[BTrisc]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Bad Romance is beyond overrated by the Monsters. Quoting Alfred Hitchcock titles does not equal lyrical genius. Having a RedOne create a similar song to Poker Face does not equal production/instrumental genius. WFL is a fresh new venture that Calvin Harris and Rihanna embarked on and it paid off sales wise, chart wise and is on its way to becoming an anthem both in and out of the club.

The Bad Romance hook was a far greater risk than anything in We Found Love and paid off to become one of the most iconic music moments of the past ten years.

[IWasHere]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Bad Romance is beyond overrated by the Monsters. Quoting Alfred Hitchcock titles does not equal lyrical genius. Having a RedOne create a similar song to Poker Face does not equal production/instrumental genius. WFL is a fresh new venture that Calvin Harris and Rihanna embarked on and it paid off sales wise, chart wise and is on its way to becoming an anthem both in and out of the club.

Well the same came be said for WFL. It's extremely repetitive and one can say the only reason The Navy praise it so much is bcuz if it's chart success. I do remember how some of y'all dragged it to hell when it first leaked.

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by monsterx

WFL is SO overrated, and the video in the future will look antiquated I mean it's totally tumblr/hipster

The HIGH-FASHION never dies

The whole point of WFL video is not supposed to be slick and glossed. It was supposed to give off the "antiquated" vibe and emotions.

Just cuz GaGa wore McQueen does not mean it's flawless "high fashion." There is timeless fashion and there is tacky fashion and for a good portion of the video, GaGa was emulating the tacky side of fashion. But that's neither here nor there. The song WFL is superior to BR. PERIOD.

[BTrisc]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

The whole point of WFL video is not supposed to be slick and glossed. It was supposed to give off the "antiquated" vibe and emotions.

Just cuz GaGa wore McQueen does not mean it's flawless "high fashion." There is timeless fashion and there is tacky fashion and for a good portion of the video, GaGa was emulating the tacky side of fashion. But that's neither here nor there. The song WFL is superior to BR. PERIOD.

We'll see if We Found Love gets any Grammies.

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by IWasHere

Well the same came be said for WFL. It's extremely repetitive and one can say the only reason The Navy praise it so much is bcuz if it's chart success. I do remember how some of y'all dragged it to hell when it first leaked.

I never mentioned a thing about repetition. BOTH songs have intense levels of repetition so that argument is null. And everyone mentions this but I don't know who besides the Rihanna haters laughed at WFL's slow ascension. I've always loved the song from the very first snippets that I've heard and I've always been a supporter.

[Horus]

Originally posted by monsterx

Bad Romance sold +5M in the US without being #1
WFL sold +4M being #1 like 10 weeks? and Sexy And I Know It outsold WFL and only was #1, 2 or 3 weeks

LMFAO - Sexy and I Know It #40
We Found Love #Noteveninthetop100

WFL is SO overrated, and the video in the future will look antiquated I mean it's totally tumblr/hipster

The HIGH-FASHION never dies

Ohh yea sure!!!
Baby, baby, baby, ohhh

[reppingBey]

Bad Romance is the better song by far. And the video should go down as one of the best videos of all times!

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by BTrisc

We'll see if We Found Love gets any Grammies.

I guess a grammy for Best Short Form Music Video is suddenly relevant because no one can defend Bad Romance otherwise without a mention of the video.

[reppingBey]

Originally posted by Lyzz the Monster

Bad Romance is a masterpiece. WFL is catchy but beyond repetitive.

Perfect quote.

[Cannabis]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

The whole point of WFL video is not supposed to be slick and glossed. It was supposed to give off the "antiquated" vibe and emotions.

Just cuz GaGa wore McQueen does not mean it's flawless "high fashion." There is timeless fashion and there is tacky fashion and for a good portion of the video, GaGa was emulating the tacky side of fashion. But that's neither here nor there. The song WFL is superior to BR. PERIOD.

I mean we can't compare
Bad Romance is TIMELESS and more ICONIC than ANYTHING on Rihanna discography

Tha Rah Rah Moment >>>>
The Walk Walk Fashion Baby >>>


Bad Romance has Grammys for the song and the video

[BTrisc]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

I guess a grammy for Best Short Form Music Video is suddenly relevant because no one can defend Bad Romance otherwise without a mention of the video.

I see you're ignoring the Best Pop Performance Grammy.

[Cannabis]

Originally posted by MrBillyBrhtd

Ohh yea sure!!!
Baby, baby, baby, ohhh

Thanks for the quote babe

[Serendipity]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

I guess a grammy for Best Short Form Music Video is suddenly relevant because no one can defend Bad Romance otherwise without a mention of the video.

Sis, I do love you but just letting you know that Gaga did get a grammy for best pop vocal for Bad Romance not just the video.

[IWasHere]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

I never mentioned a thing about repetition. BOTH songs have intense levels of repetition so that argument is null. And everyone mentions this but I don't know who besides the Rihanna haters laughed at WFL's slow ascension. I've always loved the song from the very first snippets that I've heard and I've always been a supporter.

My point was WFL is overrated by the Navy simply bcuz of its chart success. You really think most of the Navy would be stanning for WFL if out didn't spent 10 @ #1?! Lol

[reppingBey]

Originally posted by BTrisc

The Bad Romance hook was a far greater risk than anything in We Found Love and paid off to become one of the most iconic music moments of the past ten years.

That Bad Romance hook was so risky. Really, enough can't be said about that.

[RainMan]

sooo hard, two of my favourite all time songs



i might give it to Bad Romance because it was more original for the time

[DvnR]

Where's the "both" option? I can't decide.

[BTrisc]

I do LOVE WFL though. Simplicity really does work for Rihanna sometimes.

[HausOfGerard]

Bad Romance.

[eli's_rhythm]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

"Do not take the videos into consideration"

Nervous that GaGa would lose the poll Remixed?

But WFL is the better song in my opinion. It's on the verge of being an anthem with a little more time. Bad Romance is great but the lyrics restrict it while WFL's lyrics has a sense of freedom. Also, the instrumentals of WFL can stand by itself whereas Bad Romance cannot.

I disagree, BR has a fantastic instrumental. But it's still overrated as a song.

I can't really pick, I do love them both. I think WFL is the perfect song to dance to with friends while BR is more of a lonely anthem for when I'm by myself.