omg, I totally forgot about it, I have to give it more than a 0 just for it giving me a kii

[Doogle]

Just Stand Up is a 10

[conatus]

Originally posted by Doogle

Just Stand Up is a 10

At least!

[Truth Teller]

Originally posted by Doogle

Just Stand Up is a 10

Are you using a 1-1000 scale?

[Doogle]

Originally posted by conatus

At least!

It's worth giving a 10 for the gif worthy content in the video alone, but the final chorus when they all go OFF is just a highlight of the discography's of every girl on the song.

Also our only Bey/Rih collab.