[OnikaChrist]

Originally posted by Alchemist

206 members. Queen really owns us

She's the biggest artist on ATRL, so it's expected.

[UMS125]

Originally posted by Erreur2 La Nature

The NYT review seems to be honest, Joanne is like a demo album. It feels like she started working on it 3 months ago and put all the demos on it. IDK it's surprising for Gaga, in a bad way.

this.

[Soup in Teapot]

Britsh's taste.

[DivaCup]

Originally posted by TinkerbellClap

This thread is going too fast. Why are there so many people in here?



I don't think Metacritic works that way (sum of reviews / # of reviews). I'm not sure tho.

Gaga has them haters perched

[J a y]

Originally posted by Luder

If this is the review thread, I don't wanna see the HDD one.

No other artist has this much impact on 'music fans' and I don't know why

This forum is OBSESSED with her and people say she's over ahak; I thought there'd be Gaga fans checking for her and that's it this era.

Everyone must have ****ed off and left her alone by now.. how many eras is gonna take for my girl to get some peace and quiet??

She doesn't want to be famous anymore. She just wants to make music and perform for fans

Stefani knows because Bennett and Ronson told her that's how Amy deteriorated. She couldn't cope

[Dessy Fenix]

Originally posted by TinkerbellClap

This thread is going too fast. Why are there so many people in here?



I don't think Metacritic works that way (sum of reviews / # of reviews). I'm not sure tho.

Everyone is perched to see it flop/succeed

[ThisCharmingMan]

Originally posted by FutureHive

they rarely do that nowadays

childish gambino famously got a 1.6

Didn't they give a 2 to the last Mumford And Sons album or am I just confused?

[Alchemist]

100 pages before Friday?

[LadyGagaStan93]

Originally posted by Brando

I don't see anyone crying about the Telegraph's review, questioning their credibility, digging up their tweets etc etc.

They actually DID review the music though Like it's apparent that they listened to the album. Even if they did have bad stuff to say, I could at least be cool with the fact that they you know.... reviewed the album....

[kwek_kwek]

Originally posted by theblackestday

Petty
That would only make him hate Gaga more and give her next album a 0/10

Then NYT shouldn't allow that writer to review Gaga's music if he is taking it peronally.

[lightstheyblindme]

Originally posted by Erreur2 La Nature

The NYT review seems to be honest, Joanne is like a demo album. It feels like she started working on it 3 months ago and put all the demos on it. IDK it's surprising for Gaga, in a bad way.

[CakeLike]

Originally posted by Brando

I don't see anyone crying about the Telegraph's review, questioning their credibility, digging up their tweets etc etc.

Because they gave it a fair score based on the music and not the persona, the album deserves 4 or 5 stars out of 5. Her best ever album, is it too hard to understand

[rasmushooker]

dd;

watch monsters still scream from the top of the mountain how bad the fame is, how redone is terrible etc

y'all deserve this

[lightstheyblindme]

Originally posted by LadyGagaStan93

They actually DID review the music though Like it's apparent that they listened to the album. Even if they did have bad stuff to say, I could at least be cool with the fact that they you know.... reviewed the album....

this

[Dessy Fenix]

Originally posted by CakeLike

Because they gave it a fair score based on the music and not the persona, the album deserves 4 or 5 stars out of 5. Her best ever album, is it too hard to understand

What makes the others unfair though?

[ShouldersSideways]

Originally posted by J a y

No other artist has this much impact on 'music fans' and I don't know why

This forum is OBSESSED with her and people say she's over ahak; I thought there'd be Gaga fans checking for her and that's it this era. Everyone must have ****ed off and left her alone by now.. how many eras is gonna take for my girl to get some peace and quiet??

Honestly a lot of people on here hate her. People hate Bey because of how the hive acts but people hate Gaga because of how she AND her fans act. So there's more here perched to see her fail.

[Kim Kardashian]

So the Telegraph balances out the NYT review but she'll still probably be in orange.

[Mikeymoonshine]

So now she's gotten a good review is the album suddenly better according to those arguing that "it's just bad and the reviews show it"? What if it did somehow end up 70+, would you all say it was a good album or would messy critics suddenly stop being the authority in how good the album is? I'm so confused I was told this wouldn't get positive reviews.

[TinkerbellClap]

Wait. The guests are banned? Oh wow, Joanne's POWER! in atrl

[Rusty]

Originally posted by Brando

I don't see anyone crying about the Telegraph's review, questioning their credibility, digging up their tweets etc etc.

Its intro talks Gaga. The remaining 6 paragraphs review the album. This is a review of Joanne, not Lady Gaga. But stay mad.