|
Tournament: Survivor: ATRL Edition! [Season 2]
Member Since: 3/27/2012
Posts: 27,951
|
Ray touched my no-nos
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
Ray is a saint he would never. Plus he's not into ****ing animals
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/27/2012
Posts: 27,951
|
What are you trying to say?
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/18/2007
Posts: 28,980
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/27/2012
Posts: 27,951
|
Am nervous
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
Yes you'll have results tonight.
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/22/2012
Posts: 10,005
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DillonATRL
Yes you'll have results tonight.
|
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 8/24/2011
Posts: 6,860
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DillonATRL
Yes you'll have results tonight.
|
finally...
|
|
|
Member Since: 12/18/2010
Posts: 10,698
|
Quote:
Originally posted by DillonATRL
Ray is a saint he would never.
|
I must concur.
Anyways, RESULTS ARE HEREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
Hello Castaways! It's that time to reveal your results for the 18th & FINAL Round of the game as well as the 8th round of the merge! For this round, the scoring is a bit different for different challenges so here below is the score sheet:
* Round 1 to 10: 5 Points Total
* Round 11: 5 Points for the tracklist 5 Points for the singles - 10 Points Total
* Round 14: 5 Points Total
* Round 16: 5 Points for the tracklist 5 Points for the sabotage song - 10 Points Total
* Round 17: 10 Poiints Total
* Total Points Possible: 85 Points
First I will post your entry then the judges comments separately...you will have about a 10 post round right here.
Alright?
Let's get started...
Sleiani
|
|
|
Member Since: 10/18/2007
Posts: 28,980
|
I'm so nervous right now
|
|
|
Member Since: 12/18/2010
Posts: 10,698
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/22/2012
Posts: 33,490
|
oh goodness
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/27/2012
Posts: 27,951
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
1. AdamAL4
Quote:
Originally posted by Dillon
1. AdamAL4
Hey Adam Let's see your flashback to the beginning of the game to the present...
Round 1: This was a good start to the game. You had a decent score and I was impressed because I had never seen you before so I thought you as well as iLukey were going to not send in or be active. Anyway, your revision is clever and is an iconic and good duet. A step up. 5/5
Round 2: I thought it was good and clever to begin with. Only Ray screwed up your average so it's still a good entry to me regardless. 5/5
Round 3: Wasn't this released in the US recently? Anyway, I think his music is cute. Nothing much to say about him. This was when I knew you were going to be pretty consistent in the game. 4.5/5
Round 4: I hated judging this round I hate foreign songs so I was really generous. Yours was one of the ones I actually enjoyed. 5/5
Round 5: Me and Four had an issue with this one Yeah I was really disappointed to find out some of you got your entries sent to you. It takes away the fun imo but you stood your ground solo as we all know. But anyway, Too Little Too Late works much better. Love JoJo. 5/5
Round 6:I'm glad you picked them because the BB basically have only one remembered song and this is it. Other bands had multiple songs which caused the scores to be scattered among the judges. 5/5
Round 7: Your track was perfect to begin with, 5/5
Round 8: One of the reasons I liked you as a player was because i didn't get so much cliche choices from you. Sure maybe those choices get slightly better scores depending on the round but doesn't a risk paying off feel much better? I think so. 4.5/5
Round 9: This was your flop round. We all have one. This was it for you. Skin is a good entry I guess. I just feel like most of Loud was released except for Fading and LTWYL2 and Skin so not much variety there. 4/5
Round 10: This was clever and yes as I stated going with a generally unrespected artist helped you here. It was Go Hard 2.0 but worse. 5/5
Round 11: I'm glad you took my advice on the Weightless (God is Jesus) ending the album 5/5 for the tracklist.
I agree with Strip Me being the lead and Little Too Much being the 2nd single. I like Recover as the 4th single. Neon Lights is alright I mean i wouldn't die if it wasn't released. 4.5/5 for the singles.
Round 14: Horny muchacho I love me. But Adam, you only gave me four songs Fallin For You gets a 4/4 as well as Love Like This and Love on Top. I'm Into You gets a 3 still. then I guess I'll keep If I Had You as the 5th track sign it gets a better score than WHYB (2.5). Overall, I'll give you a 4.5/5 for the revision.
