[vuelve88]

Originally posted by Xtina Culture

Come out of the closet as an Xtina stan already.

Girl, please.

[slw84]

Originally posted by Tainted Blood

Was this thread really necessary? We're on ATRL after all, we ALL know Christina will lose. Are you really that delusional that you thought that Christina would win this one?

No, it's not necessary especially when we all know that Britney is more memorable when it comes to many things including songs.

I think it would be better to have a realistic thread. For instance, who is more critically acclaimed or who is the better vocalist...but then again like this thread there would be an obvious winner (xtina).

Maybe there shouldn't be a B vs. C as there is usually an easy win/lose and not much to debate.

Now a Rihanna/Beyonce or Pink/Christina would be worthwhile.
Britney is incomparable so...

[SeanXtina]

Pointless, Stupid, Reductive and Unnecessary Thread.

Stop being so one dimensional with these Xtina vs. Britney Stan Wars.

[gotintoririfever1]

Originally posted by Alexey

we are not deluded you should go to yes.com. the only X' song that you can hear on the radio are MLJ and Genie In A Bottle while Britney's songs like 3, womanizer and HIAM are still heavily played!

so if a song is still heavily played, it means that its memorable?

i mean what kind of logic?

so what happened to the 60's 70's 80's and 90's songs that were almost never played today but those artists are more memorable than today's popstar

[Alexey]

Originally posted by gotintoririfever1

so if a song is still heavily played, it means that its memorable?

i mean what kind of logic?

yes! then why the **** "memorable" songs like What A Girl Wants and Come On Over Baby are not played on the radio? so that means that no one remembers them cause even old Madonna's songs are played on the radio.

[Alexey]

Originally posted by gotintoririfever1

so what happened to the 60's 70's 80's and 90's songs that were almost never played today but those artists are more memorable than today's popstar

HOT AC plays them tho

[xproudofbritney]

Britney's.

[Madam X]

Originally posted by Alexey

yes! then why the **** "memorable" songs like What A Girl Wants and Come On Over Baby are not played on the radio? so that means that no one remembers them cause even old Madonna's songs are played on the radio.

I can't remember the last time I heard an old Madonna song on the radio.

[Alexey]

Originally posted by Xtina Culture

I can't remember the last time I heard an old Madonna song on the radio.

and y'all calling Britney's fans deluded
WFLC: MADONNA - Express Yourself
10.6.2012 7:41am
KJSN: MADONNA - Lucky Star
10.6.2012 4:45am
CJGV: MADONNA - Into The Groove
10.6.2012 6:47am
KPKX: MADONNA - Open Your Heart
10.6.2012 5:55am
and etc.

I can't

[alkralkra]

Christina, tbh.

[hector.adriel]

The shade in the comments in this thread.

Anyways, Britney's. Basically bc of BOMT and Womanizer. "3" is memorable to me too, stop saying it isn't, I mean, it sold over 2.5M copies in the US alone and spent 3 months in the Hot 100 Top 10 without one single hair of promo.

[Signs]

Originally posted by Duca

"...Baby One More Time" and "Womanizer" each are more memorable than all of Christina's #1's, so...

True. In fact toxic is more memorable than all of Christina's #1's...

[Madam X]

Originally posted by Signs

True. In fact toxic is more memorable than all of Christina's #1's...

Just because a song is #1 doesn't mean it's more memorable. I mean, 'Beautiful' peaked at #2, and it can compete with 'Toxic'.

[Madam X]

Originally posted by Alexey

and y'all calling Britney's fans deluded
WFLC: MADONNA - Express Yourself
10.6.2012 7:41am
KJSN: MADONNA - Lucky Star
10.6.2012 4:45am
CJGV: MADONNA - Into The Groove
10.6.2012 6:47am
KPKX: MADONNA - Open Your Heart
10.6.2012 5:55am
and etc.

I can't

I only accept receipts, not text someone could have easily typed.

[Sapphire]

Originally posted by Evangeline

But Britney might have more memorable songs overall like Toxic and Slave which didn't hit #1.

IKR?!
Britney's early songs got me remembered
Sometimes, Crazy, Oops, Stronger, Lucky, Slave, Im Not a Girl Not Yet a Woman, Overprotected, Me Against The Music, Everytime, and I cant still believe Toxic didnt go number 1 just like Beautiful

[Gossip_Boy]

BOMT >>>>>> Christina

[Rihannito]

BOMT>>>>>>>>>>> Christina's number one.

I LOOOVE genie a on the bottle and what's a girl want, but BOMT is just ICONIC and LEGENDARY.

Tho christina's best songs are not her number ones aka fighter, beautiful, hurt, Dirrty...

[Alexz]

Originally posted by Loghen

Hold It Against Me was last year, kid.
And didn't Christina get another #1 after a decade too? Lady Marmalade - Moves Like Jagger?

And they're not even solo songs.

[D.M.F]

BOMT's not memorable no matter how ya'll try to make it into something grand (video is). Genie's played way more than it, just look at recent airplay from around a week ago -

Baby One More Time: 0.1m AI
Genie: 1.8m AI

Receipts - http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.ph...14071#10014071

why the **** "memorable" songs like What A Girl Wants and Come On Over Baby are not played on the radio?

Lies, and fairy tales -

Come On Over: 1.5m AI

Another song that's played way more than Baby aka the more memorable song by C Aguilera.

[D.M.F]

Originally posted by Signs

True. In fact toxic is more memorable than all of Christina's #1's...

False. Truth can be proven. Like this -

Toxic: 2.00m AI
Beautiful: 7.00m AI

Both weren't #1 hits yet Beautiful's more played than anything by Brit, and her #1s just like X's # singles versus Britney's.