[Razzle]

Originally posted by supertiffany

the only one who's consistent in getting praises in finals was kelly clarkson right?

carrie underwood is a frontrunner however she was getting criticisms by simon even everyone knows she is a favorite and yet she is getting negative comments

jessica will survive this, better song is what she needs, if only love on top was released in her year year of birth then it would have been better but at least it showed she can sing dance and up tempo but it didnt showed much of her vocals.

Didn't Archuleta get praised a lot too?

[[Bask]]

Jessica + Colton studio

[Beyond Say]

Everyone should tweet Jessica and tell her to sing Love on Top whenever she has the chance to. I did last week.

@JSanchezAI11

[jpsketch]

Originally posted by Pelvic Thrust

Carrie was very consistent since Hollywood Week actually. I can't remember any bad AI performance from her.

Her "Piece of My Heart" was kind of a mess, and I don't remember any of the judges being too keen on it.

She didn't really have a bad performance, but I don't think she really came alive for most of America until Alone.

Originally posted by Sept

did you watch the show?
Nigel also said Carrie won every single weeks

Of course. I still stand by my opinion that season 4 was one of the absolute worst seasons in Idol history. You knew Carrie was going to win because she was the only good contestant that season.

[Pelvic Thrust]

Originally posted by jpsketch

Of course. I still stand by my opinion that season 4 was one of the absolute worst seasons in Idol history. You knew Carrie was going to win because she was the only good contestant that season.

Agreed! I hated that season too.

[supertiffany]

Originally posted by jpsketch

Carrie didn't become a favorite until her performance of Heart's Alone. After that she was golden, before that...

she was already a frontrunner and one of the faves it solidified with alone though but what i want to say is she stills gets negative comments. ok?

i just posted this because people were over reacting with judges negatives/ not so pleased comments they should calm down for jessica is still strong and it is also a challenge for them to vote more and harder.

the only frontrunner i can think of not getting any was kelly clarkson.

david archuleta, carrie underwood, adam lambert, jordin sparks were frontrunners and yet get negatives so if that would apply to jessica it means she's safe to be in the finals/coronation night it is a trend/plan to spice up the show so this night dont affect jessica that much.

[jpsketch]

I just don't remember Carrie being the frontrunner before the top 11, which even still is practically the entire season.

[tj hazuki]

Carrie dominated the voting though every week.

[Benzene]

Originally posted by jpsketch

I just don't remember Carrie being the frontrunner before the top 11, which even still is practically the entire season.

Carrie was never in the bottom 2, and was basically never criticized. After "Alone," I knew she would win.

[Shy Boy]

I'm thought Elise would be safe.

[Parks]

Poor Elise. She did well last night.

[Benzene]

I wasn't really hot on Elise last tonight tbh, not surprised.

[Taste of Honey]

Demi is a beyond amazing vocalist.

[Shy Boy]

Deandre is in the bottom out of this group.

EDIT: I didn't notice Shannon was in the group, hmm. It'll be one of those two.

[Taste of Honey]

Originally posted by Shy Boy

Deandre is in the bottom out of this group.

EDIT: I didn't notice Shannon was in the group, hmm. It'll be one of those two.

IDK. OSD moved into the Top 1000 of Itunes after she performed so who knows.

Hmmm...okay.

[jpsketch]

DeAndre safe. That's all I care about.

[Parks]

Gonna be a three girl bottom.

[Quiqui4eva]

I know Ryan did not just clock my Deandre and save Jessica. I'd get on stage and beat his midgit ass if I were in the audience.

[JC.]

C'mon Heejun complete that bottom 3

[Shy Boy]

Originally posted by JC.

C'mon Heejun complete that bottom 3

It'll be Erika.