Round 16: I'm glad you added Check On It and Love on Top 5/5 for the new tracklist.
Then your sabotage song is the #1 sabotage song for Britney so 5/5 Nice.
Round 17: I know Four is a mess for that Moving Cinema to the front was smart since now you don't look repetitive with track number 11 having the same meaning. I'll give you 9.5/10 for this one.
Final Score: This grade is basically what grade I give you as a player throughout the entire journey so it's pretty crucial you do well this round and well.....
76.5/85 = 0.9
Final Grade From Dean Dillon :
90% A-
I've enjoyed you as a player Adam. You're not the typical ATRLer which is refreshing. I'll be saying more in the interviews (if you make the Top 3) so stay tuned for more praise . Very nice game you have played.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Ray Bass
76/85 = 89.41 %
|
ADAM
Adam
Round 1
1. AdamAL4 - Jason Aldean & Kelly Clarkson - Don't You Wanna Stay
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I too wish you'd taken more time to consider your entry, the Elton John song is such a great choice. at least you're getting the full points now. 5/5
|
Round 2
2. AdamAL4 - Duran Duran - A View To A Kill - A View To A Kill
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I think you could have gone with a different Bond theme and it would have been an improvement, because this was really not the most memorable tune. however, it was a unique choice and not bad, either, so I don't blame you for keeping it. 5/5
|
Round 3
3. AdamAL4 - Olly Murs feat. Chiddy Bang - Heart Skips A Beat - X Factor UK
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I don't really care about the rappers but yeah, the original version is superior. 5/5
|
Round 4
3. AdamAL4 - Jolin Tsai - The Great Artist
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I'm happy with this too. 5/5
|
Round 5
3. AdamAL4 - Gwen Stefani – Cool
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I still can't believe people had others pick their submissions for them. like wtf. I didn't give you the full points for Cool but I still liked it a lot, it was a different approach and I thought that was interesting (even though it turned out it wasn't even your idea, sadly). Too Little Too Late fits of course but it's a bit blah. 3.5/5
|
Round 6
3. AdamAL4 - Backstreet Boys - I Want It That Way
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
It's My Life is an amazing cover and I actually would have loved you changing this for it, because I'm all for bands and it would have been a big surprise moment. 4.5/5
|
Round 7
3. AdamAL4 - Missy Elliott - Work It
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
good. 5/5
|
Round 8
3. AdamAL4 - MIKA - Make You Happy
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
thank God this entry actually came from you, I was impressed by it and would have been so disappointed if someone else had chosen this. it's perfect. 5/5
|
Round 9
3. AdamAL4 - Beyonce - End of Time - 4
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
this was not a good entry and you did come up with something better. however, I wouldn't call Skin an album gem though. there's still room for improvement. 3.5/5
|
Round 10
3. AdamAL4 - will.i.am. feat. Mick Jagger & Wolfgang Partner - Go Home
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I was the only one who didn't think this was a perfect entry for this round, and I still stand by that. I get where you're coming from, will.i.am. has a lot of bad stuff, but this one did not make my ears bleed. 3/5
|
Round 11
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I'm glad you changed Little Too Much as the first single, but apart from that, there was nothing that bothered me.
singles: 4/5
tracklist: 2.5/5
|
Round 14
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I guess Blackout will haunt me until the day I leave ATRL I feel bad that you didn't understand the concept originally and no one explained it to you. you definitely used your chance to improve your entry, though, these are all songs I like. Bangarang is not my favorite Skrillex track and he was a very safe choice since you could see in Adrian's ratings that I liked him. and like I told Danny already, Blackout is predictable. I'm taking a point off for that, but you improved drastically from your original entry. 4/5
|
Round 16
4. AdamAL4
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
you listened to the judges and included the songs that were missing. well done. 5/5
|
sabotage song
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
much better choice. 5/5
|
Round 17
2. AdamAL4
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I loved your entry like it was, seeing you put Cinema as the opener is surprising and I really wish you had explained why. I thought Mother Mother were quite fitting as the first song because they're your faves. 8/10
|
OVERALL
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
80%
you did well, Adam, revising your entries where it was needed, trying to understand and accept criticism and not making any questionable changes. your entry is my second favorite this round. well done, and congrats on getting this far in the game. similarly to Adrian, you brought something different to the table, although you stayed more under the radar for most of the game. I'm glad you got a bit more active towards the end. well done!
