Discussion: Are These The 20 Biggest Eras by Pop Gurls This Decade? - Page 6

Prismy

Quote:

Originally posted by ezra

This decade's biggest:
1. 21
2. The Fame Monster
3. 1989
4. LOUD
5. Born This Way
6. Teenage dream
7. Red
8. The Truth About Love
9. BEYONCE
10. 4
11. Pink Friday
12. Born to Die
13. Prism
14. Bangerz
15. Unapologetic
16. Talk that Talk
17. Speak Now
18. ARTPOP
19. Title
20. My Everything

TD is bigger than LOUD and BTW.

PRISM is bigger than 4, Pink Friday and BTD.

ezra

Quote:

Originally posted by Capricorn

Bangerz and PRISM should be higher imo.
Bangerz had 2 big hits and the era got LOADS of attention
PRISM had also 2 smash hits, unlike e.g 4 or Born To Die

4 was wildly acclaimed though. And it's tour is huge. So, I took into consideration those areas of success and decided Prism was much less successful. Considering it's only here because of it's 2 big singles anyway it felt weird putting it up so high.

LoKoPaNdA

Quote:

Originally posted by ezra

TFM has 7 top 10 hits and 2 #1's. Bad Romance alone outsold SIO and Blank Space combined. And yea no 1989 is huge but 7 million is only half of TFM's 14-15 million. It won Grammy's and had a 200M+ debut tour as well so it's definitely a bigger era than all of these except 21.

The Fame is not accounted for, just The Fame Monster EP

Taylor will get Grammys and a 200M+ tour as well. And like I said, selling 8M in 2015 is unheard of.

But everyone's welcome to his own opinion

P!nk Forever

'Greatest Hits... So Far!!!' was a bigger era than 'Artpop' indisputably.

If you disagree it was always still bigger than Ariana's 'My Everything' era.

Cain

Quote:

Originally posted by jax.

um no. TTT, Bangerz, Prism, and Unapologetic are nowhere close to as big as BEYONCÉ.

They really are girl, sorry

Theus

Quote:

24. Stars Dance
25. DEMI

if these two are here then why carly's kiss isn't there when its above both

Prismy

Acclaim should not play too big a factor when determining an album's success imo.

Bey_Rihstan

21
The Fame Monster
Teenage Dream
1989
Born This Way
The Truth About Love
RED
loud
Speak Now
PRISM
Talk That Talk
Unapologetic
Born to Die
Pure Heroine
BEYONCÉ
Pink Friday
Bangerz
4
Animal
Femme Fatale
ARTPOP

actually I feel like 4/Beyonce should be higher mess idk where to place them

ezra

Quote:

Originally posted by LoKoPaNdA

The Fame is not accounted for, just The Fame Monster EP

Taylor will get Grammys and a 200M+ tour as well. And like I said, selling 8M in 2015 is unheard of.

But everyone's welcome to his own opinion

The Fame/Monster is one era. I'm counting eras in your thread about biggest eras. So, 15M in 2010 is unheard of as well and hasn't been done by anyone other than Adele since. You're welcome to your own opinion though

Kots

Quote:

Originally posted by jax.

ajsdklasj oh

oops

poor kats!

According to IFPI, PRISM is at 4.1 million

KillingYourCareer

Quote:

Originally posted by ultraviolento

1. 21
2. TD
3. 1989
4. TFM
5. TTAL
6. Red
7. Prism
8. Loud
9. BTW
10. PF/BTD

This sounds much more legit, with BTD at #10 and Red a little bit lower maybe

HEIDI

MDNA, ARTPOP, BEYONCÉ, Pure Heroine, and Talk That Talk weren't strong eras.

LoKoPaNdA

Quote:

Originally posted by Theus

if these two are here then why carly's kiss isn't there when its above both

I thought Kiss was at 1M? Anyway, you may be right. CMM is one of the best selling singles of all time after all

Cyanide

Quote:

Originally posted by gerardsuxx

ARTPOP era:
1.9M
Applause #4
DWYW #13
GUY #76

Femme Fatale era:
1.9M
HIAM #1
TTWE #3
IWG #7

Femme Fatale WINS

ARTPOP hit 2M like last year.

gerardsuxx

1. 21
2. 1989
3. Teenage Dream
4. The Fame Monster (just the EP monsters, The Fame was released in 2008!!!!)
5. Born This Way
6. Loud
7. RED
8. PRISM
9. Unapologetic
10. Born to Die
11. The Truth About Love
12. Talk That Talk
13. BEYONCÉ
14. Animal
15. Pink Friday
16. Greatest Hits... So Far!!! (sold 4M, had a #1 single and a #2 single).
17. Bangerz
18. 4
19. Femme Fatale
20. My Everything

Floyd Mayweather

Where's 4
It was more successful than Artpop

Tristan

My Everything is bigger than ARTPOP and Title

Dessy Fenix

Quote:

14. Pure Heroine
15. Bangerz
16. BEYONCÉ
17. MDNA
18. Animal
19. ARTPOP
20. Title

What even

alestevens

I mostly agree with the list except of:

-Born To Die and The Truth About Love should sweep places

-BEYONCÉ should be one spot above of Talk That Talk

-Bangerz should be one spot above Pure Heroine

-MDNA should be one spot above of Bangerz

HEIDI

btw, if your list doesn't include Animal then your list is immediately invalid.