[Bad Wolf]

Originally posted by Pon.

So she isn't ready for the competition

American idol is not only a competition of singers but also a competition of artists

It is not only about how he/she can hit that note but also about how he/she makes it his/her own,

The best artists of our time weren't always fit into one category or one genre of music as an artist.

Take Elvis for example. He was rock, country, R&B, blues, jazz, and yet at the same time everything he did was pop too. It's called VERSATILITY and Siobhan had it damnit.

[eteru]

Originally posted by -mUsIcLoVeR-

It looks different without Siobhan.

It certainly does.

Im sorry but I kinda agree with Simon's comment on Mike. He does (not only sing, but also) act and move a little feminine :X

[Pon.]

Originally posted by eteru

She probably lost it on TTF, but I loved her rendition of "Across The Universe." I think it was a great rendition and still unique in a way that many would expect her to do crazy stuff with it, but she decided to go the other route and show her softer and "calmer" side.

But that's your opinion and I respect that I just love Siobhan a lot.

Me 2, "Across the universe" is the only song i think she did great (after Paint It Black). But i just wanted her to put more darkness to the song, like "Wicked game"

[eteru]

Originally posted by Carrie-is-no-1

Siobhan is the only contestant being eliminated and get tons of discussion here/press releases elsewhere

so why not hail down to the queen

And she had a lot of airtime after she sang "Think." It was sad, but I loved the special airtime alloted for her lol.

[Яeo.]

Siohban out? Wow! They've been slaying my favorites one after another!

Lilly - Didi - Siohban.

That's it. It's time to say Bye - This season sucks hard without Siohban. She'll be missed

[Fireman25]

I predict the final two will be Crystal VS Lee.

They are the only ones who have not been in the bottom 3 yet and Lee is starting to become a front runner.

[INTRA]

Originally posted by -mUsIcLoVeR-

It looks different without Siobhan.

Is it just me or Mike looks weird here?

[Mariah]

Damn, the producers really want Crystal to win Got rid of Siobhan already

[Tinker]

Originally posted by eteru

It certainly does.

Im sorry but I kinda agree with Simon's comment on Mike. He does (not only sing, but also) act and move a little feminine :X

And what are you suggesting with this statement?

[tcatron565]

Originally posted by Mariah

Damn, the producers really want Crystal to win Got rid of Siobhan already

It has nothing to do with Siobhan's terrible performance on Tuesday. I'm sorry, I mean, I like Siobhan and all, but she destroyed "Any Man of Mine." Sad, really. I don't think she should've been eliminated, but it was all honestly her error on song choice.

[Mariah]

Originally posted by tcatron565

It has nothing to do with Siobhan's terrible performance on Tuesday. I'm sorry, I mean, I like Siobhan and all, but she destroyed "Any Man of Mine." Sad, really. I don't think she should've been eliminated, but it was all honestly her error on song choice.

I was kidding

Anyway, the producers DO exert too much influence on the contestants' song choices. They forced Siobhan to sing Through The Fire in the RnB week.
Same to Lilly.

[SwagLikeALegend]

That big black guy would be better suited as a linebacker.

[Luis]

1. Lee
2. Crystal
GAP
3. Casey
4. Mike
5. Aaron

[MusicTalker]

Originally posted by Luis;

1. Lee
2. Crystal
GAP
3. Casey
4. Mike
5. Aaron

That's exactly how I want it to go.

[INTRA]

I hope Lee wins.

[Pon.]

I like Mike
Almost every ballads he sang

They're all deep and full of emotion

[gracee]

^ Same here. He sings his heart out every time he's on stage.
Crystal is the most consistent contestant this year. She always stays true to herself, yet she never gets boring . She clearly knows who she is as an artist. She delivers it every time. She can hardly do anything wrong. So it's really annoying how people keep underrating her & praising Siobhan.
Sure Siobhan is a very good competitor. She's very interesting as a person, also. But clearly, she was getting dull. It seems like she overdid her "scream" , & people grew tired of it. When she didn't use it, her voice sounded kind of, bland. Without her signature scream, she was pretty boring, like, she was insecure, not knowing what to do. It appears to me that the only moment where she was really confident in herself, really gave it her very own, was when she screamed. Just my opinion.
Anyway, I think she left a bit early though. I think she should have stayed until top 5.

[Mr. Duff]

Cruystal is so OVERRATED IMO. Ugh.
Siobhan is so missed already.

[gracee]

^ Name a reason why she is overrated. An objective one.

[eteru]

Originally posted by Tinker

And what are you suggesting with this statement?

I just think it's a little weird to see him that way considering his size and all. I'm not saying it's wrong, I just find it kinda weird.