[Kool_Aid_King]

SMH at When Love Takes Over being gone.

I'm still so freaking shocked at Say My Name leaving. That song was is perfect

[supaspaz]

"Sound of the Underground" didn't even make the top 40? What is actually happening right now? The girl groups were done so, so WRONG in this rate.

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by supaspaz

"Sound of the Underground" didn't even make the top 40? What is actually happening right now? The girl groups were done so, so WRONG in this rate.

I mean, I truly don't understand.

Like, none of this makes any sense to me.

[supaspaz]

Also, I would argue that "When Love Takes Over" is the best thing Guetta has ever done. For me, it's one of the only songs in the recent dance-pop boom that has truly realized the genre's greatest potential in capturing the spirit of euphoria.

[madonnas]

10s

All Saints- Pure Shores - 10
Geri Halliwell- Bag It Up - 10
Spiller ft. Sophie Ellis-Bextor- Groovejet (If This Ain't Love) - 10
Madonna- Music – 10
Kylie Minogue- Can't Get You Out Of My Head - 10
Aaliyah- More Than A Woman – 10
Las Ketchup- The Ketchup Song (Asereje) - 10
Girls Aloud- Sound of the Underground - 10
Beyoncé ft. Jay-Z- Crazy in Love - 10
Kylie Minogue- Slow - 10
Britney Spears- Toxic - 10
Sugababes- Push the Button – 10
Shakira ft. Wyclef Jean- Hips Don't Lie - 10
Lily Allen- Smile - 10
Robyn- With Every Heartbeat - 10
Madonna ft. Justin Timberlake, Timbaland- 4 Minutes - 10
Lady Gaga- Bad Romance - 10
Carly Rae Jepsen- Call Me Maybe - 10


my 0s

Mariah Carey ft. Westlife- Against All Odds - 0
Jennifer Lopez- Love Don't Cost A Thing – 0
DJ Sammy ft. Yanou- Heaven - 0
Evanescence- Bring Me To Life - 0
Kelly Osbourne and Ozzy Osbourne- Changes - 0
Michelle McManus- All This Time - 0
Mario Winans ft. Enya and P Diddy- I Don't Wanna Know - 0
Girls Aloud- I'll Stand By You - 0
*****cat Dolls- Stickwitu - 0
Sandi Thom- I Wish I Was A Punk Rocker - 0
Leona Lewis- A Moment Like This - 0
Katie Melua ft. Eva Cassidy- What A Wonderful World – 0
Rihanna- Take A Bow - 0
Katy Perry- I Kissed a Girl - 0
Beyoncé- If I Were A Boy - 0
Leona Lewis- Run - 0
Alexandra Burke- Hallelujah - 0
Kelly Clarkson- My Life Would Suck Without You - 0 (WHY ISN'T THIS OUT YET?!?!?!)
Rihanna ft. Drake- What's My Name? - 0
Jessie J ft. B.o.B- Price Tag - 0
Nicole Scherzinger- Don't Hold Your Breath - 0
Little Mix- Cannonball - 0
Jessie J- Domino - 0
Katy Perry- Part of Me - 0
Tulisa- Young - 0
Rita Ora ft. Tinie Tempah- R.I.P - 0



At least most of my 0s are out I expected a LOT more from some of those 10s though.

[EJQL8]

Originally posted by jinzo

43. Kylie Minogue- Spinning Around (7.255)



Highest score: 10 x4 (JDella11, berberocka, Dream, Soma80)
Why are you giving 0s to Kylie? Do you want to be banned?: 0 x1 (airbornE)

An unflattering picture of Kylie:



This was intended originally for Paula Abdul's comeback album. Imagine? Imagine if Kylie didn't channel her inner dance goddess on this? No.

Instead, this was Kylie's big comeback. Her first UK #1 since Confide in Me, this track has become synonymous with those golden hotpants. The hotpants were found by Kylie's friend on a market, and costed 50p. That's almost double the total revenue of Alexandra Burke's Heartbreak on Hold.

Jinzo's verdict: 9.5
I feel stupid for not giving this a 10! It really is perfect. I just felt like I was giving the flaw-free year of 2000 far too much stanning. Like, 2012? Are you taking notes?

It's "Tears on my Pillow", actually. Confide peaked at number 2.

[Ace Reject]

Wait.

Kelly's still here? Come the eff on.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Wait.

Kelly's still here? Come the eff on.

Seriously!!!! These results like, don't make sense to me

[supaspaz]

Wait. How is "My Life Would Suck Without You" still here but "Pure Shores" is not? That is completely ridiculous.

Can we get an update on what's left? I feel like I'm going to be fuming at all the terrible songs that I didn't realize haven't been eliminated yet.

[Sporefan]

Please tell me Jinzo forgot to reveal MLWSWY at the start
That trash should not even be in the top 100

[jinzo]

Originally posted by supaspaz

"Sound of the Underground" didn't even make the top 40? What is actually happening right now? The girl groups were done so, so WRONG in this rate.

