[DanceFreak]

1. Umbrella VS Bad Romance
2. Disturbia VS Poker Face
3. SOS VS Born This Way
4. Don't Stop The Music VS Just Dance
5. Russian Roulette VS Bloody Mary
6. Rude Boy VS LoveGame
7. Only Girl VS Judas
8. Hard VS Alejandro
9. Firebomb VS Dance in the Dark
10. What's My Name? VS Paparazzi
11. Te Amo VS Americano
12. S&M VS Telephone
13. California King Bed VS You and I
14. Breakin' Dishes VS Scheiße
15. Unfaithful VS The Edge of Glory
16. Skin VS Paper Gangsta
17. Man Down VS Government Hooker
18. Rockstar101 VS Heavy Metal Lover

Gaga:18
Rihanna: 0

[Pokistic]

Umbrella VS Bad Romance
Disturbia VS Poker Face
SOS VS Born This Way
Don't Stop The Music VS Just Dance
Russian Roulette VS Bloody Mary
Rude Boy VS LoveGame
Only Girl VS Judas
Hard VS Alejandro
Firebomb VS Dance in the Dark
What's My Name? VS Paparazzi
Te Amo VS Americano
S&M VS Telephone
California King Bed VS You and I
Breakin' Dishes VS Scheiße
Unfaithful VS The Edge of Glory
Skin VS Paper Gangsta
Man Down VS Government Hooker
Rockstar101 VS Heavy Metal Lover

[Luna]

Umbrella VS Bad Romance
Disturbia VS Poker Face
SOS VS Born This Way
Don't Stop The Music VS Just Dance
Russian Roulette VS Bloody Mary
Rude Boy VS LoveGame
Only Girl VS Judas
Hard VS Alejandro
Firebomb VS Dance in the Dark
What's My Name? VS Paparazzi
Te Amo VS Americano
S&M VS Telephone
California King Bed VS You and I
Breakin' Dishes VS Scheiße
Unfaithful VS The Edge of Glory
Skin VS Paper Gangsta
Man Down VS Government Hooker TIE
Rockstar101 VS Heavy Metal Lover

Wow. I really do like both of their music I guess it was just how they were paired off.

[alstrom]

Umbrella VS Bad Romance
Disturbia VS Poker Face
SOS VS Born This Way
Don't Stop The Music VS Just Dance
Russian Roulette VS Bloody Mary
Rude Boy VS LoveGame
Only Girl VS Judas
Hard VS Alejandro
Firebomb VS Dance in the Dark
What's My Name? VS Paparazzi
Te Amo VS Americano
S&M VS Telephone
California King Bed VS Yoü and I
Breakin' Dishes VS Scheiße
Unfaithful VS The Edge of Glory
Skin VS Paper Gangsta
Man Down VS Government Hooker
Rockstar101 VS Heavy Metal Lover

17 - 1 to Gaga

[KarlosVzla]

Umbrella VS Bad Romance
Disturbia VS Poker Face
SOS VS Born This Way
Don't Stop The Music VS Just Dance
Russian Roulette VS Bloody Mary
Rude Boy VS LoveGame
Only Girl VS Judas
Hard VS Alejandro
Firebomb VS Dance in the Dark
What's My Name? VS Paparazzi
Te Amo VS Americano
S&M VS Telephone
California King Bed VS You and I
Breakin' Dishes VS Scheiße
Unfaithful VS The Edge of Glory
Skin VS Paper Gangsta
Man Down VS Government Hooker
Rockstar101 VS Heavy Metal Lover

[JackOfHearts]

Umbrella VS Bad Romance
Disturbia VS Poker Face
SOS VS Born This Way
Don't Stop The Music VS Just Dance
Russian Roulette VS Bloody Mary
Rude Boy VS LoveGame
Only Girl VS Judas
Hard VS Alejandro
Firebomb VS Dance in the Dark
What's My Name? VS Paparazzi
Te Amo VS Americano
S&M VS Telephone
California King Bed VS You and I
Breakin' Dishes VS Scheiße
Unfaithful VS The Edge of Glory
Skin VS Paper Gangsta
Man Down VS Government Hooker
Rockstar101 VS Heavy Metal Lover

Rihanna: 3
Lady Gaga: 12
Tie: 3

I simply couldn't pick between Umbrella/Bad Romance, Only Girl/Judas, and Breakin' Dishes/Shieße.

