[HausOfGerard]

Nope.

[Typhlosion]

Nope.

[BKTweets12]

Nope but incredibly underrated by those outside the fanbase.

[Harajuku]

no.

[Wafflecakes]

Nope.

[Mannequin.Dummy]

This is the only album by Beyonce that really makes me wear my stan hat... whenever I forget how much I love her, this album reminds me.

[Maiko]

Yes, B'Day is a classic. It's Beyonce's only classic and a masterpiece.

[jomarr]

Great album but no.

[KingKT]

YES IT IS AND YOU ALL WILL DEAL!

[KingBey21]

It's not as highly regarded as her other albums but it's her most artistically risky album and has some of her most aggressive vocals of her career. No other artist of her generation could have pulled it off as effectively as she did.

[rihannafan]

Far from it. One of the worst albums i've ever heard, may I add.

[Kitt]

YES.

Originally posted by Mannequin.Dummy

This is the only album by Beyonce that really makes me wear my stan hat... whenever I forget how much I love her, this album reminds me.

To put it simply.

[Romaysae]

Yes

[I Am Music]

No, least not yet. It is a flawless album from start to finish but not a classic yet bey has more to show in her career.

[MusicTalker]

It should be, but no. For some reason people seem to snub this album compared to her other 3, including Bey herself at the SuperBowl.

Besides 4, it has the best variety of songs & it was really creative. Very percussion & trumpet heavy with a cool kind of marching-band quality to a lot of the uptempos. Her vocals were the most confident on this album.

This album was also a humungous quality leap forward from Dangerously In Love, which is probably her classic album, if any. DIL as a whole is kind of overrated, besides the singles.

[manwhore]

Flaw free album even before the rerelease.

[Shakira Stan]

The fact that she collaborated with Shakira makes a classic.

[J-esper]

It is a classic for me, this + 4 tie for me for her best album. This album carries her best uptempo's. 4 her best mellow and R&B tracks

[superben]

Not really.

It's a great album, though.

[mandym]

Hmm... no, but I love it.