[Eternium]

Originally posted by Mariano

I am not arguing about Telephone as it's the only one that seems far fetched, BUT

PF, JD and BR sold nearly 10M in 12 MONTHS To question that, it's just STUPID.

BTW sold 8.2M in 10 months WW and AFTER THAT it sold 1M in USA and JAPAN alone.

Are y'all for real .....

Nobody argued PF, JD and BR The argument was that Lady Gaga had more 10M sellers but in reality she has three.

You just showed with your own receipts that BTW didn't sell 10M. How does it invalidate Katy's "record?"

[castle13]

Sure jan

[NewRihannaStan]

Queen

[Retro]

Originally posted by Eternium

It's not charting anywhere and it has remarkably weak catalog sales. 900k is not a small feat in 2015

In 2015? Okay. And how about between all but two countries on Earth throughout 2012, 2013, 2014, and 2015 so far?

[PhreshDiamond]

Originally posted by Mariano

This won't make Rihanna's songs sell more than Poker Face, Just Dance, Bad Romance etc. you realize that right ?

but they already did

this just proves that they can sell the extra 400k or so copies they need to hit 10m over a FEW MORE YEARS, unlike gaga

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

Originally posted by Eternium

It's not charting anywhere and it has remarkably weak catalog sales. 900k is not a small feat in 2015

The song was out in 2011. If OP claims his fave's singles sold 4/5 M in more years then I'm pretty sure BTW would've sold at LEAST 900K copies in three years

[iconicmiley]

Why is this reported

Anyways, some of you guys should be less petty and jealous of anyone's but your fave's success.

Good for Katy.

[Jackson]

Originally posted by PhreshDiamond

We Found Love
#129 Ireland
#190 Switzerland

Take Care
#99 United Kingdom
#114 Ireland

Only Girl
#135 Denmark

Umbrella
#164 Turkey

Stay
#123 Netherlands
#161 New Zealand
#173 Switzerland
#182 Ireland
#197 Australia

Diamonds
#99 Turkey
#113 Ireland
#152 France
#153 Philippines
#162 Russia
#162 Switzerland
#177 Brazil
#184 Spain

Where Have You Been
#144 Turkey

Man Down
#114 Turkey


THIS is catalogue selling these songs + others will hang around these positions for YEARS and YEARS and pop into the top 200 of other countries all the time

(this is hiding small countries, with small countries added almost every one of her singles is charting some where)

Meanwhile in the US aka a relevant market, Dark Horse is #96 and Roar is #191.

[Bounce]

Originally posted by Eternium

Nobody argued PF, JD and BR The argument was that Lady Gaga had more 10M sellers but in reality she has three.

You just showed with your own receipts that BTW didn't sell 10M. How does it invalidate Katy's "record?"

Katy's only 10m selling songs are Firework and Roar.

[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by Mariano

What catalogue sales are you talking about ?

PF, BR and JD sold 9.5M + in 12 months, YOU DO NOT NEED catalogue sales to top 10M with those 3

IKAG sold 5.7M in 2008 and you think it has sold 4.3M MORE WW ?
Hot N Cold sold less than 5M in 2008 and you think it has sold 5M SINCE 2009 ?

Bye..

???? IKAG sold around 2.5M with UK + US sales ALONE, it had a huge bump during the TD era

HNC's sales were split bb it sold 5.6M in the US alone and was a bigger hit WW

Enough with this non-sense boo!

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

Originally posted by Retro

In 2015? Okay. And how about between all but two countries on Earth throughout 2012, 2013, 2014, and 2015 so far?

!

[Bounce]

Originally posted by PhreshDiamond

but they already did

this just proves that they can sell the extra 400k or so copies they need to hit 10m over a FEW MORE YEARS, unlike gaga

Rihanna doesn't have any song that outsold PF, JD and BR WW

[Jackson]

Originally posted by Retro

In 2015? Okay. And how about between all but two countries on Earth throughout 2012, 2013, 2014, and 2015 so far?

Born This Way dropped completely off the charts though, it had like 0 longevity. It didn't happen.

[Starstruck.]

Originally posted by Bounce

Katy's only 10m selling songs are Firework and Roar.

Nope

[Starkboy]

Originally posted by Mariano

USA alone, you have no idea how right you are by saying this, cuz it literally kept selling only in the USA



what the hell The only 10M selling out of those is LTWYL and WFL is probably close

What's wrong with y'all, where are your receipts

Lady Gaga has the most 10M selling songs:

Just Dance
Poker Face
Bad Romance
Telephone
Born This Way

So Telephone and BTW outsold WFL? Jesus Christ you have to stop with your ****ing lies.

[Dollas n Diamonds]

WTH is going on in here

its incredibly obvious Katy's first 2 singles didn't sell 10M

but slay Katy getting one of the worst written songs in history and possibly the worst in your discography to 10M

thats undeniable power

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

Originally posted by Starstruck.

???? IKAG sold around 2.5M with UK + US sales ALONE, it had a huge bump during the TD era

HNC's sales were split bb it sold 5.6M in the US alone and was a bigger hit WW

Enough with this non-sense boo!

Still not seeing any receipts bb

[Retro]

Originally posted by iconicmiley

Why is this reported

Anyways, some of you guys should be less petty and jealous of anyone's but your fave's success.

Good for Katy.

I expect you to say the same next time there's an obviously false thread about Gaga's success. Just saying. Since we're believing instead of "being jealous" now.

[superben]

Queen of scoring 10m-selling hits

[Starkboy]

Originally posted by GotSkill

Meanwhile in the US aka a relevant market, Dark Horse is #96 and Roar is #191.

Dark Horse is discounted.

And US is not the only relevant market, ignorant.