[@michael]

Originally posted by DiamondDust

I love When I Grow Up! Sick beat, and the video is cray cray. Although I think it's ridiculous that PCD ever tried to market itself as a girl group when it was so obviously Nicole Scherzinger featuring a group of trashy backup dancers.

I think it's so weird how radio and consumers bought Nicole Scherzinger music when she was known as The Pussycat Dolls, but they won't buy her stuff when she's just Nicole Scherzinger. There must be something about those back-up dancers that brought in the success

[@michael]

Also, Supa, how you gonna just give us the tip like that? You big tease only giving us two songs.

[genetic fail]

When I Grow Up - 10
Hush Hush - 8

Is my taste that ******?

[DiamondDust]

Originally posted by genetic fail

When I Grow Up - 10
Hush Hush - 8

Is my taste that ******?

I'm right there with ya, boo. And I think that if Nicole had started solo, she would be a much bigger star. They would have known how to market her better.

[genetic fail]

Originally posted by DiamondDust

I'm right there with ya, boo. And I think that if Nicole had started solo, she would be a much bigger star. They would have known how to market her better.

IKR? I think these rates have been influenced by the fact that Nicole is a flop now
Seriously... Grow Up is a really nice song. Hush 4x ain't that bad either.

[@michael]

Originally posted by DiamondDust

I'm right there with ya, boo. And I think that if Nicole had started solo, she would be a much bigger star. They would have known how to market her better.

Maybe she should've started with a stage name. I mean, there's a reason Stacy Ferguson and Stefani Germanotta aren't worldwide superstars She could've been Scherzy, like Fergie But she can't change her stage name now, because it would look desperate.

[genetic fail]

Originally posted by @michael.

Scherzy

[@michael]

Originally posted by genetic fail

Hey, it's sorta cute! A lot better than Scherzinger.

[jomarr]

OMG. I was so harsh with PCD. My scores on both songs are lower than the average.

I don't know but there's nothing really special with both songs.. And they get annoying in time

[Nait Phoenix]

Those were two songs I rated high... can't believe they're getting clocked this early...

[Rock That Beat...]

Originally posted by supaspaz

There are quite a number of PCD songs that are getting punched out of this rate early...

[DiamondDust]

I Hate This Part ***** though. But, again, it should have just been a solo song. The other girls literally do NOTHING in the video/in life. Poor Nicole. Anyways, loving this rate!!!!!!! Gimme some TLC!!!

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by genetic fail

IKR? I think these rates have been influenced by the fact that Nicole is a flop now

Don't be fooled. The Pussycat Dolls were never very well regarded by critics—or most audiences, for that matter—but the R&B tinge of their first album certainly had a better reception than the pure sex-pop of their second. I mean, I definitely jam to a couple of the cuts from PCD ("I Don't Need a Man," "Right Now," "Stickwitu," "Buttons"), but from what I can tell, Doll Domination was junk.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by DiamondDust

Gimme some TLC!!!

Those girls won't be showing up for a while. Neither will Destiny's Child.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by @michael.

Also, Supa, how you gonna just give us the tip like that? You big tease only giving us two songs.

Sorry! I went to the ballet last night and this was all I had time to post. Let me do a couple more of these right now.

[supaspaz]

"Beep" (2006)
PCD
Hot 100 Peak: #13



Overall score: 6.08
High score: 8.5 (2x)/Low score: 2 (1x)

"It's funny how a man only thinks about the [beep]/You got a real big heart, but I'm looking at your [beep]/You got real big brains, but I'm looking at your [beep]/Girl, there ain't no pain in me looking at your [beep]"

Seriously, who can resist that kind of lyrical brilliance (besides pretty much every voter in this rate)?

[Ace Reject]

They released quite a lot of trash, huh?

[supaspaz]

"Gitty Up" (1998)
Brand New
Hot 100 Peak: #50



Overall score: 6.38
High score: 9 (1x)/Low score: 3 (1x)

In their final career single, Salt-n-Pepa abandoned socially conscious messages for pure sex appeal. "Gitty Up" is not without its funky appeal, but the move clearly did not go over well—with audiences or the voters of this rate.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

They released quite a lot of trash, huh?

I really loved "Beep" back in my sophomore year of high school, and now the more enlightened, feminist version of myself is just like, "What the hell was I thinking?"

[Beyoncé on Top]

Poor PCD being punched out of the game so early. Hush Hush is amazing - I even gave it a 10.

And Beep is disgusting.