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Four - Adam - 99%
Round 1 - 5
Round 2 - 5
Round 3 - 5
Round 4 - 5
Round 5 - 5
Round 6 - 5
Round 8 - 5
Round 9 - 4
Round 10 - 5
Round 11 - 10
Round 14 - 5
Round 16 - 5
Round 17 - 10
Everything about your revision was great, except that you wanted to change End of Timesus for Skin, that's why I gave you a 4 on round 9, but other than that, I think you did great on Survivor! It was a pleasure being in this game with you, Adam!
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
Ray, I can't post your actual rates because they include the entry which makes it too long to post which I recall saying not to do. So there will be no copies of the entries posted.
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
2. Adr
Quote:
Originally posted by Dylan
2. Adr
Hey Adrian So let's take a look back at your journey in Survivor...
Round 1: You started out perfectly and Four's rates were a mess that round since I had told him to be harder but he still gave good entries bad scores Way to start out your game on here. 5/5
Round 2: You got a perfect 10 so of course you're not going to change this 5/5
Round 3: I love What About Now as well as Home and Feels Like Tonight. I think Rebeccah was used once during this season and i thought she was kinda boring. But this song is actually pretty cute. Great voice. 5/5
Round 4: It was risky but it obviously paid off so why would you change it? 5/5
Round 5: This round was just bad timing on both our parts since you submitted at a time where i couldn't tell you what was taken and by the time i was online all your other choices were submitted This new song is a better entry than Believe imo. I think I've heard their other material before. 4.5/5
Round 6: You got an almost perfect score so once again why would you change. Glad to see you enjoyed that challenge. 5/5
Round 7: Foolish is one of the most successful songs of that decade. Flawless choice. 5/5
Round 8: It wasn't my type of video really. 4.5/5
Round 9: There you go. That's the true gem of 21 5/5
Round 10: I just remember all the Lambs saying how she was going to "snatch wigs" and stuff like that and then I heard it and I was like "is this even Mariah's song?" I know some people stan for it but I don't. horrible comeback single...or "buzz" single 5/5
Round 11: Your singles are perfect although I don't really care for the switch of Blind and We R Who We R but no big deal. I always loved Blind. We R Who We R was that typical self empowerment hit. The Harold Song is probably her gem in general. Then TiK ToK and YLIMD slay as well. 5/5 for the singles
The tracklist is great...I like how you put blind towards the beginning and Animal as the last track. 5/5 for the tracklist as well. Great revision.
Round 14: I'm glad you change Jessie and Britney. I give you full credit for Sometimes but for Alicia Keys I don't know, there were other choices. 4.5/5
Round 16: I remember this It killed me to give you a low score because you thought so out of the box. I think you got all the mandatory tracks. I like it. I'm glad there's more of an in between instead of just the Gloom + Bloom. 5/5 for the tracklist
Now on to the sabotage... I didn't even know this existed great. 5/5
Round 17: My favorite of that round. 10/10 Still my favorite
Final Score: No other round decides who I vote for more...so let's see your fianl grade from Dean Dillon ...
78.5/85 = .923
92% A-
I'm really glad you joined this game. I'm a bit surprised to see you here just based on social game but it's a pleasant surprise. If you make it to the final 3, I'll be glad to give you some more insight in the interviews...you have all played a good game.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Ray Bass
83/85 = 97.64%
|
ADRIAN
Adrian
Round 1: Duets
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
you started with a bang and would be insane to change this. 5/5
|
Round 2: Soundtrack
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
the slayage continued. no explanation needed indeed! 5/5
|
Round 3: Reality TV Alumni
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
yes! this track is miles better than your original entry. Rebecca's voice is just so unique, and this track shows a more upbeat side of her in contrast to her first single, proving she is a versatile artist. great find, Adrian. 5/5
|
Round 4: Lost In Translation
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
thanks again for showing us this gem, Adrian. it's rare that a song whose lyrical content you don't understand touches you like this one does. it gives me a careless, happy feeling. I love it. 5/5
|
Round 5: Break Up Anthems: Revamped Edition
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I really wasn't the biggest fan of Believe for this round, so I'm glad you decided to change your song. and you can thank your friend for the inspiration because this choice is so much better! it's energetic and positive, he's glad he got rid of her. well done!! 5/5
|
Round 6: Battle of the Bands
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
nothing to change here, 5/5.
