Like A Virgin vs. S.O.S.
Crazy For You vs.
Umbrella
Live To Tell vs.
Take a Bow
Papa Don't Preach vs. Disturbia
Open Your Heart vs. Live Your Life
Who's That Girl vs.
Rude Boy
Like A Prayer vs. Love The Way You Lie
Vogue vs. Only Girl (In The World)
Justify My Love vs. What's My Name?
This Used To Be My Playground vs.
S&M
Take A Bow vs.
We Found Love
Music vs.
Diamonds
6 - 6
EDIT: Wait just a damn minute! This is including features! she doesn't have 12 #1s