God, this is so hard.
The Fame Monster era is definitely better than BTW, still my favorite era and "Gaga". But if I look only songs on both albums, it's way harder.
Bad Romance is still her best song by far and no songs on BTW match it.
Telephone is great, but too generic and forgettable.
Speechless is amazing, way better than Y&I.
DITD - what a song! But Marry The Night is better in the same style.
SHICD - I love it, but HML ***** on it so hard in the same style.
Alejandro - I really love the track (if you don't consider the video) - the song had a lot of potential
Monster is good pop song, but it doesn't stand out when I think of this album.
Teeth - I absolutely hate this song
Overall, BTW, as an album, is stronger than TFM. Songs like Marry The Night, Heavy Metal Lover, The Edge Of Glory, Scheibe, Governement Hooker, Bloody Mary are so unique and stricking.
My vote goes for
Born This Way. I just wrote an essay