[slobro]

Originally posted by Ash12345

BB doesn't track Ww sales though
If you have a problem with the receipts speak to the receipt thread owner

The OP is very conservative (which is better than inflating sales, but still)

For example Just Dance sold 7.7M WW in 1 Dec 2008-30 Nov 2009 (IFPI), with 3,824,397 sales from US and 746,610 sales from UK. Outside of that tracking period, it has sold 3,065,603 in the US + 188,390 in the UK alone (more by now).

That alone makes 10,953,993 confirmed sales rather than 10.5M like in the receipt thread.

An atrl receipt thread isn't the end all be all, some ones are conservative like the Gaga one, while many are inflated (the Katy and Britney ones for example)

[AxelFox]

She's already sold more records than Gaga overall.

Who cares if she sold less albums?

[XStaticProcess]

Originally posted by AxelFox

She's already sold more records than Gaga overall.

Who cares if she sold less albums?

This tbh.

[Ash12345]

Originally posted by AxelFox

She's already sold more records than Gaga overall.

Who cares if she sold less albums?

Because selling albums is more impressive than selling singles

[Ash12345]

Originally posted by XStaticProcess

This tbh.

Like if Rihanna who has sold another 120m singles (quite possible)
Would you really say it doesn't matter that she's only sold 30m albums, she's sold more records than madonna.

[Optimus]

Originally posted by AxelFox

She's already sold more records than Gaga overall.

Who cares if she sold less albums?

I wanna see the receipts for that statement

[Ash12345]

Originally posted by slobro

The OP is very conservative (which is better than inflating sales, but still)

For example Just Dance sold 7.7M WW in 1 Dec 2008-30 Nov 2009 (IFPI), with 3,824,397 sales from US and 746,610 sales from UK. Outside of that tracking period, it has sold 3,065,603 in the US + 188,390 in the UK alone (more by now).

That alone makes 10,953,993 confirmed sales rather than 10.5M like in the receipt thread.

An atrl receipt thread isn't the end all be all, some ones are conservative like the Gaga one, while many are inflated (the Katy and Britney ones for example)

I feel like it's conservative on singles but inflates album sales so balances it out
For example media traffic put BTW at 6.3m and the receipts thread put it at 17m.
Also same with tf(m) and the additional album sales seem high. Which I feel helps to make up for the conservative single estimates.

[MaRy]

29 millions? looks inflated tbh, she was at 23 before artpop now 25 at most

[Optimus]

Originally posted by Ash12345

I feel like it's conservative on singles but inflates album sales so balances it out
For example media traffic put BTW at 6.3m and the receipts thread put it at 17m.
Also same with tf(m) and the additional album sales seem high. Which I feel helps to make up for the conservative single estimates.

Its about TFM, but keep trying Even tho Mediatraffic does not count sales

Originally posted by MaRy

29 millions? looks inflated tbh, she was at 23 before artpop now 25 at most

24M before Artpop so 24+2+1=27M

[Ash12345]

Originally posted by MaRy

29 millions? looks inflated tbh, she was at 23 before artpop now 25 at most

MT has her at 26.6m with her remix albums.
I can see 27m with that gags holiday thing and the other one tbh.
29m is a bit of a reach but I trust the gagas receipts thread holders credibility.

[Swag]

How is this even a question? Just look at both's sales graphs

[AxelFox]

Originally posted by Optimus

I wanna see the receipts for that statement

The reciepts are in the OP.

14mil album sales + 120 mil single sales = 134 records sold for Miss Perry.

Gaga doesn't cross the 120 mil mark.

There is a gap bigger than 10 mil records sold between the two ladies, and the one with more records sold is obviously the winner.

[Mariano]

No.

[Ash12345]

Originally posted by AxelFox

The reciepts are in the OP.

14mil album sales + 120 mil single sales = 134 records sold for Miss Perry.

Gaga doesn't cross the 120 mil mark.

There is a gap bigger than 10 mil records sold between the two ladies, and the one with more records sold is obviously the winner.

Then rih Is bigger than whitney

[Eggy.]

Nah

[AxelFox]

Originally posted by Ash12345

Then rih Is bigger than whitney

???

You asked if Katy will outsell Gaga by 2020, I just pointed out that she already did.

And Rih is not too far ahead of Katy, I thought Withney sold a lot more records than that.

[Aurora]

Yes, it's beyond obvious at this point.

[Optimus]

Originally posted by AxelFox

The reciepts are in the OP.

14mil album sales + 120 mil single sales = 134 records sold for Miss Perry.

Gaga doesn't cross the 120 mil mark.

There is a gap bigger than 10 mil records sold between the two ladies, and the one with more records sold is obviously the winner.

In November 2013 katy was at 81M singles sales WW. Did she sell 40M singles with prism?
http://www.mtv.co.uk/katy-perry/news...ngle-bell-ball

[Rayaine]

In her wildest dreams

[Summer Boy]

Gaga sold 125 000 000 singles and 29 000 000 albums and that's from Billboard tho
So Gaga wins in every aspects minus the streams