|
Round 7: Urban Anthem
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
this round it really wasn't a problem that your first choice was already taken. you came up with something great, a modern classic in R&B. I wouldn't have expected you to change it. 5/5
|
Round 8: Music Video
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I'm so glad you kept this entry because it truly stuck out to me. it was such a risky choice to send a video from the 80s, when everyone else was obviously going for something more contemporary. I loved the vid and thankfully the other judges agreed. 5/5
|
Round 9: The Gems of the Album Tracks
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
from reading our critiques again, I was a bit surprised you changed this, but when I listen to the two songs, I actually like Don't You Remember even better than He Won't Go. they're both amazing, no doubt about that, but I just can't find a single flaw on DYR, except that the theme is a bit repetitive at this point. still I'd say it was a good decision to change. 5/5
|
Round 10: The Worst of the Industry
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I actually thought Video Phone was pretty obnoxious. it was a total mishap compared to Telephone. I hadn't heard Triumphant until Today, and even though it's nowhere near Mariah's hits I think it's not as bad as Video Phone. it's nothing special and it's indeed sad how she's being overshadowed by the features on her own track, but at least her chorus is good and the song is bearable. sorry, I don't like this decision. 2/5
|
Round 11: Recreate an Era
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
hmm, I don't quite get the changes you made. The Harold Song and Blind are both ballads, releasing them back to back wouldn't be a wise choice imo. besides, you got 5/5 from every judge for the singles except Ray, so I really don't think a change was necessary. same goes for the tracklist, if anything, you should have separated THS and Blind instead of moving them both to the middle, and right after DWTIME, too. that doesn't work at all. you kept Kiss N Tell, which I still think is too filler to be on here. Animal as the closer is good though.
singles: 0/5
tracklist: 1.5/5
|
Round 14: The Mood Ring Playlists
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
like Chasing The Sun, it's just not something I'd lose my **** to in the club. the Heads Will Roll Remix does make me wanna do that, though, so perfect improvement! the YYYs concert must have inspired you :P it was brave of you to include Ride, I still love that idea. 5/5
|
Round 16: Greatest Hits Compilations
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
congrats, Adrian, you successfully cleaned up the mess the original playlist was! keeping the concept but getting rid of the strict separation of the two parts is a great idea, as is realizing that some songs fit both categories. you also took our advice and included Stupid Girls and Family Portrait, taking out two not so important songs in their favor. great work! 5/5
|
Adr sabotaged DripDrip with Beyonce's "Run The World (Girls)"
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
you definitely had to change this and you found the right replacement. I actually did not know this song existed and it would be really out of place on a best of. 5/5
|
Round 17: Your Soundtrack
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
amazing. your soundtrack was my favorite, it's 100% you and I'm glad you have the confidence to realize that and not change anything about it. 10/10
|
OVERALL: 85%
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
Adrian, this round you showed for the final time that you truly belong in the top 3. you're dedicated to this game, you reflected well on your entries and for the most part, made the necessary changes. but you're also dedicated to music, knowing many different genres, and you were not afraid to show your unique taste throughout this game, even though it was risky at times. well done!
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Four - Adr - 98%
Round 1 - 5
Round 2 - 5
Round 3 - 5
Round 4 - 5
Round 5 - 5
Round 6 - 5
Round 8 - 5
Round 9 - 5
Round 10 - 3
Round 11 - 10
Round 14 - 5
Round 16 - 5
Round 17 - 10
You have been an amazing contestant, and I'm happy I shared this experience with you! Your revision was great except that you changed your song on Round 10 from VidePhone to Triumphant, and while I agree on everything you say about it flopping and being mostly a song of the rappers rather than a Mariah song, I don't think the song is that awful, in fact, I like it! but anyway! Congrats on being on the finals! It was amazing being on this game with you!
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/16/2011
Posts: 32,177
|
I feel like I really ****ed up this round.
