After ther first episode I said that she would be a great and unexpected killer. It's just she's one of the great characters of the show who isn't portrayed as some plain perfect bimbo as Emma and she does nothing suspicious.
The teacher is definitely not the killer. Typical Scream set up.
Im betting on Brandon being alive and the killer with the help of his daughter the journalist forgot her name. The journalist is Emma's mother's daughter and Brandon's, And she is helping papa get revenge.
It would be a great throwback to Harper's Isand. Everyone thought the killer was dead, but he ends up alive and with the help of his son, kills them all.
I think it makes sense.
Btw, how much dou y'all hate Emma;s mom? I mean, i physically hate her. She's just there. uneventful, irrelevamt, corny, untalented piece. The actress is truly HORRIBLE. Like, her acting is cringeworthy.
at some of the theories in this thread. "Emma and Brooke's moms are the killer" like what show are you watching?
Some people ignoring the fact of the lost sibling reveal and still going at it, I'm sure they will be the same people who will go "I called the killers were Piper and Jake since episode 5 minute 4, second scene, third line of dialog" when the series end
at some of the theories in this thread. "Emma and Brooke's moms are the killer" like what show are you watching?
Some people ignoring the fact of the lost sibling reveal and still going at it, I'm sure they will be the same people who will go "I called the killers were Piper and Jake since episode 5 minute 4, second scene, third line of dialog" when the series end
I am sure there will be a big death in ep 10, but I don't want anyone to die anymore. Kieran, the sheriff and Emma's mother can go but keep Emma, Jake, Brooke, Noah and Audrey.
I can't believe I got attached to all of them now. I'm so soft.
I definitely think Piper is Daisy and Brandon James' child that was put up for adoption. She's talked about how her dad has died before and her dad could be anybody, but all signs point to it being Brandon James. She seems to be kind of protective of Emma, but that could very well be an act so nobody, especially Emma, suspects her as being the killer. Her motive could be to get back at Daisy for giving her up for adoption without knowing that Daisy's parents were the ones that made the decision for her because she was only 16 and she probably blames Daisy for Brandon James' death as well. If she's getting revenge on Daisy, then Emma would get the brunt of it. It would be interesting if Piper didn't turn out to be the killer or one of the killers.
Kieran is the other person that fits the description of being Daisy and Brandon James' love child which would be gross since he would have slept with his half sister. He's still on top of my list as a possible suspect.
I'm not entirely convinced that Mr. Branson is the killer. It was very suspicious how he disappeared in the auditorium and then appeared once again after the killer was supposedly gone, but someone could be framing him. However, I am glad he got caught for that inappropriate relationship he was having with Brooke.
Having Brandon James be one of the killers would be so predictable unless he's like the cop or something, and even then. I hope it's someone shocking, but the Piper clues are so obvious.
Are they using the same cast/storyline for the next season?
Cause I don't really see how this could work as a slasher plot needs... you know... a big part of the main cast to die.
Are they using the same cast/storyline for the next season?
Cause I don't really see how this could work as a slasher plot needs... you know... a big part of the main cast to die.
Yeah. Same cast and story but they will introduce new characters.
She's such a great character and there not that many in the show.
Kieran, the sheriff and Emma's mother can go but keep Emma, Jake, Brooke, Noah and Audrey. 
