[.aR]

If you're not gonna include DC sales at least don't count the albums before 2003 for Xtina....


why?

1) It's unfair because Bey has only started going solo at 2003.
2) Album sales were much larger back then.

[Being Human]

Album sales

Beyonce @28 M (without sountracks albums)
Christina @46 M

May be.. but i dont think so.. coz' album sales too low nowadays..

[KKCuteCat]

So Christina's Chrismas album sold 6 million ?

[Alexz]

Originally posted by -Alfie-

Start them all with DIL, In The Zone and Stripped, if not then include Beyonce's DC sales too.

Um, why?

[slw84]

Originally posted by Alexz

Um, why?

So that the clear winner is ranked lower.

[MrDeeds]

Close this thread and ban the OP for those inflated numbers

[slw84]

Originally posted by .aR

If you're not gonna include DC sales at least don't count the albums before 2003 for Xtina....


why?

1) It's unfair because Bey has only started going solo at 2003.
2) Album sales were much larger back then.

But the post is asking if beyonce will ever sell more albums than Christina...not that I believe the sales are legit accurate but the answer clearly is now...they have both surpassed their commercial peak...now its about selling solid sales.
I mean ppl compare Janet, whitney and madonna sales all.the time and they didn't start the same year.

[jose168]

Originally posted by .aR

If you're not gonna include DC sales at least don't count the albums before 2003 for Xtina....


why?

1) It's unfair because Bey has only started going solo at 2003.
2) Album sales were much larger back then.

lmfao how does that make sense. so beyonce is a better album seller than madonna because you shouldnt count pre-2003 sales??

[slw84]

Originally posted by -Alfie-

Not as a songwriter, producer and performer and recording artist which she is credited in all. They didn't specify that in the OP.

Hahaha...this is so hilarious.

[slw84]

Yass Jose168...you betta spill that logic...

[slw84]

Originally posted by Monroe

That's a dumb comment to make. Ignoring the fact that Britney has outsold her and cherry picking which years to use is weak. You can't choose which years to count, and which years don't during comparisons like this.

Exactly...she might as well compare album sales from Janet, madonna and Celine post 2003 only to get sole gratification.
The industry looks at your body of work. Which is why madonna opened the grammys when mariah had that comeback year.

[slw84]

Originally posted by Guernica

According to Christina's own record label RCA Christina Aguilera has sold 17.2 million worldwide and I will take that over your "sources". Have a seat and write them a letter if you don't like it.

Record labels have inflated beyonce (140m solo.records kii), riri, MJ (claimed over 500m for marketing purposes

[Rolland]

Never, not happening.

RCA: She (Xtina) has sold over 46 million albums worldwide.

Source.

[slw84]

Bey,knight
Bey is the female artist of the decade for radio and album sales when you take away radio play on pop Rhy urban ac she ranks lower and she is the most certified because her record label is on it when it comes to that...which they should be.
The album seller of 2010s are eminem overall and Britney for the females

[hector.adriel]

I can't at the inflated numbers.

[slw84]

Why are ppl shading Britney and xtina for strong sales (14m and 8m, respectively)...it is automatic when you had Jessica Simpson selling 2m, mandy Moore only going platinum pink going 2x platinum...timing alone doesn't guarantee huge success.that they both had. Even dc3 went 8x platinum...a huge accomplishment.

[Yooorsh]

Originally posted by Rolland

Never, not happening.

Source.

Clock them, sis!!

[Beyond The Fierce]

Christina's figure is so inflated. Mess.

Yes, they're only about 9 million off each other.

[Rolland]

Originally posted by Beyond The Fierce

Christina's figure is so inflated. Mess.

Yes, they're only about 9 million off each other.

They are inflated for both.
And Beyoncé's sales are not 9 million off Xtina's sales.

[Marq]

They'll both end up very close.