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/27/2012
Posts: 27,951
|
Yara Sofia RuPauls Drag Race Season Three Before the top 3 all over again
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/5/2012
Posts: 26,361
|
3. DripDrip
Quote:
Originally posted by Dylan
3. DripDrip
Hey Jeremy/Germy/FlopFlop Let's take a nice look back on your journey on this little game we call Survivor...
Round 1: You started out stronger than I thought. This was a good entry. Remembered at least. 5/5
Round 2: I love this song You look like Rosie O Donnell too 5/5
Round 3: I love Allison Katharine's cool too. Your entry was good...nothing special. 4/5
Round 4: I just really didn't enjoy this round. Seems basically like the same as the first one you sent in 4/5
Round 5: You and Anna have the same soul I really like this band. 5/5
Round 6: This round was interesting...flopping to get others out N'Sync Bye Bye Bye was such an obvious choice I'm surprised it wasn't used in the first place. 5/5
Round 7: U flopped that round and somehow got a 10 from Anna Lose Yourself is basically a high score for any rap round so it's a safe choice but a good one. I don't consider it overrated. 4.5/5
Round 8: I like All Time Low...i mean they mentioned Ke$ha in a song like Much better than Call our Girlfriend. This is the point in the game where u struggled but you are a Diamond in the Sky 5/5
Round 9: Yes bitch agree with the God of Survivor: Dylan Anyway, Animal aside from The Harold Song is a highlight of Ke$ha's career because it had real music and a genuine emotion to it. 5/5
Round 10: Although I do enjoy the song, I think you backed up your choice very well. A good way of defending yourself 4.5/5
Round 11: Both the singles (Do It Like A Dude & Who's Laughing Now) were hits at least in the UK so I can't really agree with you there. Then I think the order is off still. 1.5/5
Singles Wise, I think Laserlight would have been a throw away in that year of dance music plus it would have been identified with Guetta and not her.. I think Price Tag was the right way to start and Domino would have been a way of saying she's here to stay. Then Who You Are was a good way to end the era as we all said. Plus Abracadabra is the only instantly likable album track really. 3/5
Round 14: This was when you impressed me the most while others completely disappointed so nothing to say here. Great then great now. 5/5
Round 16: I still think it looks a little weird and lacks Love On Top but it's no worse than actual greatest hits albums cough kelly clarkson cough 4/5
The sabotage song was great and the story behind it is cute. 5/5
Round 17: The tracklist is improved now. You got what you did wrong and you fixed it and that's the whole point of this round. So congrats on making it this far although the LTBL icnlusion kinda irks me since it's about sex and you could have used a different with that actual meaning but once again congrats. 9.5/10
Final Score:
Time to find out the general consensus of your journey here...keep in mind this does not include your social game...which I think is your strong point on top of scores...
75/85 = .8824
88% B+
In all honesty, your ban was probably the best thing that ever happened to you on here because it opened a lot of doors on here if that makes any sense at all. Beyond DripDrip, I see a genuine person so you are probably one of the reasons I did a Season 2 in the first place...after the "friends" I made on Season 1. For the 45th time, congrats.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Ray
77/85 = 90.85%
|
DRIP
DripDrip
Round 1-
DripDrip - Usher & Alicia Keys - My Boo
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I wouldn't have changed this either. it wasn't a straight 10, but still a very decent entry. 5/5
|
~~~~~~~
Round 2 -
DripDrip - Phil Collins - You'll Be In My Heart - Tarzan
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I love this song from my childhood, too! beautiful choice. 5/5
|
~~~~~~~
Round 3
DripDrip - Four Leaf Clover - Diana Vickers - X Factor UK
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
yay, you kept this as well! I'm certainly not gonna complain about that. the 10 was well deserved, it's just a good song c: 5/5
|
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Round 4 -
DripDrip - Namie Amuro - Want Me, Want Me
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
aha, taking a risk! well, this song doesn't strike me as typically J-Pop either, I can still hear a pretty big R&B vibe. that's cool though, and even though I didn't dislike your original choice, I like this even better. the risk paid off! 5/5
|
~~~~~~~~
Round 5 -
DripDrip - The Pretty Reckless - Since You're Gone
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I'm glad Ray's lower score didn't throw you off. us other judges loved the song and what's most important, you are completely confident in this entry. 5/5
|
~~~~~~~~
Round 6 -
DripDrip - Fall Out Boy - Dance, Dance
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
