|
TV Show: AHS: Roanoke | Paleyfest Panel: 3/26 | Season 7: 2017
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 5/28/2011
Posts: 39,615
|
Nfnn then why did you reply to that post? You clearly didn't read it.
And I don't totally dislike her. I'd be saying the same if it was ANY singer of her calibur with the same level of acting skills/experience. It's a weird, random and risky casting option, and there's 0 argument to that.
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 8,579
|
Please don't ripoff The Shining like how Freak Show and Murder House blatantly ripped off a bunch of horror movies (Shining included for MH)
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 13,781
|
Quote:
Originally posted by X/O/X/O
Nfnn then why did you reply to that post? You clearly didn't read it.
And I don't totally dislike her. I'd be saying the same if it was ANY singer of her calibur with the same level of acting skills/experience. It's a weird, random and risky casting option, and there's 0 argument to that.
|
I read everything you said actually and all I see is you trying to undercut Gaga every chance you get.
Even when someone like Vespertine (Who clearly read what you said and was only responding) responds, the first thing you do is call him out for not reading.
Believe it or not - someone doesn't have to agree with you in order to grasp what you said.
I see the undertones in what you're saying and I don't approve.
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 5/28/2011
Posts: 39,615
|
Fhjm
You so lucky I'm on mobile
The only reason I seem like I'm trying to discredit or undercut her is because she ain't got ANY experience in shaky acting. You'd be acting the same if he cast Katy or someone else instead.
And it appeared that Vespertine didn't read, because nowhere in that post before him did I state that we have an exact indicator of her acting. She excels in theatrics and dramatics, so it wouldn't be a surprise if she heavily used them, but we have no idea what to expect.
His reply read as "You said she overacrs and you think that's all that's gonna happen.", which is not what I said.
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/10/2009
Posts: 19,215
|
Quote:
Originally posted by X/O/X/O
So, Ryan created the season around her. Great job ignoring the stars that have been waiting for a spotlight role for like 2-3 seasons, Ryan.
|
I don't think he said that. He said the character was built for her. Madison Montgomery was also (likely) built for Emma Roberts, so I don't think that this indicates Gaga will be the star of the show.
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 5/28/2011
Posts: 39,615
|
I just want Lily & Frances to have Sarah-sized roles, but Ryan refuses.
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/10/2009
Posts: 19,215
|
Is Lily still involved in THG? I really want either Lily or Kathy to play the main character this time.
LOVE Angela and Frances, but I really enjoy the kooky side characters they've been playing recently.
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 13,781
|
Quote:
Originally posted by X/O/X/O
Fhjm
You so lucky I'm on mobile
The only reason I seem like I'm trying to discredit or undercut her is because she ain't got ANY experience in shaky acting. You'd be acting the same if he cast Katy or someone else instead.
And it appeared that Vespertine didn't read, because nowhere in that post before him did I state that we have an exact indicator of her acting. She excels in theatrics and dramatics, so it wouldn't be a surprise if she heavily used them, but we have no idea what to expect.
His reply read as "You said she overacrs and you think that's all that's gonna happen.", which is not what I said.
|
It goes both ways. Your comment literally reads "I do question her acting since she doesn't have much experience, and since she often relies on dramatics, it would not be a surprise if she becomes a large ham and overacts."
Just because you foreshadow it with "I'm not saying I expect her to be bad." doesn't take away the implication of what you were getting at.
But play the victim I guess
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/20/2011
Posts: 13,921
|
Nmnnn" I'm almost home now so I'm about abkht to join this mess once my computer boots up.
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 12,666
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Repo
Please don't ripoff The Shining like how Freak Show and Murder House blatantly ripped off a bunch of horror movies (Shining included for MH)
|
Ryan Murphy has no originality so
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 25,504
|
Just like how it is ok for some of you guys to "assume" that monsters will be praising Gaga / the season even if it's bad, the same way you should assume that a lot of haters will be hating on Gaga and the season just because it's Gaga.
Just like how it is ok for some of you to assume Gaga will be bad (even though we haven't seen her properly act, BUT one thing we know for sure is that she has an ACTUAL background and you can't just compare her to Katy for example, cuz someone already did that a few posts above) the same way some of us are excited and believe she can be really good.
Don't heat it up from now, there is too much time till we actually see the new episodes...
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 5/28/2011
Posts: 39,615
|
Quote:
Originally posted by geemarty
It goes both ways. Your comment literally reads "I do question her acting since she doesn't have much experience, and since she often relies on dramatics, it would not be a surprise if she becomes a large ham and overacts."
Just because you foreshadow it with "I'm not saying I expect her to be bad." doesn't take away the implication of what you were getting at.
