Poll: Most impactful : "...Baby One More Time" or "Wannabe" ? - Page 6

YouBetterPopBitch

Quote:

Originally posted by abrahamjmr

Both had really significant impact. If "Wannabe" hadn't been released, "...Baby One More Time" wouldn't exist. People who say "Wannabe" is forgotten are really stupid, I played the song in my class a couple of weeks ago and my students are around 12-16 years and they were all jamming to the song. Same happens with "...Baby One More Time", they know at least the chorus.

I totally agree with what you said.

...BOMT is winning the poll as of now. It was a lot closer a few hours ago !

phatty033

Quote:

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

Girl, you can keep going about the impact of BOMT. i'm still stuck on you thinking that 12 years is close to two decades, YET attempting to come for MY intelligence. lmao

and yes, those 5 irrelevant girls at my school performing at my school does measure it's impact.
you don't know music from before your time unless you were exposed to it or if it has impact.

also, studies show that wannabe is the most recognizable pop song of all time. that alone beats any receipts that you've conjured up. last time i heard about bomt was when it was luring pirates away or some ****. and BOMT was a bigger hit in the UK, it's obviously going to get more recurrent airplay

so you weren't able to find those commercials/movies that wannabe was supposedly mentioned in I see. I'm screaming at you thinking some study done in Manchester negates all the receipts

I mean as per, yall always pick & choose when it's more convenient to you. I also watched a group of girls at my sister's elementary school talent show performing BOMT last year, but I didn't mention it because unlike you, I can provide real receipts for BOMT. No one cares about your anecdotes and fairytales and I really don't have the time to entertain ignorance.

James Maslow

BOMT, every time.

Shelter

Both were huge. SG opened the door for all pop girls after that, so the Brit fans need to take a damn seat trying to drag it.

Slayonce

I still hear Wannabe. The other one is pretty much forgotten.

BlueTimberwolf

Wannabe

abrahamjmr

Quote:

Originally posted by Slayonce

I still hear Wannabe. The other one is pretty much forgotten.

Sure thing, honey.

emmanuel_punk

Both are the same

MovinKindaSlow

Quote:

Originally posted by Slayonce

I still hear Wannabe. The other one is pretty much forgotten.

So forgotten that it was the first solo female video of the 90s to be VEVO certified.

Concrete

Quote:

Originally posted by phatty033

the last time it was performed was in 2003 so
2000-2010-1 decade
2010-2020-the 2nd decade

I don't think it was a stretch for me to say nearly 2 decades.

And you still have not provided any receipts

What are these commercials/movies it was featured in? no one cares if some girls covered the song at your damn talent show

when BOMT has been covered by Ed Sheeran, Tori Amos, Selena Gomez, etc. These whack ass arguments. Valid receipts for example would be:

135 million views

96 million views

Despite the spice girls recently performing at the world cup, a huge global event. YT views is one of the best measures for memorability for songs released before 2005.

http://comparemyradio.com/tracks/Bri..._One_More_Time
239 plays

http://comparemyradio.com/tracks/Spice_Girls/Wannabe
34 plays

Don't yall love to cling to recurrent plays? BOMT gets more recurrent airplay in the UK despite it being the Spice Girls' home country

IMPACT

I can literally keep going

Homebrand

Quote:

Originally posted by Nano

The YouTube views disagree with you.

Yeah but Wannabe isnt even on a official vevo channel, nor have spicegirls even released a album in the last 15 years.. Brit is still making music throughout the whole vevo era so the fact Wannabe has 96mil is much more impressive than brits BOMT at 135mil

Your logic is so flawed

Nano

Quote:

Originally posted by Homebrand

Yeah but Wannabe isnt even on a official vevo channel, nor have spicegirls even released a album in the last 15 years.. Brit is still making music throughout the whole vevo era so the fact Wannabe has 96mil is much more impressive than brits BOMT at 135mil

Your logic is so flawed

You said Wannabe is more remembered, but then when I showed you receipts that BOMT is you said that the reason it's more remembered is because Britney released music recently. Your logic is flawed.

Homebrand

Quote:

Originally posted by Nano

You said Wannabe is more remembered, but then when I showed you receipts that BOMT is you said that the reason it's more remembered is because Britney released music recently. Your logic is flawed.

I literally just explained to you why its views are higher omg did you even read what i said

OffTheWall

Wannabe

Lucyyyyyyyyy

Quote:

Originally posted by Homebrand

I literally just explained to you why its views are higher omg did you even read what i said

The views are higher because it's more remembered

Wannabe is on vevo so I don't get your point? And who cares if the Spice Girls havent released an album in 15 years? They performed it at the Olympics in 2012 which is better than any promo Britney has done since vevo was a thing and she hasn't performed BOMT on TV in over a decade????

You people try so hard to discredit Britney

both songs were huge with incredible impact and both are remembered, but BOMT is remembered more as proven by its vevo views, usage in the media, the fact people still dress up in the iconic schoolgirl outfit for halloween etc.

˚Greedy for Ari˚

Wannabe was bigger, but BOMT has more impact i feel.

DanceAgain

Both tbh

Spice Girls and Britney are equally iconic and so are most of there records

Homebrand

Quote:

Originally posted by Lucyyyyyyyyy

The views are higher because it's more remembered

Wannabe is on vevo so I don't get your point? And who cares if the Spice Girls havent released an album in 15 years? They performed it at the Olympics in 2012 which is better than any promo Britney has done since vevo was a thing and she hasn't performed BOMT on TV in over a decade????

You people try so hard to discredit Britney

both songs were huge with incredible impact and both are remembered, but BOMT is remembered more as proven by its vevo views, usage in the media, the fact people still dress up in the iconic schoolgirl outfit for halloween etc.

Let me explain it to you..

For example Rihannas take a bow has 165mil views, it was released before vevo existed but its views are higher than BOMT so does that make it more remembered? obviously not. Rihanna has been relevant since the time vevo debuted hence why its views are rather high...

Understand?

Lucyyyyyyyyy

Quote:

Originally posted by Homebrand

Let me explain it to you..

For example Rihannas take a bow has 165mil views, it was released before vevo existed but its views are higher than BOMT so does that make it more remembered? obviously not. Rihanna has been relevant since the time vevo debuted hence why its views are rather high...

Understand?

No because Take A Bow was pretty new out when VEVO became a thing and Rihanna has promoted the song since?

Homebrand

Quote:

Originally posted by Lucyyyyyyyyy

No because Take A Bow was pretty new out when VEVO became a thing and Rihanna has promoted the song since?

Promoted the song? she barely even perform it on tour

Do you not understand what im saying??? If the spicegirls were still releasing music / relevant like britney has been dont you think its views would be higher?

gee