| |
Discussion: The Winner Is... | Marina Discography Rate (p. 152)
Member Since: 8/27/2011
Posts: 13,026
|
This rate is a mess and a half already.
ATRL can't do anything right.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/31/2013
Posts: 12,948
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
Not one of the best on the album  there are 10 other songs that deserved to leave first
|
This. Hypocrates is top 5 on EH. 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/18/2011
Posts: 5,396
|
I missed 35 pages?
Time to catch up!
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/18/2011
Posts: 5,396
|
Not surprised at Space and Woods being out first but it's actually kinda good.
Not people having a meltdown over The Archetypes  It's not even a song!
I KNEW WEEDS WOULD BE OUT FIRST FROM FOORT weasley trying to troll me haha! But omg... Gold it out already??? No way come on before some of the crap of EH? Come on...
WHAT AT SEVENTEEN LEAVING COME ON!!!! I knew I should have dragged EH more. How did it beat out Rootless? I can't believe Rootless beat out Seventeen AND Guilty...
Mess at Better Than That being out too. I knew this rate was gonna be Electra Heart inflated scores. So dumb.
|
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 4/3/2014
Posts: 34,134
|
Hypocrates  The only real loss from this rate so far
Poor genetic thot tho, there goes his 11. 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 57,339
|
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/25/2012
Posts: 41,860
|
wait we lost Hypocrates?
didn't even notice

|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/4/2014
Posts: 1,241
|
i was at work and missed this UGH
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 5/6/2011
Posts: 26,891
|
Quote:
Originally posted by wesleywalrus
|
Quote:
Originally posted by wesleywalrus
Discography Rate

|
◂ |
48. Gold
Average Score: 6.383
Stans (2): HEIDI, jaxswim
Lovers (9): Reinvention, Argent, Eeveelution, wesleywalrus, Auburn, MadelineXPepito, Legit, Heroine, Colton Haynes
Haters (2): SkyN, Bitchcraft
|
Album Placement: 11 of 12
Comments:
HEIDI: y'all will NOT be punching this masterpiece out that fast! ( )
Jaxswim: What kind of perfection? This song has such an amazing vibe and message, accompanied by an outstanding melody and the production compliments it well.
Breakdown:
Sad Girl: 4
Charting Neptune: 5
CREATIVEREBELLION: 4
mandym:4
Wotamin: 2
Diuzza: 9
HonourableVomit: 8
Lulu: 4
Reinvention: 10
Thomasuxx: 6
HEIDI: 11
Summer Boy: 6.5
diam0nd: 8
Terylee: 2
Kxvk:4
Lana Del Yonce: 3
Girlicious: 3
Eeveelution: 10
Frozen99: 7.8
IcarusIsFlying: 6
Argent: 10
BlackAura: 9.5
SkyN: 1
Atlantis: 5
Vilppu: 2
Vulnicura: 4
Catch22: 8
wesleywalrus: 10
Killua: 7
Icarus.: 6
Stardust.: 8.5
Titan: 2
KillingYourCareer: 5.5
paulyyyozd: 4
Misanthrope: 7
Kim Kardashian: 7.5
MeAndMyHand: 8
Summerboy95: 4.1
Auburn: 10
MP2K: 7.5
MadelineXPepito: 10
Suilen: 6.5
RatedG²: 8
Superiore: 4.5
LoKoPaNdA: 8
Eh Eh.: 9
Legit: 10
conatus: 6
ItalianAvenger: 6
Paramore: 5
ImmaSlave4u: 6
buythestars: 8
emily_nd: 9
Lucas32: 8
BYoncé: 7.5
Petals: 5
tylerlscwv: 3
Free hugs: 4
leaked-iT: 6.7
Afferty: 5
Quicksand: 7
Reverie: 6.5
A Bomb: 8
Sabbath: 7.5
mxtthewdelrey: 5
Ewan Chaos: 7.5
Bloomers: 5
Diarrhoea: 4
MarryTheMonster: 9.2
Dollas n Diamonds: 4
enxe: 8.5
Heroine: 10
Bitchcraft: 1
genetic fail: 7.3
teen-idle: 6
Colton Haynes: 10
Buyonce1814: 3
Jaxswim: 11
Qatari Monster: 7
Amaloner: 7.2
|
WHAT?! NOT these two bops being the first out and outlasted by Trashier Than That and Forgotten
Quote:
Originally posted by wesleywalrus
Discography Rate

