OK...they need to quit with this. The judges need to be Simon, Nicole Scherzinger, Mariah Carey, and a songwriter/producer for the 4th. Simple. Done. Bring it on
No. Cheryl gonna be on that panel, and if not, this show is going down the drain. Im happy with my UK one anyway
Keep this in mind guys, most of us didn't know Simon Cowell or Randy Jackson before American Idol.
But I still don't think Cheryl should join the US show. She isn't known here and I'm not sure how the American public will react to her. But then again, think of all the amazing gifs we could have.