[Ascension]

Originally posted by Ressti

But.. Blackstar only 3 more #1 placements than LEMONADE (21 and 18 respectively) and that's because many rock publications wouldn't review LEMONADE. He has about 10 more placements (and reviews) than Beyoncé.

Like Piccadilly Records...
http://www.albumoftheyear.org/list/5...bums-of-2016/2

They didn't even put LEMONADE in the top 100 list, because it's not an alternative or rock album.

But anyway, if this is how we're measuring quality, Blackstar is better reviewed, but not by much. They're pretty equal in the eyes of critics.

Blackstar honestly isn't even better reviewed, just more broadly featured since there are far more small time publications that are rock/indie based that will include a random rap album here or there to prove ~inclusion, but won't touch R&B with a ten foot pole. Bey has gotten more #1 and 2nd/3rd place rankings among the proper multi-genre lists.

[Digitalism]

Lemonade is great but you sound so insecure
Both album of the year and metacritic place Blackstar at number 1. There is nothing wrong in comming at second place

[J-esper]

[zombaland]

ANTI at #12

[Sunshine.]

Omg. I thought it was Blackstar. This is such a nice surprise

Bey always wins

[ultraviolento]

Originally posted by Digitalism

Lemonade is great but you sound so insecure
Both album of the year and metacritic place Blackstar at number 1. There is nothing wrong in comming at second place

Yeah, but those include global lists so it's not hard to understand why Lemonade stats arent as good.

BBC only used local lists!

[Teezy]

Originally posted by ultraviolento

Yeah, but those include global lists so it's not hard to understand why Lemonade stats arent as good.

BBC only used local lists!

You're such a weird ****ing loser

[QueenBLadyG]

Originally posted by Teezy

You're such a weird ****ing loser

Holy ****.

[Digitalism]

Originally posted by ultraviolento

Yeah, but those include global lists so it's not hard to understand why Lemonade stats arent as good.

BBC only used local lists!

The BBC is from the UK and there is several american publications there
they handpicked whatever they wanted and made list
Complete lists with all the critics show Blackstar at #1 and that's the end of it

[ultraviolento]

Originally posted by Digitalism

The BBC is from the UK and there is several american publications there
they handpicked whatever they wanted and made list
Complete lists with all the critics show Blackstar at #1 and that's the end of it

I agrih

[T-Swizz]

Originally posted by Digitalism

Lemonade is great but you sound so insecure
Both album of the year and metacritic place Blackstar at number 1. There is nothing wrong in comming at second place

MC placed Bowie @ #9

[Sunshine.]

Originally posted by Digitalism

The BBC is from the UK and there is several american publications there
they handpicked whatever they wanted and made list
Complete lists with all the critics show Blackstar at #1 and that's the end of it

If Bowie can't get nominated for AOTY this isn't true at all

[T-Swizz]

Originally posted by Sunshine.

If Bowie can't get nominated for AOTY this isn't true at all

They fabricated Bowie's Metacritic position

[Ressti]

Originally posted by Digitalism

The BBC is from the UK and there is several american publications there
they handpicked whatever they wanted and made list
Complete lists with all the critics show Blackstar at #1 and that's the end of it

No, they picked lists that were more inclusive as far as genre. What sense does it make to include lists that only feature indie and rock music?

[ultraviolento]

Originally posted by T-Swizz

MC placed Bowie @ #9

http://www.metacritic.com/feature/cr...of-2016?ref=hp

aint you tired of always being WRONG?

[Lyrical.]

Professional critics & the GP > typical Hive hating ATRL members.

Yeah, I would be hurt too.

[pieuxvu]

Originally posted by Dopeamine

Lemonade is so overrated at this point. Anti, Blonde, ASATT, LOP are much better records and have much higher replay value.

The critics disagrees. Try again next time.

Originally posted by Dark XXX

I agree,.

Lemonade is a good album but critics are overpraising it because it was released by Beyonce. No other black artist would have got this amount of acclaim if they released it. Plus the possibility of them being called racist if critics were to criticise it.

Failed shade again.
None of Bey album receives this kind of acclaim.

[Crescendolls.]

Originally posted by KORDEI

poor ultraviolento. Not only did Lemonade outsell Blackstar, it's also nominated for AOTY (regardless of if it wins or not, it still has a chance unlike Blackstar) and now it's also the most acclaimed album of the YEAR! mess!

[QueenBLadyG]

Originally posted by Ressti

No, they picked lists that were more inclusionary as far as genre. What sense does it make to include lists that only feature indie and rock music?

They don't care about it not being fair for Bey. As long as they can boast about something, common sense and dignity fly out the window.

[Sunshine.]

Originally posted by Ressti

No, they picked lists that were more inclusive as far as genre. What sense does it make to include lists that only feature indie and rock music?

And them ignoring the lists you emailed them

That's some shady **** to do as an aggregate collector.