[BabyCantYouSee]

Xtina took very long breaks between each album and each album of hers sounds extremely different from the other, which might've turned some people off.

Britney because of her breakdown and she didn't fill the image everyone expected her to with her comeback in 2008 and also in 2011. The public gave her too many chances and they got sick of her.

[BabyCantYouSee]

Originally posted by Eternium

In 2016, her overall career is still bigger than P!nk's and Bey's.

And I wouldn't brag too much because both P!nk and Bey are waning, too.

YT:
Sorry - 41M
Just Like Fire - 54M

They're not exactly the top girls, either.

Her career is definitely not bigger than Beyonce's. Britney was very big for 6-6.5 years in total in music. Beyonce's never flopped with one album.

[cancer]

Originally posted by rlj

Also was J-lo ever really there aside from a few hits? Her consistent presence is not due to her music career...

Of course she was big in music! After Britney, JLo was like the biggest popstar in the early 2000s.

[cancer]

To answer the question, the music Xtina JLo have been releasing this decade has been very bad.
Britney Jean was horrible too plus Britney really doesn't seem like she's hungry for success anymore.

Bey and P!nk want to be the best and they love what they do and people see that. Along with the fact that they make great music and have immense talent. The GP just really loves these two.

[LOUAY]

Do obvious because of talent.

[Eternium]

Originally posted by BabyCantYouSee

Her career is definitely not bigger than Beyonce's. Britney was very big for 6-6.5 years in total in music. Beyonce's never flopped with one album.

Beyonce's first album with DC was smaller than BJ even with payola.

Bey's overall career is objectively smaller in album equivalents despite having two more studio albums and over 20 more singles.

[Brinny Baby]

Originally posted by QueenBeyoncé

So are Britney fans telling me Britney could have a hugely successful stadium tour today like Beyoncé? Goodnight . Some fads just die out. You pick whatever fad that is...

I already clocked you about Circus being a full decade in her career, and that era is ballparked near than eras BEYONCE and Lemonade and above 4. Yet Beyonce is 2003-2016 and Britney is only 1999-2002/4? Girl Bye!

[Achilles.]

Talent.

[AlphaOmega]

This mutha****a said pink over Britney

[vamp]

Ask this question in 20 years and we'll see where Pink and Beyonce are at.

[Jay Fenty]

Britney Spears is a cultural icon cemented into American history, something that the other girls listed will never achieve.. she is in her own lane.

[Timber]

Originally posted by vamp

Ask this question in 20 years and we'll see where Pink and Beyonce are at.

[dfantasy]

P!nk and Beyonce just keep getting better in terms of performance. They are like fine wine. Musically, P!nk stagnated, but her voice in the past 3 to 4 years are stronger than her debut era. Bey kept reinventing but still stayed true to herself.

Britney gave up her dream a long time ago. Xtina lost her voice due to years of strain.

Would love to see all 4 of them slaying.

[*-ChriZ-*]

Originally posted by Eternium

Beyonce's first album with DC was smaller than BJ even with payola.

Bey's overall career is objectively smaller in album equivalents despite having two more studio albums and over 20 more singles.

It always boils down to the same thing:

Britney had an incredible peak, but in terms of longevity, she's simply not on par with Bey nor P!nk.
Same can be said for Gaga and her generation. She also had an incredible peak compared to her peers, but she's failing in terms of longevity (at least musically speaking. She might be able to redeem herself with LG5)

[Underdogs]

Mess at some of these Britney stans. No one from this generation knows of her or her music.

[Brinny Baby]

Originally posted by Underdogs

Mess at some of these Britney stans. No one from this generation knows of her or her music.

Beyonce, yes but Britney is bigger on social media than Pink. She's more known to teens than Pink is

[Underdogs]

Originally posted by Brinny Baby

Beyonce, yes but Britney is bigger on social media than Pink. She's more known to teens than Pink is

She isn't. Pink has better sales and streams, bigger hits, more successful tours, she rejected a residency at Vegas and the X Factor job before they were offered to Britney etc

There's no competition. Britney has more likes on Facebook though, if that's what you mean.

[Can't_M!ss_This]

Originally posted by Brinny Baby

Beyonce, yes but Britney is bigger on social media than Pink. She's more known to teens than Pink is

It girl Iggy Azalia and teen hottie Britney couldn't get a hyped song past what? 27ish on the Hot 100?

P!nk has an uphill battle to get big on streaming, where she's virtually a non-factor btw, and still scored a two week Top 10 and is currently sitting at 12. With a soundtrack single. Those teens are not doing Britney any favors on the charts.

Oh and I can't post it right now but P!nk is in the Top 10 most popular acts among both adults and teens, one of the few acts to do so along with Bruno and Katy. So perhaps P!nk is bigger with teens after all? She gets those pop radio smashes like it's expected

[Brinny Baby]

Originally posted by Underdogs

She isn't. Pink has better sales and streams, bigger hits, more successful tours, she rejected a residency at Vegas and the X Factor job before they were offered to Britney etc

There's no competition. Britney has more likes on Facebook though, if that's what you mean.

Pink's success in those fields is attributed her her wider appeal like thirty year old soccer moms.

Britney is bigger on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram etc. Pink has the twenty-somethings and middle-aged people to thank for her success but she isn't cared for by teens. I was a teenager during the TTAL era and it was a huge era but we didnt feel it

Pink isn't bigger than Britney on YouTube either too

[MANUELF]

Originally posted by RobynFKA

He stated no top20 WW album.. BB200 is US only buy hey why not, Circus is a bop.

That is still wrong, Circus was top 20 in 2008 and Femme Fatale was almost top 20 in 2011