[RobynYoBank]

Originally posted by Amaru

If Slam awarded PF:RR a 30%, I'm curious as to what Pitchfork will say about the album.

She won't get a 0 because of a few tracks, like Beez in the Trap and Come On a Cone. But they will set fire to her. I expect a more severe version of the MDNA review.

[IWasHere]

I agree.

[Siya]

Didn't PitchFork give Nicki best new track for Beez In The Trap? Still doesnt change the fact that RR is climbing up the charts. Period.

[EmaciatedHooker]

Originally posted by Siya

Didn't PitchFork give Nicki best new track for Beez In The Trap? Still doesnt change the fact that RR is climbing up the charts. Period.

Originally posted by WFL

That album is just amazing. They gave TD 1,5 stars but it had a grammy nomination for album of the year.

You guys should stop with this illogical BS. We all know crappy music sells (not saying RR is crappy).

[Cap10Planet]

Not shocking.

I think she will suffer a slight critical backlash for this album. Her sales should be good, though.

[EOMM92]

I can't!!! This thread was so much fun!!!

*waits for more reviews*

[marky cat]

Originally posted by Last Boy on Earth

Come On A Cone is not one of the strongest tracks, it's so annoying and I agree with this review, it is a listenable album but probably the worst Pop album since Teenage Dream

Yea,TD is so bad that it was nominated for an AOTY on Grammys,broke many records and won many awards!

[marky cat]

Originally posted by WFL

That album is just amazing. They gave TD 1,5 stars but it had a grammy nomination for album of the year.

THIS!

[madonnas]

Originally posted by marky cat

Yea,TD is so bad that it was nominated for an AOTY on Grammys,broke many records and won many awards!

Grammy's aren't indicative of critical acclaim.

[SLAYANNA NAVY]

Damn they dragged Nicki for F.I.L.T.H.

[Quiqui4eva]

I don't think they're dragging her for how the Pop music sounds, but just for the fact that she had Pop songs after starting out in Hip Hop.

[ethan]

Originally posted by madonnas

Grammy's aren't indicative of critical acclaim.

You're right, they're much better. Grammy noms >>> Slate and other crappy magazines reviews.

I bet this review was done by a grown man. That's certainly not Nicki's demographic. Have someone who should like PF:RR review it. Then maybe I'll care what they say.

Originally posted by Monster

Talk That Talk is so far reviewed better.

Reviewed better =/= better. Not at all.

Originally posted by RobynYoBank

The pop half of Roman Reloaded is absolutely atrocious. It's worse than LMFAO's album: it doesn't even give the courtesy of one or two true pop gems.

Absolutely false. Pound the Alarm, Whip It, Young Forever, and Va Va Voom are all fantastic.

Originally posted by Addicted

Maybe its just a question of taste then, but when I see how high some albums got compared to this It certainly doesn't make me want to read anything else this publication puts out.

Right? worse than MDNA? Ch... okay.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by ethan

You're right, they're much better. Grammy noms >>> Slate and other crappy magazines reviews.

I bet this review was done by a grown man. That's certainly not Nicki's demographic. Have someone who should like PF:RR review it. Then maybe I'll care what they say.




Reviewed better =/= better. Not at all.



Absolutely false. Pound the Alarm, Whip It, Young Forever, and Va Va Voom are all fantastic.



Right? worse than MDNA? Ch... okay.

Even if the album has a target demographic, reviewers can recognize when something is good at what it does. PF:RR is not. simple as that.

And MDNA is light years ahead.

[Onen]

Come on a cone is not a good song at all

[ethan]

Originally posted by madonnas

Even if the album has a target demographic, reviewers can recognize when something is good at what it does. PF:RR is not. simple as that.

And MDNA is light years ahead.

I disagree. & I disagree.

[Jeiboy]

At least the Pop songs were enjoyable

[P!nk]

I'm on my phone and it only came up as "Slant magazine slams Pink..."

I was ready to put some hoes in their place!

[Amaru]

Originally posted by ethan

I bet this review was done by a grown man. Have someone who should like PF:RR review it. Then I'll care what they say.

Almost sig worthy. Almost.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by ethan

I disagree. & I disagree.

Care to elaborate?

[Rico Shameless v2]

Damn and I thought their Blackout review was harsh. That got 3 1/2 stars. Slant.