|
◂ |
47. Seventeen
Average Score: 6.39
Stans (1): Lana Del Yonce
Lovers (5): Paramore, Lucas32, mxtthewdelrey, Dollas N Diamonds, genetic fail
Haters (7): Diuzza, paulyyyozd, Misanthrope, Reinvention, Summerboy95, BYonce, Afferty
|
Album Placement: 14 of 15
Comments:
Lana Del Yonce: I'm going to get so much backlash for this but I adore this song, it's a complete masterpiece, from the cute intro, to her quirky remarks throughout the song.
Charting Neptune: Absolutely awful .. I really wish she would've left this track off this amazing album
Breakdown:
Sad Girl: 4
Charting Neptune: 4
CREATIVEREBELLION: 5
mandym: 7
Wotamin: 8
Diuzza: 1
HonourableVomit: 2
Lulu: 6
Reinvention: 1.6
Thomasuxx: 6.5
HEIDI: 7
Summer Boy: 9
diam0nd: 8
Terylee: 4
Kxvk: 5
Lana Del Yonce: 11
Girlicious: 7
Eeveelution: 7.5
Frozen99: 7.8
IcarusIsFlying: 3
Argent: 9
BlackAura: 4
SkyN: 8
Atlantis: 3
Vilppu: 5.5
Vulnicura: 5
Catch22: 6
wesleywalrus: 5
Killua: 8
Icarus.: 7
Stardust.: 8.3
Titan: 4
KillingYourCareer: 9
paulyyyozd: 1
Misanthrope: 1
Kim Kardashian: 9
MeAndMyHand: 5
Summerboy95: 1.3
Auburn: 4
MP2K: 7
MadelineXPepito: 5
Suilen: 8.5
RatedG²: 6.5
Superiore: 2
LoKoPaNdA: 8
Eh Eh.: 8
Legit: 7
conatus: 6
ItalianAvenger: 9
Paramore: 10
ImmaSlave4u: 7
buythestars: 6
emily_nd: 9
Lucas32: 10
BYoncé: 1
Petals: 8
tylerlscwv: 8
Free hugs: 7
leaked-iT: 8
Afferty: 1
Quicksand: 7.5
Reverie: 6
A Bomb: 9
Sabbath: 7.9
mxtthewdelrey: 10
Ewan Chaos: 8
Bloomers: 6
Diarrhoea: 5
MarryTheMonster: 7
Dollas n Diamonds: 10
enxe: 6.5
Heroine: 9
Bitchcraft: 8.7
genetic fail: 10
teen-idle: 4
Colton Haynes: 3.9
Buyonce1814: 8
Jaxswim: 7.5
Qatari Monster: 9
Amaloner: 6.8
|
This almost got my 11. Underrated masterpiece
Quote:
Originally posted by wesleywalrus
|
NOT my ****in 11 YALL ARE TRASH YALL NEED TO REEVALUATE YALLS LIVES!!! YALL NEED JESUS AND MOTHER ****IN MARY YALL NEED TO PRAY EVERYNIGHT YALL EVILL AND GOING TO HELL FIGHT ME PUTAS FIGHT ME IMMA MAKE YALL EAT YALL UNWASHED WEAVES
Quote:
Originally posted by wesleywalrus
Discography Rate

|
◂ |
41. Better Than That
Average Score: 6.69
Stans (0):
Lovers (3): Frozen99, paulyyyozd, Bitchcraft
Haters (3): Misanthrope, genetic, Colton Haynes
|
Album Placement: 10 of 12
Comments:
CREATIVEREBELLION: i'm with marina, i hate that Eillie Golduing hoe. She's disgusting.
Genetic: This song is just UGLY. The message, the sound, the EVERYTHING! Can we delete this from her discography please?
Breakdown:
Sad Girl: 6
Charting Neptune: 7.5
CREATIVEREBELLION: 5
mandym: 6
Wotamin: 6
Diuzza: 4
HonourableVomit: 8
Lulu: 7
Reinvention: 2
Thomasuxx: 9
HEIDI: 4
Summer Boy: 7
diam0nd: 9
Terylee: 7
Kxvk: 5
Lana Del Yonce: 4
Girlicious: 5
Eeveelution: 5
Frozen99:10
IcarusIsFlying: 4
Argent: 8.5
BlackAura: 7
SkyN: 8
Atlantis: 6
Vilppu: 4
Vulnicura: 3
Catch22: 4.5
wesleywalrus: 7
Killua: 8
Icarus.: 7
Stardust.: 9
Titan: 6
KillingYourCareer: 6.5
paulyyyozd: 10
Misanthrope: 1
Kim Kardashian: 8
MeAndMyHand: 9
Summerboy95: 7
Auburn: 3
MP2K: 7
MadelineXPepito: 9
Suilen: 8.5
RatedG²: 5
Superiore: 3.5
LoKoPaNdA: 9
Eh Eh.: 8
Legit: 7
conatus: 6
ItalianAvenger: 8
Paramore: 7
ImmaSlave4u: 9
buythestars: 7
emily_nd: 8
Lucas32: 9
BYoncé: 7.9
Petals: 4
tylerlscwv: 5
Free hugs: 9
leaked-iT: 8.3
Afferty: 7
Quicksand: 5
Reverie: 7.8
A Bomb: 8
Sabbath: 7
mxtthewdelrey: 6
Ewan Chaos: 9
Bloomers: 8
Diarrhoea: 6
MarryTheMonster: 6
Dollas n Diamonds: 9
enxe: 8.5
Heroine: 2
Bitchcraft: 10
genetic fail: 1
teen-idle: 8.5
Colton Haynes: 1
Buyonce1814: 7
Jaxswim: 9.5
Qatari Monster: 9
Amaloner: 8.4
|
Bye trash. Shoulda been the first one out tbh
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/16/2011
Posts: 32,177
|
Loving these results. Not missing anything yet. Just praying for my baby Savages to hold on.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 26,845
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Prometheus.
Loving these results. Not missing anything yet. Just praying for my baby Savages to hold on.
|
Just hold on, we're going home 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 6,514
|
Girls, Guilty and Gold deserved way better
And why is How To Be A Heartbreaker still in? 
|
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 8,324
|
Better than that deserves to be at least top 40 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/7/2015
Posts: 10,195
|
1/4 of Froot out already and they weren't even the songs I dragged. 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/2/2011
Posts: 43,174
|
Nothing too shocking for the start. Poor FROOT.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/7/2015
Posts: 18,105
|
All the trash is going out 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 57,339
|
Guilty is so underrated. I've never understood why it's so reviled.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/5/2012
Posts: 538
|
My guess is that the next to go are Rootless, Girls, Can't pin me down, HTBAH. I should have dragged EH more since I see so many dragged FROOT.
The winner song will be from FROOT though 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 2/4/2014
Posts: 8,658
|
Weeds, it's ATRLOBAL impact. Y'all made a giant mistake.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/16/2012
Posts: 3,027
|
Quote:
Originally posted by wesleywalrus
|
IM NOT OKAY WITH THIS 
|
|
|
|
|
|