[TheVoiceXtina]

Not many can do a full on dance routine...in sync with the music and be able to give live, passionate, tear inducing vokals afterwards. i know of 2

[B94]

Originally posted by DejaVu

Adele does not have great technique. The reason she's had so much problems with her vocal chords is actually because of that. She sounds great and a lot better than Xtina, but i still wouldn't consider her in today's top 5 vocalist.

Well maybe before her technique wasn't the best, but i'm pretty sure now she's taken steps in how to not let that happen again. That last part is you're opinion, I don't agree at all.

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by DejaVu

please post 5 performances where she doesn't strain. It may take you a while to find them, but I think they may exist!

[B94]

Originally posted by jpsketch

Don't get me wrong, I adore Adele and yes, she does everything she needs to do in a live performance.

But in performances like this (and many many others!):



Her voice just goes nowhere. In the studio version she pretty much takes you home at the end of the song. Here just just remains the same.

Where do you expect it to go?

[DejaVu]

Originally posted by Kats

There was no dragging involved sis, your the one who keeps trying to downplay Christina Aguilera and ADELE's vocals compared to Kelly Clarkson. I'll let you continue.

Not at all. I adored Christina up until the Bionic era. And loved adele until everyone began claiming she was the voice of our generation.

You're the one coming in here talking about Grammy awards as if they mean anything in the context of this poll. you were so adamant on proving it too.

Originally posted by TheVoiceXtina

Not many can do a full on dance routine...in sync with the music and be able to give live, passionate, tear inducing vokals afterwards. i know of 2

Gaga and Beyonce? Queens.

Originally posted by TheVoiceXtina

such an empowering woman

I'll help you.



The problem is, for every good performance she has, I can post exactly 15 bad ones. It's been scientifically proven.

[jpsketch]

Originally posted by B94

Where do you expect it to go?

Her vocal at the end of the song matches her exact vocal in the beginning of the song. She displayed absolutely no range or colors to her voice.

In my opinion, a vocalist should go from point A to point B in a song. Adele goes from point A to point A (when she sings live).

[alkralkra]

Clarkson is clearly superior to the other two there's nothing to even argue.

[B94]

Originally posted by jpsketch

Her vocal at the end of the song matches her exact vocal in the beginning of the song. She displayed absolutely no range or colors to her voice.

You know what, I won't even go any further.

[DejaVu]

Originally posted by B94

You know what, I won't even go any further.

This is a thread about vocals, is it not?

[TheVoiceXtina]

Originally posted by alkralkra

Clarkson is clearly superior to the other two there's nothing to even argue.

Well, the Grammys should decide that

[TheVoiceXtina]

Originally posted by DejaVu

Not at all. I adored Christina up until the Bionic era. And loved adele until everyone began claiming she was the voice of our generation.

You're the one coming in here talking about Grammy awards as if they mean anything in the context of this poll. you were so adamant on proving it too.


Gaga and Beyonce? Queens.

I said in sync

[jpsketch]

Originally posted by B94

You know what, I won't even go any further.

I'm just talking about her live vocals. She serves me everything I need in the studio.

[alkralkra]

Originally posted by TheVoiceXtina

Well, the Grammys should decide that

Lol were talking bout vocals lets not get off topic

[P!nkInside]

Xtina = Soprano
Kelly = Soprano
ADELE = Contralto
Best Vocalist:
Kelly: Maximum Range, Maximum Control, As good as it gets.
ADELE: Low Range, Great Control, Great Emotion, Just Special.
Xtina: Maximum Range, Minimum Control, Bad Technique, VERY unique voice.

Kelly > ADELE > Xtina
In My Opinion.

[Errrlend]

Adele is not a powerhouse as the others.
so
KC and CA

[B94]

Originally posted by DejaVu

This is a thread about vocals, is it not?

And what does that have anything to do with me not wanting to continue on with someone who saying a bunch nonsense? no range, no color? get the hell outta here with that mess.

Originally posted by P!nkInside

Xtina = Soprano
Kelly = Soprano
ADELE = Contralto
Best Vocalist:
Kelly: Maximum Range, Maximum Control, As good as it gets.
ADELE: Low Range, Great Control, Great Emotion, Just Special.
Xtina: Maximum Range, Minimum Control, Bad Technique, VERY unique voice.

Kelly > ADELE > Xtina
In My Opinion.

[Guy]

Xtina doesn't belong in this poll, let alone out in second place. Kelly is the winner, but Xtina is a mediocre vocalist. And please, before I get flamed, recognize the difference between being a good singer or someone with a good base (natural talent) and being a good vocalist. They're two different things.

[jpsketch]

Originally posted by P!nkInside

Xtina = Soprano
Kelly = Soprano
ADELE = Contralto
Best Vocalist:
Kelly: Maximum Range, Maximum Control, As good as it gets.
ADELE: Low Range, Great Control, Great Emotion, Just Special.
Xtina: Maximum Range, Minimum Control, Bad Technique, VERY unique voice.

Kelly > ADELE > Xtina
In My Opinion.

Pretty much.

[Chemist]

Gayest poll ever, what a ******

[DejaVu]

Originally posted by B94

And what does that have anything to do with me not wanting to continue on with someone who saying a bunch nonsense? no range, no color? get the hell outta here with that mess.

Adele's range is akin to J Lo's. It's not like the poster was lying, so I'm not getting what's so funny.