Definetly Christina. Pinks music always sounds the same. Christina is ever changing and you never know hows shes gonna sound next. The other two never really went far.
P!nk will never be a diva.
P!nk will never have the vocal range Christina has.
P!nk will never have near the beauty Christina has.
P!nk will never have the success and impact Christina has.
But P!nk will always be jealous of Christina.
Sorry, but the truth must hurt for y'all.
- you don't need to be a diva to be a respected artist
- Pink has her own thing going on vocally.
- irrelevant to the discussion. Actually puts Pink's talents into a better light, by showing how a talented act can become successful with average looks
- She already has
- Pink is the one who praised You Lost Me on her twitter. I don't think anyone can get classier than that.
Pink is a rock diva, she has an incredible and VERY unique vocal range, she is gorgeous and always has been, and has had a lot of success in almost everything she has ever done. While I think that XTina wins this one, to take it to the level of hating on Pink just because you are a stan makes everything you say less credible. Sorry bout it!
This is my personal opinion, of course.
If I'm about to write something not biased on this forum, I'm going to say it before. But almost everybody on ATRL is biased, so... let's leave it there.
I think Christina is miles better and she was the center point of Lady Marmelade anyways.
"Accessible" music? Not many people are doing pop/rock and having success with it at this very time. Not Avril. Not Kelly. Not anyone you hear on radio at this current moment, except Pink. And no one looks at Christina when she's here or gone, so that's a moot point.
WHOA!!!! I Just Died in Your Arms Tonight...................
Sales then were a whole lot more compared to now. If Bionic were released then it would have trumped over Try This tbh. Try This flew under the radar and she wasn't even as popular either.
Sales weren't too better though honestly. 2003 was basically the beginning of illegal downloads coming to the forefront. So even though downloading music illegally was heard of, it wasn't very prevalent until the early millennium. Anywho, for the sake of the poll, Pink has had the better career overall. They've both have had their peaks, but Pink's career has successfully stabilized while Xtina's has somewhat floundered.
I can't even believe all of the pressed back and forth on this forum...
I just think you guys are waaaay too focused on what is going on right now in this moment when that wasn't the topic at all.
XTina was huge on her debut, her comeback with Stripped was critically acclaimed as a step out of the teen pop arena and sales backed it up, she was applauded all around for her vocals on Back to Basics and had a #1 record with it, she had a mildly successful movie this year, and even with the flopping of Bionic, don't act like everyone wasn't buzzing about it. Or that it wasn't the #2 most illegally downloaded album of the year. People ARE still interested. OBVIOUSLY people are interested in Pink too, because she is amazing and consistent.
But in the end: SALES, ENDORSEMENTS, MEDIA ATTENTION, MOVIES, AWARDS... XTINA > PINK. Better career. Da end.
Even if Bionic didn't flop I'd say they were about equal & as far as Stripped. It wasnt that critically acclaimed and metacritic can agree with me
Bionic being the 2nd most illegally dL'd album is nothing to brag about because even if they did do that they didnt go out and BUY THE PRODUCT which is what counts in the first place.
And as far as Burlesque nobody was buzzing about it in a positive way. It got comparisons to Glitter from jump street &most of the reviewers dragged it so lets not act like that was so well received either. And to add insult to injury Cher won an award for her song in the movie and shes not even the lead.
Quote:
Originally posted by xChunk
P!nk will never be a diva.
P!nk will never have the vocal range Christina has.
P!nk will never have near the beauty Christina has.
P!nk will never have the success and impact Christina has.
But P!nk will always be jealous of Christina.
Sorry, but the truth must hurt for y'all.
Pink is a rocker chick not a diva
P!nk doesnt need to because X-tina dosnt even know what to do witth her own vocal range
P!nk doesnt need X-tinas beauty
& P!nk gave Xtina props for her song & singing... does that sound like a jealous person to you?
I didn't say that she didn't do it. But P!nk is a rock chick who has made some amazing covers through the years, live covers and nailed it while singing them.
I'm just saying that you can't exactly say that P!nk will never get to touch the vocal range Christina owns. P!nk is killing it with her unique raspy voice.
Pink and Christina.
I've never heard of Mya outside Lady Marmalade and I don't follow Lil Kim's career at all so I really have no idea what's going on in it. lol
P!nk will never be a diva.
P!nk will never have the vocal range Christina has.
P!nk will never have near the beauty Christina has.
P!nk will never have the success and impact Christina has.
But P!nk will always be jealous of Christina.
Sorry, but the truth must hurt for y'all.
You just made me laugh so hard, hun. You're so funny
Christina has been on the decline for YEARS. 8x Platinum to 4x Platinum to 1x Platinum to 2x Aluminum.
You're right...I mean Cher/Janet Jackson/Whitney Houston haven't really had a hit album for a few years. I GUESSSSSS Pink has a better career than them too!
