[Amaru]

Technically, Kelly did great. Beyonce has that something extra for me though, I'm just in love with her rendition

[karlo_98]

Kelly >>>

[Reed]

Giselle

[DejaVu]

Kelly quite easily. I wasn't a fan of Beyonce back then and this is a good example why. Just absolutely too much.

Originally posted by annashaus

Now, now now...

1. Whitney
2. Jennifer Hudson
3. Kelly Clarkson & Beyoncé

not quite.

1. Whitney Houston
2. Mariah Carey
3. Jordin Sparks
4. Kelly Clarkson
5. Jennifer Hudson

Still, Kelly's the only live one.

[Signs]

Beyonce.

[julesknowles]

not here for the corny choir

[Nerevanin]

Kellegend

[dhilamilan1899]

sorry guys,... i choose kelly clarkson all the way

[InLoveWithKaty]

Kelly. Her vocals here is just....

[Konichiwa]

Kelly. Beyonce's is nice though.

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Who knew the queen has so much love on ATRL?!? I guess true talent does win...in the end...WHAT DOESN'T KILL YOU MAKES YOU STRONGER!

But seriously, Beyoncé did extremely well, doing it as extravagantly as she could but not overdoing it with too many trills and frills. But Kelly had that extra soul in her voice that made more people connect with it. But both are from Texas and both twerked it.

[Chivas]

Didn't Beyonce lip sync hers? Doesn't that mean Kelly kinda wins by default?

[Sláy]

Originally posted by Comedor

Kelly who?

Beyonce is only comparable to Whitney Houston. All the other gerls are welcome to try.

TRUE TEA!! SPILL IT! Kelly's wasn't memorable. Bey, Whit and Mariah. Trinity.

[Lasers]

Originally posted by Chivas

Didn't Beyonce lip sync hers? Doesn't that mean Kelly kinda wins by default?

Yeah Bey's was lipped.

Both are ****ing amazing though, so hard to choose.