|
Rate the American Idols: Season 5!
Member Since: 10/5/2005
Posts: 11,422
|
Wow, everyone’s rankings are very different from each other tonight. Good Job People! J
First off, set aside AI, and it doesn't have anything to do with the post, but I am really disappointed with Fox. The War at home is a lousy comedy that should’ve been off the air by now. The only reason why it’s having success is because of the hot time slots its been given. I will not watch that BS after AI. There are worthy comedies that should have hold of the time slot. – (Arrested Development could’ve used it.)
But back on track to AI:
Offset (People that I didn’t really care for, but don’t see going.):
Kellie – What a character, she is a very unique girl, country is turning into city story. The performance, to me, wasn’t there for me half the time, but America loves her. She could easily break into the top 8. I prefer Fantasia’s rendition of the song she did a couple years ago.
Mandisa – She knows that this wasn’t her strongest performance, and it wasn’t great in my perspective. I think what got me negative was the arrangement, and a couple notes which were out of place. But I think we’re going to see some huge performances in the future from her, and hopefully some more practical jokes/pranks/tricks. J
Melissa – I hate country, but I thought she did well, and the performance is forgettable. She might be around next week.
“Chopping block” material:
Kinnik – I hate country. She did OK, could stay around another next week, but I see her going at the same time.
Heather – First off, wow, she was brave for picking Carey. But I thought she did good-OK, but didn’t it. I don’t think she’ll be going home, but I wouldn’t be suprised.
Brenna – The only thing that’s keeping her afloat is her personality on camera. I did not like her again this week, wasn’t feeling her. But I wouldn’t mind seeing her clash with Simon again next week.
My Current Picks:
Katherine – Did a good job, and will go on. I like the fact that she and Kellie act like complete dorks outside of the competition. J
Paris – I disagree with the judges saying Paris was playing old; she was showing her range as a performer this week. Paris chose this song for her family, which I have a respect for, and she performed it with a high Elegance. She will get my 2nd vote
Ayla – She did the best this week. And she’s kinda hot... Way to go for her. She gets my 1st vote.
Lisa – Improved, better than last week. – (I thought she was overrated.) I liked her tonight.
In the end:- Ayla (Best.)
- Paris
- Katherine
- Lisa
- Mandisa
- Melissa
- Kellie
- Heather
- Kinnik
- Brenna (Bye)
|
|
|
Member Since: 12/22/2003
Posts: 983
|
mandisa
ayla
lisa
paris
kellie
melissa
katharine
heather
kinnik
brenna
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/2/2004
Posts: 5,939
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mikal
Aww, poor Mugshot not liking people not liking Ayla.
Anyways, 10 Women...who make me want to shove a pen into my eyes.
Paris (8/10) - Hate the song, LOVE THE VOCALS! That's how you sell a ballad, damn it! Plus, she seems to get the song better than any of the other females.
Lisa (5/10) - She tries to just tick off the boxes of vocal ability, but she refuses to connect. Yes, she's 16, but if you don't "get" a song, don't sing it. Even if you can, don't. Once again scored high because she can sing, not cuz I liked it.
Ayla (4/10) - A LOT of vibratto causing her head to shake. Maybe her battery was dying down. Rather bland and boring and TOO DAMN SMILEY!
Melissa (4/10) - Are you TRYING to go home? Now she does a gimmick song after testing my patience with Faith. Better than last week and sassy songs work for her, but very pageantish. And she was in and out sometimes and she didn't connect all that well, but it worked better than last week.
Kinnik (3/10) - Gretchen Wilson? This was one odd perf, since last week she had the tech chops and she lost it all to have "personality." Maybe sang a third of the words and mumbled/garbled the rest.
Kellie (3/10) - You. Are. Not. Paybee. She still gets way to flat during anything that lasts longer than two seconds and rather dull during the chorus. Better than last week, but not by much. And the Trio can stop shoving her down my throat. Is there a brain in there?
Katherine (2/10) - You silly? Or dumb? Neeeeeeeeever. So she might not be a clam, but her performance is dull as hell. And why are you wearing formal shorts with Cheeto's old pregger shirt? In and out of pitch for most of the song.
Mandisa (2/10) - Cry? What? What an all-over-the-place perforance. Lots of off notes and weird hand motions. Definite downgrade from last week. And it's DOIN', not doing.
Heather (1/10) - Dear Mariah (CC Mimi): KILL HEATHER! She can't open a song, she probably should never smile or wear that again, and made a rather deep song as light and fluffy as her hair. Even more pageanty than Melissa. AND NO MORE HIGH NOTES DUMBASS. I should give you a 0 just for the worst high note in history, and might even rival Sway's perf as worst ever.
Brenna (1/10) - PLEASE LET THIS BE HER LAST DANCE! It killed Ryan Starr! Flat some more, while posing and trying to repeat the same line forever. Rank ass verse section. I didn't think anyone could be worse tha dumbass Heather. Yay, I was wrong. She gets a 1 for Bitchface, though!
Should Be Last 3 - Mandisa, Heather, Brenna
Should Go Home - Heather, Brenna
Wll Be Leavin' - Heather, Melissa
|
Ayla is a ----ing godess compared to that deformed midget clown named Paris.
|
|
|
Member Since: 5/3/2003
Posts: 8,091
|
AHAHAHAHAHAH good one Mugshot!
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 9/24/2001
Posts: 10,763
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mugshot
Ayla is a ----ing godess compared to that deformed midget clown named Paris.
|
*gives Mugshot a cookie to help calm him down*
Jesus people, we do not all have to like the same people. Just because some of us haven't been betwixed by the Jolly Robotic Giant doesn't mean ****. Hell, can we all agree that brenna and Heather should go the hell home rather than whine that not everyone loves the bland boring white girl? Yeesh.