They really were. It seems they're amongst the most polarising for some unexplainable reason. I mean, I can understand if people marked lowly because they haven't heard All Saints before, and so they gave it 0/1/2 out of sheer stupidity and lack of RedOne electro beat or Flo Rida rap, but Girls Aloud and Sugababes should be absolutely every ATRLer's iTunes.

Originally posted by EJQL8

It's "Tears on my Pillow", actually. Confide peaked at number 2.

I was reading the chart statistics too quickly.

Originally posted by Sporefan

Please tell me Jinzo forgot to reveal MLWSWY at the start
That trash should not even be in the top 100

Kelly Clarkson stans

Everywhere

Originally posted by supaspaz

Wait. How is "My Life Would Suck Without You" still here but "Pure Shores" is not? That is completely ridiculous.

Can we get an update on what's left? I feel like I'm going to be fuming at all the terrible songs that I didn't realize haven't been eliminated yet.

Just look at the very next post!

[jinzo]

So what's left in our Top 40?

2000

Britney Spears- Born To Make You Happy
Britney Spears- Oops!...I Did It Again
Madonna- Music
Leann Rimes- Can't Fight the Moonlight
Eminem ft. Dido- Stan

2001

Jennifer Lopez- Love Don't Cost a Thing
Destiny's Child- Survivor
Christina Aguilera, Pink, Mya and Lil Kim ft. Missy Elliot- Lady Marmalade
Kylie Minogue- Can't Get You Out Of My Head

2002

Pink- Just Like a Pill
Nelly and Kelly- Dilemma
Christina Aguilera ft. Redman- Dirrty

2003

t.A.T.u- All The Things She Said
Christina Aguilera- Beautiful
Evanescence- Bring Me To Life
Beyoncé ft. Jay-Z- Crazy in Love

2004

Britney Spears- Toxic
Britney Spears- Everytime
Natasha Bedingfield- These Words ( )

2005

Sugababes- Push The Button
Madonna- Hung Up

2006

Madonna- Sorry
Nelly Furtado- Maneater
Shakira ft. Wyclef Jean- Hips Don't Lie
Lily Allen- Smile

2007

Rihanna ft. Jay-Z- Umbrella
Leona Lewis- Bleeding Love

2008

Duffy- Mercy
Estelle ft. Kanye West- American Boy
The Ting Tings- That's Not My Name

2009

Lady Gaga ft. Colby O'Donis- Just Dance
Lily Allen- The Fear
Kelly Clarkson- My Life Would Suck Without You
Lady Gaga- Poker Face
Lady Gaga- Bad Romance

2010

Lady Gaga ft. Beyoncé- Telephone
Rihanna- Only Girl (In The World)

2011

Adele- Someone Like You
Rihanna ft. Calvin Harris- We Found Love

2012

David Guetta ft. Sia- Titanium

[Brando]

Originally posted by jinzo

Kelly Clarkson stans

Everywhere

Can't remember what I gave to that song. It certainly doesn't deserve more than a couple of points.

[Brando]

Tatu is still here

And I feel that Britney/Beyonce/Gaga songs will start dropping like flies now

Something tells me Born To Make You Happy is the first in line, because it's too old for ATRL gurls.

[Great Username]

I mean, I haven't followed this rate but I assume "More Than A Woman" isn't actually not in the top 40. You realise that if you think "My Life Would Suck Without You" or "That's Not My Name" is better than it, that you're an actually awful human being right?

[VJoker]

Duffy - Mercy needs to go.
I gave scores from 6-10 to the rest of the songs left.

[jinzo]

Originally posted by Great Username

I mean, I haven't followed this rate but I assume "More Than A Woman" isn't actually not in the top 40. You realise that if you think "My Life Would Suck Without You" or "That's Not My Name" is better than it, that you're an actually awful human being right?

That's why I wall posted you! I assumed you'd help out the girl bands as well, who have been totally wronged in this rate.

I have no idea how on earth Natasha Bedingfield and The Ting Tings have gotten further than Freak Like Me, The Promise, Pure Shores, What's My Name? and Spinning Around- but it's a democracy so the people decide....

[Brando]

Originally posted by jinzo

That's why I wall posted you! I assumed you'd help out the girl bands as well, who have been totally wronged in this rate.

I have no idea how on earth Natasha Bedingfield and The Ting Tings have gotten further than Freak Like Me, The Promise, Pure Shores, What's My Name? and Spinning Around- but it's a democracy so the people decide....

The Ting Tings are still here?

I should have been given out scores like madonnas. Only 0's and10's

[adrianbeane]

I can only cosign with everyone. This rate is going horribly.

And there's still so many mediocre crap left.

[VJoker]

Originally posted by jinzo

That's why I wall posted you! I assumed you'd help out the girl bands as well, who have been totally wronged in this rate.

I have no idea how on earth Natasha Bedingfield and The Ting Tings have gotten further than Freak Like Me, The Promise, Pure Shores, What's My Name? and Spinning Around- but it's a democracy so the people decide....

I like the songs from Natasha and TTT but they are not better than Pure Shores or WMY at all.