But play the victim I guess
|
I'm not even the only one who would think that. Talking about Gaga joining AHS to others, several others have literally mentioned that she's known for her extravagance. It's what people expect. I'm not trying to be slick. I honestly don't know how to feel or what to expect about her as an actress. You said exactly what I said, and I don't see anything wrong with that. She could work it, I never denied that. I'm not trying to play victim. I think it's strange that y'all act like it's ridiculous to question her skills when we don't know much about them. If I wanted to try and take a dig at her, I'd do it. I'd say "She's probably gonna suck" or something, but that's not how I feel. I've stated my thoughts on it, and you're grasping at straws trying to say I mean anything else. It's as bad as the Tumblr fans saying everything is a clue.
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 5/28/2011
Posts: 39,615
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 13,781
|
Since you feel like continuing i'll go ahead and compile some tea for you - I'll try to make it as tumblr-like as I can so you can understand
Quote:
Originally posted by X/O/X/O
So, Ryan created the season around her. Great job ignoring the stars that have been waiting for a spotlight role for like 2-3 seasons, Ryan.
|
Quote above showing resentment towards Gaga.
Quote:
Originally posted by X/O/X/O
Also, just to clarify, training for one performance =/= Training for a season of acting, cuz y'all like to bring that up a lot
I am not insisting she will be bad. But I am not insisting she will be good. I am saying that her acting is questionable because we literally have not seen it, and I am naturally a skeptical person. Don't take anything I'm saying as an attack on Gaga, please, thank you, God bless.
|
Quote above reiterating what you've already said numerous times - my favorite part is the sentence in bold at the end. You're once again trying to put a bandaid on some subtle shade.
Quote:
Originally posted by X/O/X/O
bj;
LORD, if this is what it's gonna be like with y'all...
I'm saying, she doesn't have experience, and acting isn't a skill you can just pick up so quickly. If it was, Emma wouldn't have BUTCHERED the already-poorly-written Maggie, and Taissa would have an Emmy.
She could be fantastic, for all we know. I have said that numerous times. But we do not know. It's a risky move on Ryan's part to cast her with such little experience & demonstration. And, before y'all repeat "Well he must have tried her out!!!", there's like an 80% he did not. That's a Ryan problem, not a Gaga problem.
|
Showing aggression towards a certain group of people ( I'll leave this one open-ended since you didn't state specifically who)
Quote:
Originally posted by X/O/X/O
fdjb;
Gir (pt. 2), she dropped out of Tisch before completing tha year.
|
Slight drag at the end! But I guess you're JUST SAYING!
Quote:
Originally posted by X/O/X/O
d
Knot ALL of them, TGT.
But you're the most level-headed Monster I've met to date, other than, like, Meowster, but he's been weird so I'm not sure if he counts.
|
Singling out one monster while trying to shade the rest.
Now tell me again how i'm crazy for thinking you're throwing shade at Gaga? These quotes are only from the last three pages BTW.
Quote:
Originally posted by X/O/X/O
I'm not even the only one who would think that. Talking about Gaga joining AHS to others, several others have literally mentioned that she's known for her extravagance. It's what people expect. I'm not trying to be slick. I honestly don't know how to feel or what to expect about her as an actress. You said exactly what I said, and I don't see anything wrong with that. She could work it, I never denied that. I'm not trying to play victim. I think it's strange that y'all act like it's ridiculous to question her skills when we don't know much about them. If I wanted to try and take a dig at her, I'd do it. I'd say "She's probably gonna suck" or something, but that's not how I feel. I've stated my thoughts on it, and you're grasping at straws trying to say I mean anything else. It's as bad as the Tumblr fans saying everything is a clue.
|
The only one grasping at straws is you - stop trying to deflect and actually take a look at the mess you've been spewing the past few pages.
If you're going to drag... then drag - but lets not try to hide behind some excuse.
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/3/2011
Posts: 28,911
|
Quote:
Originally posted by geemarty
Since you feel like continuing i'll go ahead and compile some tea for you - I'll try to make it as tumblr-like as I can so you can understand
Quote above showing resentment towards Gaga.
Quote above reiterating what you've already said numerous times - my favorite part is the sentence in bold at the end. You're once again trying to put a bandaid on some subtle shade.
Showing aggression towards a certain group of people ( I'll leave this one open-ended since you didn't state specifically who)
Slight drag at the end! But I guess you're JUST SAYING!
Singling out one monster while trying to shade the rest.
Now tell me again how i'm crazy for thinking you're throwing shade at Gaga? These quotes are only from the last three pages BTW.
The only one grasping at straws is you - stop trying to deflect and actually take a look at the mess you've been spewing the past few pages.
If you're going drag... then drag - but lets not try to hide behind some excuse.
|
Omg
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/20/2011
Posts: 13,921
|
Geemarty scalping for the gods.
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 5/28/2011
Posts: 39,615
|
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 5/28/2011
Posts: 39,615
|
For the record, the first quote was resentment towards Ryan. Lily & Frances have paid their dues and deserve huge roles. That was what that was about.
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/20/2011
Posts: 13,921
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 11/10/2009
Posts: 19,215
|
How could u do me like that X/O/X/O.
|
|
|
|
|