
I've been lurking Mjsbigblog since Season 7 of American Idol and all the laughs the comments have given me through the years
Scotty Mcreery ep and album sold more than Phillip. Scotty's season had better ratings and he appealed to the one direction we type of fans (rabid fans) but look at him for his second album

His first album went platinum after 13 weeks I believe (which were the weeks of the holiday season) and then he didn't sell much at all. Also his album was released almost two months before Phillip's so he gained more sales sooner because of the holiday season. Phillip I think gained some fans out of the Idol bubble so that's good