[Remmy]

Umbrella VS Bad Romance
Disturbia VS Poker Face
SOS VS Born This Way
Don't Stop The Music VS Just Dance
Russian Roulette VS Bloody Mary
Rude Boy VS LoveGame
Only Girl VS Judas
Hard VS Alejandro
Firebomb VS Dance in the Dark
What's My Name? VS Paparazzi
Te Amo VS Americano
S&M VS Telephone
California King Bed VS You and I
Breakin' Dishes VS Scheiße
Unfaithful VS The Edge of Glory
Skin VS Paper Gangsta
Man Down VS Government Hooker
Rockstar101 VS Heavy Metal Lover

5 - 14

[thewaitinggame]

1. Umbrella VS Bad Romance
2. Disturbia VS Poker Face
3. SOS VS Born This Way
4. Don't Stop The Music VS Just Dance
5. Russian Roulette VS Bloody Mary
6. Rude Boy VS LoveGame
7. Only Girl VS Judas
8. Hard VS Alejandro
9. Firebomb VS Dance in the Dark
10. What's My Name? VS Paparazzi
11. Te Amo VS Americano
12. S&M VS Telephone
13. California King Bed VS You and I
14. Breakin' Dishes VS Scheiße
15. Unfaithful VS The Edge of Glory
16. Skin VS Paper Gangsta
17. Man Down VS Government Hooker
18. Rockstar101 VS Heavy Metal Lover

this poll made me realize how awful gaga's music truly is

[XChrisX]

1. Umbrella VS Bad Romance
2. Disturbia VS Poker Face
3. SOS VS Born This Way
4. Don't Stop The Music VS Just Dance
5. Russian Roulette VS Bloody Mary
6. Rude Boy VS LoveGame
7. Only Girl VS Judas
8. Hard VS Alejandro
9. Firebomb VS Dance in the Dark
10. What's My Name? VS Paparazzi
11. Te Amo VS Americano
12. S&M VS Telephone
13. California King Bed VS You and I
14. Breakin' Dishes VS Scheiße
15. Unfaithful VS The Edge of Glory
16. Skin VS Paper Gangsta
17. Man Down VS Government Hooker
18. Rockstar101 VS Heavy Metal Lover

I didn't vote for the tracks I haven't listened to fully to be fair.

But for the songs I have listened to, it's like this:
Rihanna: 6
Gaga: 9

[Rico Shameless v2]

Umbrella VS Bad Romance
Disturbia VS Poker Face
SOS VS Born This Way
Don't Stop The Music VS Just Dance
Russian Roulette VS Bloody Mary
Rude Boy VS LoveGame
Only Girl VS Judas
Hard VS Alejandro
Firebomb VS Dance in the Dark (hate both)
What's My Name? VS Paparazzi
Te Amo VS Americano
S&M VS Telephone
California King Bed VS You and I (hate both)
Breakin' Dishes VS Scheiße
Unfaithful VS The Edge of Glory
Skin VS Paper Gangsta
Man Down VS Government Hooker
Rockstar101 VS Heavy Metal Lover

Rihanna - 5
GaGa - 11

[Cas]

I can't at majority of you prefering Bad Romance over Umbrella

[Strangergab]

1. Umbrella VS Bad Romance
2. Disturbia VS Poker Face BOTH
3. SOS VS Born This Way
4. Don't Stop The Music VS Just Dance
5. Russian Roulette VS Bloody Mary
6. Rude Boy VS LoveGame
7. Only Girl VS Judas
8. Hard VS Alejandro
9. Firebomb VS Dance in the Dark
10. What's My Name? VS Paparazzi
11. Te Amo VS Americano
12. S&M VS Telephone
13. California King Bed VS You and I
14. Breakin' Dishes VS Scheiße
15. Unfaithful VS The Edge of Glory
16. Skin VS Paper Gangsta
17. Man Down VS Government Hooker NONE
18. Rockstar101 VS Heavy Metal Lover

[Strangergab]

Originally posted by Cas

I can't at majority of you prefering Bad Romance over Umbrella

Because is way better

[Rock That Beat...]

Umbrella VS Bad Romance
Disturbia VS Poker Face
SOS VS Born This Way
Don't Stop The Music VS Just Dance
Russian Roulette VS Bloody Mary
Rude Boy VS LoveGame
Only Girl VS Judas
Hard VS Alejandro
Firebomb VS Dance in the Dark
What's My Name? VS Paparazzi
Te Amo VS Americano
S&M VS Telephone
California King Bed VS You and I
Breakin' Dishes VS Scheiße
Unfaithful VS The Edge of Glory
Skin VS Paper Gangsta
Man Down VS Government Hooker
Rockstar101 VS Heavy Metal Lover

Rihanna = 12
Gaga = 6

[Cas]

Umbrella VS Bad Romance
Disturbia VS Poker Face
SOS VS Born This Way
Don't Stop The Music VS Just Dance
Russian Roulette VS Bloody Mary
Rude Boy VS LoveGame
Only Girl VS Judas
Hard VS Alejandro
Firebomb VS Dance in the Dark
What's My Name? VS Paparazzi Tie.
Te Amo VS Americano
S&M VS Telephone
California King Bed VS You and I
Breakin' Dishes VS Scheiße
Unfaithful VS The Edge of Glory
Skin VS Paper Gangsta
Man Down VS Government Hooker Tie.
Rockstar101 VS Heavy Metal Lover Tie.

[Cas]

Originally posted by Duca

I really cannot understand how can anyone pick "Bad Romance" over "Umbrella." GaGa will never come close to recording something like that.

Those drums, those vocals >>>>>>>>

This.