[That Bad Eartha]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Wouldn't Another Place, Another Time be a better option? And Private Dancer was used in the 84 rate.

Also, is Quicksand the one doing the Unbreakable/Rebel Heart/Me, I Am Mariah ... The Elusive Chanteuse/Kiss Me Once rate?

Poor KMO.

Maybe. I love Another Place and Time, but idk if it could be called a comeback. SWHFTM was a bigger commercial success.

Idk who is hosting it, but KMO is gonna get dragged (deservedly so) since Mariah, Madonna, and Janet all released their best albums in years and Kylie released her worst.

[Superiore]

Originally posted by Superiore

The only thing I'm not sure about is including Shakira cause of the non-American criteria since I excluded artists from Canada and Central America. What do you say about it?

Also, when could it start?

.

[Mimie]

How do I do this?

I wanna do a Walt Disney Discography Rate, not soon tho

[Quicksand]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Wouldn't Another Place, Another Time be a better option? And Private Dancer was used in the 84 rate.

Also, is Quicksand the one doing the Unbreakable/Rebel Heart/Me, I Am Mariah ... The Elusive Chanteuse/Kiss Me Once rate?

Poor KMO.

I'd love to take up that rate!

[KillingYourCareer]

Ugh I hate it when people start rates and don't finish them. This one was very interesting and it was completely wasted

[KillingYourCareer]

Originally posted by Quicksand

I'd love to take up that rate!

100% here for it, do it

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by KillingYourCareer

Ugh I hate it when people start rates and don't finish them. This one was very interesting and it was completely wasted

It "wasn't finished" because we collectively realized that Kylie and Mariah deserved better than comparisons to ... those two.

But if someone wants to do a Spring Pop Madness 204 rate with the other two albums, Lily Allen's "comeback," and something else, I'd be more than here for it.

Originally posted by Superiore

.

What was the idea again?

[Colton Haynes]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

It "wasn't finished" because we collectively realized that Kylie and Mariah deserved better than comparisons to ... those two.

But if someone wants to do a Spring Pop Madness 204 rate with the other two albums, Lily Allen's "comeback," and something else, I'd be more than here for it.



What was the idea again?

Well I'm here.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Colton Haynes

Well I'm here.

What albums were released last year (that haven't been rated) is the question.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by tylerlscwv

Maybe. I love Another Place and Time, but idk if it could be called a comeback. SWHFTM was a bigger commercial success.

Idk who is hosting it, but KMO is gonna get dragged (deservedly so) since Mariah, Madonna, and Janet all released their best albums in years and Kylie released her worst.

You know what would be a cute rate?

Bring Ya to the Brink v. Crayons v. Closer To The Truth. Super cute actually!

[ECNEICSNOC]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

It "wasn't finished" because we collectively realized that Kylie and Mariah deserved better than comparisons to ... those two.

They're still gonna be in a rate with Rebel Heart and Unbreakable, right?

[Colton Haynes]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

What albums were released last year (that haven't been rated) is the question.

Let me get to researching!

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by ECNEICSNOC

They're still gonna be in a rate with Rebel Heart and Unbreakable, right?

Sister, we've been discussing it on this page! #should'veknownbetter

[Quicksand]

I need some title ideas for the Madonna/Kylie/Janet/Mariah rate

[That Bad Eartha]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

You know what would be a cute rate?

Bring Ya to the Brink v. Crayons v. Closer To The Truth. Super cute actually!

Totally here for this. Maybe add Grace Jones' Hurricane for the 4th? Like I said, I've still got to finish my Madonna rate (countdown starts next Tuesday-ish), but I'll host this when I'm done.

I hope Crayons doesn't get dragged though. It can be rough on first listen, but it really does reward repeat listens.

[Ace Reject]

The Singles Jukebox. If you're not familiar with it, has some similarities - but more stark differences - with/between Pitchfork/RS/Pazz + Jop/Popjustice. Two ideas:

1) a rate of their year end top ten singles from 09-14.

2) a rate of all the singles to have scored higher than 7.00 from them this year. (There are forty so far!!!)

Who wants to take the lead on either/or?

[Colton Haynes]

Acey, What about Kiss Me Once vs. Me... I Am Mariah vs. Sheezus vs. Queen of the Clouds?

[That Bad Eartha]

Originally posted by Colton Haynes

Acey, What about Kiss Me Once vs. Me... I Am Mariah vs. Sheezus vs. Queen of the Clouds?

He meant Shakira. vs AKA vs Sheezus vs whatever else you can think of.

KMO and MIAMTEC are for the rate with Unbreakable and Rebel Heart.

EDIT: Also maybe you could use Paloma Faith's A Perfect Contradiction (idk if it has been used)? It fits a bit better than QOTC just because it isn't Paloma's debut.

[Ace Reject]

Yeah, and let's dismantle that Epic rate thing, because no one wants to hear Karmin.

Piece by Piece v. Title v. Breathe In, Breathe Out v. Unbreakable Smile would make a perfectly cromulent rate.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by tylerlscwv

He meant Shakira. vs AKA vs Sheezus vs whatever else you can think of.

KMO and MIAMTEC are for the rate with Unbreakable and Rebel Heart.

EDIT: Also maybe you could use Paloma Faith's A Perfect Contradiction (idk if it has been used)? It fits a bit better than QOTC just because it isn't Paloma's debut.

Yeah, I offered Paloma and Lykke to him as options.