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/2/2004
Posts: 5,939
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mikal
*gives Mugshot a cookie to help calm him down*
Jesus people, we do not all have to like the same people. Just because some of us haven't been betwixed by the Jolly Robotic Giant doesn't mean ****. Hell, can we all agree that brenna and Heather should go the hell home rather than whine that not everyone loves the bland boring white girl? Yeesh.
|
You're attempt at making a backhanded comment really failed, Mikal.
|
|
|
Member Since: 4/27/2002
Posts: 4,083
|
I was really dissapointed in Katharine's performance... I hope America doesn't vote her off because of it. She is one of the best vocalists there, even though she had a rather dull performance.
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/21/2005
Posts: 4,456
|
Top picks after last night (in random order):
Paris, Mandisa, Lisa, Ayla
People that need to go:
Brenna, Heather
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/22/2004
Posts: 2,991
|
My top pick: Kellie
3 people I think need to go: Paris, Heather, and Brenna
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 9/24/2001
Posts: 10,763
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mugshot
You're attempt at making a backhanded comment really failed, Mikal.
|
CHICKEN! ^_^
And me? Make a backhanded comment? Never! *gives Mugshot yet another cookie*
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/2/2004
Posts: 5,939
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mikal
CHICKEN! ^_^
And me? Make a backhanded comment? Never! *gives Mugshot yet another cookie*
|
Where are you getting all the cookies from?
|
|
|
ATRL Senior Member
Member Since: 1/5/2002
Posts: 11,088
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Mugshot
Ayla is fantasitc. If she was black and sang like she came from the ghetto you guys would love her.
|
OMG THATS WHAT MY FRIEND SAID TODAY IN LUNCH oooomgg that is so weird. lol
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/6/2005
Posts: 17,088
|
Right when Taylor was singing that song I thought of Bo singing. Then I saw that Bo was there!?! Psychic?
Taylor sounded okay, I love that song.
Elliott ^____^ AWESOME!!!!
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/22/2005
Posts: 13,429
|
01. Melissa - 9.7/10 (Prettiest last night too, I noticed she kinda looks like Katie from Road Rules)
02. Mandisa - 9.5/10
03. Paris - 9/10
04. Kinnik - 8/10
05. Ayla - 7/10
06. Kellie - 7/10 (LMAO, I love her, she has such a cute personality)
07. Katharine - 7/10
08. Heather - 6/10
09. Brenna - 5/10
10. Lisa - 3/10 (I'm sorry but she was flat the entire song!)
Should Go Home
Brenna & Lisa
Will Go Home
Heather & Brenna
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/6/2005
Posts: 17,088
|
Dude Chad, why the f.uck should Lisa go home? You're weird for thinking that.
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/22/2005
Posts: 13,429
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Sir. Will
Dude Chad, why the f.uck should Lisa go home? You're weird for thinking that.
|
She had the worst performance last night. Where you hearing the same thing? She wasn't on the right note the whole time, she was flat through all of it. At least the others were on key through theirs.
I know she won't go home, but my opinion is my opinion. And her being flat is a damn near fact!
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/6/2005
Posts: 17,088
|
Gedeon MOST LIKELY just stole the show with that fantastic performance.
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/19/2003
Posts: 3,226
|
9.7 AYLA - was very surprised, slow song but did not bore me
9.6 MELISSA - great song choice, fits her voice perfectly
9.0 MANDISA - made her own but just wasnt the best
9.0 KELLIE - cant help but love her, few pitch problems but enjoyed it
8.9 PARIS - sounded great...just something missing?
8.6 KINNIK - fun song, not bad, i dunno just not a fan
8.3 KATHARINE - big fan but what happened? it bore me
7.0 LISA - wasnt bad but it was almost there... she can do so much better
4.0 BRENNA - mediocre performance
1.0 HEATHER - big risk when you sing mariah songs, didnt do justice at all
|
|
|
Member Since: 7/2/2004
Posts: 5,939
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kaos
9.7 AYLA - was very surprised, slow song but did not bore me
9.6 MELISSA - great song choice, fits her voice perfectly
9.0 MANDISA - made her own but just wasnt the best
9.0 KELLIE - cant help but love her, few pitch problems but enjoyed it
8.9 PARIS - sounded great...just something missing?
8.6 KINNIK - fun song, not bad, i dunno just not a fan
8.3 KATHARINE - big fan but what happened? it bore me
7.0 LISA - wasnt bad but it was almost there... she can do so much better
4.0 BRENNA - mediocre performance
1.0 HEATHER - big risk when you sing mariah songs, didnt do justice at all
|
I love you?
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/22/2005
Posts: 13,429
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kaos
9.7 AYLA - was very surprised, slow song but did not bore me
9.6 MELISSA - great song choice, fits her voice perfectly
9.0 MANDISA - made her own but just wasnt the best
9.0 KELLIE - cant help but love her, few pitch problems but enjoyed it
8.9 PARIS - sounded great...just something missing?
8.6 KINNIK - fun song, not bad, i dunno just not a fan
8.3 KATHARINE - big fan but what happened? it bore me
7.0 LISA - wasnt bad but it was almost there... she can do so much better
4.0 BRENNA - mediocre performance
1.0 HEATHER - big risk when you sing mariah songs, didnt do justice at all
|
Wow, your rating a a lot like mine.
|
|
|
|
|