With You is eliminated because it is the only song that didn't have immunity vote while No One received the immunity because it didn't have any point in the elimination for in the previous round.
The Contenders:
- Alicia Keys "No One"
- Ashlee Simpson "Outta My Head"
- Britney Spears "Piece Of Me"
- Gwen Stefani "Early Winter"
- Janet Jackson "Feedback"
- Rihanna f/ Ne-Yo "Hate That I Love You"
- Sara Bareilles "Love Song"
- Timbaland f/ Keri Hilson & Nicole Scherzinger "Scream"
Voted Off:
- Chris Brown "With You"
- Colbie Caillat "Bubbly"
- Taylor Swift "Teardrops On My Guitar"
- Alicia Keys "Like You'll Never See Me Again"
- Jennifer Lopez "Hold It Don't Drop It"
- Jordin Sparks "Tattoo"
- Lifehouse "Whatever It Takes"
- Daughtry "Feels Like Tonight"
- Christina Aguilera "Save Me From Myself"
- Spice Girls "Headlines (Friendship Never Ends)"
- Simple Plan "When I'm Gone"
- Carrie Underwood "Ever Ever After"
- Ne-Yo "Go On Girl"
- Boys Like Girls "Hero/Heroine"
- Daughtry "Crashed"
- Elliott Yamin "One Word"
- Blake Lewis "Break Anotha'"
- The Red Jumpsuit Apparatus "Your Guardian Angel"
- Timbaland f/ OneRepublic "Apologize" (December 2007 Winner)
- Britney Spears "Gimme More" (November 2007 Winner)
- Paramore "crushcrushcrush" (October 2007 Winner)
Immunity:
- Alicia Keys "No One"
Vote Off 2, Save 1
Off:
- Ashlee Simpson "Outta My Head"
- Gwen Stefani "Early Winter"
Save:
- Britney Spears "Piece Of Me"
