[mandym]

It was a moderate hit, I'd say.

[Embustera]

Flop

[AussieLovatic]

Moderate Hit it's still played a lot on radio here.

[YonceIsFierce]

Originally posted by Costea

I say hit bc everyone i know uses that song, even with minimal airplay

But that's everyone you know. No one I know cares about that song. So based on its current iTunes position and chart position I would say tbd.

[Lifeline]

Originally posted by YonceIsFierce

But that's everyone you know. No one I know cares about that song.

And that is only everyone you know. Contradictory in itself.

[LCTV]

What has it even impacted.. multiple youtube tabbers?

[NX127]

Top10 in 30 countries with huge VEVO views ... Hit

[swissman]

Originally posted by vuelve88

I'm saying this solely because a lot of Beyoncé fans are strangely dragging her when it took Beyoncé 5+ releases before she could get another top 10 hit.

It's simply a matter of treating a situation fairly. I happen to think the song's current peak of #15 is respectable.

It is respectable indeed. But are we forgetting that there have been many releases from Shakira that did not hit top ten since her last in 2007 with Beyonce? You're saying this like she has four more chances to match Beyonce (as if it is even a competition) when there have been many singles before CRTFY that already haven't hit that spot. I'm not saying this is a bad thing, I'm just using your standards.

And I'm sorry if you think the Hive are putting down this song just because Rihanna is in it. Knowing some people, I'm sure they are. But it doesn't automatically mean that every Hive member's opinion is biased like that. It's pretty obvious from the overall lukewarm response to the song that it's not a bonafide hit. As well as it being obvious from it's respectable chart position that it's not some flop.

[Aphrodite]

Underperformance

[Johnny Cash]

Originally posted by Superbitch

I've noticed certain stanbase who hates rih rih enjoys trashing this song. So transparent.

Well, they're locals. Shakira is global I can see why they don't understand that.

This.

[alestevens]

This flop underperforming song is #10 on the Worldwide Chart for a 2nd week in a row

[Johnny Cash]

Originally posted by alestevens

This flop underperforming song is #10 on the Worldwide Chart for a 2nd week in a row

Sis Its actually a month

[Yooorsh]

FLOP!

[Bey_Rihstan]

Just a tad bit of an underperformance,Lbr.
It hasn't even been promoted performance wise

[IBeMe]

its a mediocre hit i guess... i mean it charted a bit better in some other countries. but all in all it did less then expected. ppl were hoping for a top 5 hit...

[BGKC]

It was a smash hit in Columbia
a moderate hit WW
a flop in the US

[alestevens]

Originally posted by Johnny Cash

Sis Its actually a month

Im talking about the actual WW chart (Mediatraffic), not Kworb´s chart for WW iTunes

[alestevens]

Originally posted by BGKC

It was a smash hit in Columbia
a moderate hit WW
a flop in the US

It´s a smash hit in Latin America
It´s a hit WW
It´s a moderate hit in the US

[GrandMomCookies]

Originally posted by vuelve88

I'm saying this solely because a lot of Beyoncé fans are strangely dragging her when it took Beyoncé 5+ releases before she could get another top 10 hit.

It's simply a matter of treating a situation fairly. I happen to think the song's current peak of #15 is respectable.

You do know your fav last top 3 was with beyonce right ?

[MaoMars]

moderate hit or underperformance, it depends on the perspective you choose to look at.