a wise decision, I mean Fall Out Boy 4 lyfe just not for this round. I would have preferred you replacing them with another real band, not a boygroup, but Bye Bye Bye is a 90s pop classic. 4/5
|
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Round 7 -
DripDrip - Kanye West - Heartless
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I still hate this round because I'll probably never understand the concept of "Urban". but judging by the charts, Lose Yourself actually did better on the general Hot 100 and Pop charts than the Hip Hop/Rap charts and I just remember it being a huge hit outside of the urban scene, so this might not have been the best decision. 2/5
|
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Round 8 -
DripDrip - Robyn - Call Your Girlfriend
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
this video was different from what we expected, and I hope you know I didn't give you a 10 because I felt bad for you. I actually loved that you sent this and I still stand by what I said. For Baltimore though, it's such an adorable video and really close to my heart, and I'm happy you're giving ATL some promo :P how they showed his tattoo was perfect.. and I guess it relates to the song a bit better than Robyn's. 5/5
|
~~~~~~~~~
Round 9 -
DripDrip - Ke$ha - Kiss N Tell - Animal
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
perfect!! I'm so glad you took on our words and actually agree that Kiss N Tell was a weak choice. Animal, on the other hand, is amazing and an absolute gem of a song, exactly what we were looking for that round. 5/5
|
~~~~~~~~~~~
Round 10 -
DripDrip - Rihanna feat. Nicki Minaj - Raining Men
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
a brave choice to keep this since you did not get the best scores for this, but I get your reasoning. still, you probably would have been able to find something better, but kudos for standing by your opinion. 4/5
|
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Round 11 -
Recreate An Era: Jessie J – Who You Are
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
sorry, but here I don't approve of you sticking with your submission. WLN and DILAD are crucial songs for Jessie and they have to be on that album, and that's not just my opinion. you missed out on a chance to improve here. 0/5
|
Singles:*
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I'm okay with you replacing COL with Who You Are, but keeping Laserlight as the lead single is just a big no. Price Tag shows much better who she is as a singer, artist and person. Guetta is not needed. 1/5
|
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Round 14 -
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
thanks for this explanation, now I get what you were trying to do with these songs. it's a nice idea, but I'm not sure how well it fits the theme. I wish you'd have at least tried to replace Just Tonight and Shake It Out to more fitting songs. Let Me Down Easy, for me it seems to be about breaking up, but she wants to stay friends so yeah, not what I was looking for here. sorry, I don't see any improvement. 0/5
|
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Round 16
Greatest Hits – Beyonce
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I can't believe you did not include Sweet Dreams and Best Thing I Never Had. and if you're so obsessed with I Was Here, I'd at least put that at the end, to demonstrate that she has left a mark. I don't like how you revised this at all. 0/5
|
DripDrip sabotaged AdamAL4 with Beyonce's "Daddy"
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
I wouldn't have changed it either. 5/5
|
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Last Round-
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
this is interesting, I never thought about the repetitiveness of the songs actually representing your personality on ATRL. good idea to bring Miss Nothing into this, especially 'cause it's a rock song, but I would have liked to see even more of that. I mean, you used Christina twice and that Britney song doesn't fit one bit. 5/10
|
OVERALL: 66%
Quote:
Originally posted by Anna
you didn't do too bad, Jeremy, and your explanations for each round were very detailed. kudos for being so confident in most of your entries despite some of them getting criticized, but it also makes it look a bit like you don't want to accept the judges' suggestions or at least overthink your choices. I think you could have made some more changes and improve your scores.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Four - Jeremy - 100 %
Round 1 - 5
Round 2 - 5
Round 3 - 5
Round 4 - 5
Round 5 - 5
Round 6 - 5
Round 8 - 5
Round 9 - 5
Round 10 - 5
Round 11 - 10
Round 14 - 5
Round 16 - 5
Round 17 - 10
Oh Jeremy! I didn't know you flopping on Round 6 was a plan! Very interesting. I gotta say that your revision was really good, and because of that I gave you all the points! It's been an amazing experience and I'm glad I was in this game with you and all the other survivors! Good luck on the finals, although I don't think you need it.
|
|
|
|
|
|