[kwek_kwek]

Just sent in my rate.

[posh]

B'Day

Average: 9.9
Highest score: 11 (x 1)
Lowest score: 8 (x 1)

Good Girl Gone Bad

Average: 5.04
Highest score: 10 (x 2)
Lowest score: 0 (x 4)

Blackout

Average: 7.5
Highest score: 10 (x 5)
Lowest score: 0 (x 1)

The Fame Monster

Average: 9.6
Highest score: 10 (x 6)
Lowest score: 8 (x 1)

I tried to censor myself a bit at the start by attempting to listen to these songs through more "critical" ears, but there are just way too many pop gems/classics for me to not give out those 10s where they were due.

It's not MY fault that Bey and Gags can do no wrong.

[Staryu]

Originally posted by Johnny Mac

Good Girl Gone Bad

Average: 5.04

[enxe]

Originally posted by Johnny Mac

B'Day

Average: 9.9
Highest score: 11 (x 1)
Lowest score: 8 (x 1)

Good Girl Gone Bad

Average: 5.04
Highest score: 10 (x 2)
Lowest score: 0 (x 4)

Blackout

Average: 7.5
Highest score: 10 (x 5)
Lowest score: 0 (x 1)

The Fame Monster

Average: 9.6
Highest score: 10 (x 6)
Lowest score: 8 (x 1)

I tried to censor myself a bit at the start by attempting to listen to these songs through more "critical" ears, but there are just way too many pop gems/classics for me to not give out those 10s where they were due.

It's not MY fault that Bey and Gags can do no wrong.

Some will say your scores are biased, I will say you scores reflect good taste

[Stark]

Originally posted by Johnny Mac

B'Day

Average: 9.9
Highest score: 11 (x 1)
Lowest score: 8 (x 1)

Good Girl Gone Bad

Average: 5.04
Highest score: 10 (x 2)
Lowest score: 0 (x 4)

Blackout

Average: 7.5
Highest score: 10 (x 5)
Lowest score: 0 (x 1)

The Fame Monster

Average: 9.6
Highest score: 10 (x 6)
Lowest score: 8 (x 1)

I tried to censor myself a bit at the start by attempting to listen to these songs through more "critical" ears, but there are just way too many pop gems/classics for me to not give out those 10s where they were due.

It's not MY fault that Bey and Gags can do no wrong.

[kwek_kwek]

Blackout

Average: 6.71
Highest Score: 10
Lowest Score: 4


B'Day

Average: 6.96
Highest Score: 8
Lowest Score: 5


Good Girl Gone Bad

Average: 6.5
Highest Score: 9
Lowest Score: 4.5


The Fame Monster

Average: 9.5
Highest Score: 11
Lowest Score: 8

[Baby Boy]

I was too fair with my votes imo.

[Toysoldier99]

Originally posted by Johnny Mac

I loved SUAD in 2008, but it's aged horribly. I'd actually go as far as to say it's aged the worst among all the songs in this rate. (not the worst song, though. That title goes to a different track on GGGB.)

I agree with you 100% there, most of GGGB was amazing in 2008-2009 but is very dated now. But it's still pretty solid overall.

Everyone trashing Sell Me Candy should be disqualified tbh.

[enxe]

Originally posted by kwek_kwek

Blackout

Average: 6.71
Highest Score: 10
Lowest Score: 4


B'Day

Average: 6.96
Highest Score: 8
Lowest Score: 5


Good Girl Gone Bad

Average: 6.5
Highest Score: 9
Lowest Score: 4.5


The Fame Monster

Average: 9.5
Highest Score: 11
Lowest Score: 8

The stanning is so transparent I see

[Superpower]

Originally posted by Johnny Mac

B'Day

Average: 9.9
Highest score: 11 (x 1)
Lowest score: 8 (x 1)

Good Girl Gone Bad

Average: 5.04
Highest score: 10 (x 2)
Lowest score: 0 (x 4)

Blackout

Average: 7.5
Highest score: 10 (x 5)
Lowest score: 0 (x 1)

The Fame Monster

Average: 9.6
Highest score: 10 (x 6)
Lowest score: 8 (x 1)

I tried to censor myself a bit at the start by attempting to listen to these songs through more "critical" ears, but there are just way too many pop gems/classics for me to not give out those 10s where they were due.

It's not MY fault that Bey and Gags can do no wrong.

Not you beating my 9.53 average for Bday
I still don't think this will be enough to secure BDAY a top10 spot.
-
Prismatic, can you refer all the members who gave Bday an average over 7 to my Videography rate?

[kwek_kwek]

Originally posted by enxe

The stanning is so transparent I see

It's just happened that TFM is against those trash albums. And I cannot blame Gaga for putting up such a masterpiece album

[enxe]

Originally posted by kwek_kwek

It's just happened that TFM is against those trash albums. And I cannot blame Gaga for putting up such a masterpiece album

I agree that Gaga's album is a masterpiece, but I don't think the others are trash

[greeneyedsoul]

B'Day

Average: 4.63
Highest score: 8 (x 2)
Lowest score: 0 (x 1)

Good Girl Gone Bad

Average: 7.04
Highest score: 10 (x 2)
Lowest score: 3 (x 1)

Blackout

Average: 8.25
Highest score: 11 (x 1)
Lowest score: 6 (x 1)

The Fame Monster

Average: 8.5
Highest score: 10 (x 3)
Lowest score: 6 (x 2)

[Rusty]

Originally posted by Prismatic

It's quite amazing how some songs got no 11s but are gonna make it far in the rate.

And no, it's not because of sabotaging.

Watch my 11-rated song be the first 11-recipient out because everyone else is a flop.

[Prismy]

Originally posted by Superpower

Prismatic, can you refer all the members who gave Bday an average over 7 to my Videography rate?

If you refer your participants here first.

Some of them have ignored my invitation!

[Prismy]

Originally posted by Rusty

Watch my 11-rated song be the first 11-recipient out because everyone else is a flop.

Even the GGGB fillers got some 11s, I don't think you'll have to worry.

[Baby Boy]

I already referred three people ngl.

[Prismy]

Originally posted by Baby Boy

I already referred three people ngl.

No wonder the top 12 positions are all snatched by Blackout.

[Baby Boy]

Originally posted by Prismatic

No wonder the top 12 positions are all snatched by Blackout.

[posh]

Can people actually listen to Ring The Alarm and be like, "this doesn't really deserve a 10"

Like, I can't fathom.