Well, only one of my games showed up in the close calls (Shenmue not making the list is a real shame). Gunstar Heroes is also too low, but I guess I expected that.
Bioshock is kind of overrated, but I thought that it was going to be higher. I would have said the same about MW, but not when MW2, MW3 and Black Ops are undoubtedly making this list.
Is it possible to argue that not knowing Super Metroid is a sin? I'm not even hugely into the game like so many people are, but it's undeniably one of the greatest games ever made.
Also, Final Fantasy Tactics came really close to making my list. Still my favorite strategy game ever.