[bunnie]

Besides the lyrics, the song is everything. Just imagine if it was about about something else! ! The instrumental >>>>>>>

[Scandal & Media]

Kind of, the song isn't her best, it's too similar to Bad Romance structure wise. The lyrics (minus the chorus) and the production are great, though.

[Rainer]

Yes.

[☈evolusion]

No. It's a stupid song and deserved to flop.

[Feather]

Yes. If it was on The Fame, the song would have smashed. RedOne gave us all what we wanted -- we loved The Fame, so he gave us The Fame-material stuff... But for some reason, some people did not just like it. It has the Just Dance, Poker Face, Love Games elements. What's so bad about it?

[ALA]

Eh. I don't know about underrated.

I think if the song had different lyrical content and smashed then the BTW probably would've been a lot different.

[Bliss]

Yes. Loooove this song.

[Illegal]

So much. It should have been her biggest single to date.

[coolcristobal]

Originally posted by Sye

But... but... it didn't do well in the US! Doesn't that mean it's a flop?!

It was in the Top 10 one week...and for the rest of the weeks it remained in the charts, it stayed around the Top 10-20. I din't know why people would consider that a flop...Somewhere around Top 10-20 is not a flop, but they aren't hits either. You Da One, Fly, Moment 4 Life, Best Thing I Never Had, What The Hell are all songs that only peaked at at least Top 11, and people don't consider them as flops.

[Squall]

Yes, I really don't understand why people hate it, it's one of the best songs on BTW !

[coolcristobal]

Originally posted by Ramcoro

How many of Judas's peak positions were debuts? Anyways, Love Game did better in most countries. Plus, you have to consider that Gaga was MUCH bigger at the time Judas was released than when LG was. Didnt LG also chart significantly higher on most YE charts WW?

The only peak positions that were debuts that I know of were U.S.A, Italy, and Australia (I'm sure there's more, but not much).

[KyKy]

Not when I am running at 8mph

[superben]

It's right where it should be

[Khidyperry]

Underrated and overrated

[Brooklyn]

i don't like the lyrics

[Darren-5-08]

Definitely. It should have smashed so hard

[manwhore]

yes, its magic and life changing. It will bring purpose to anyones life as long as you open yourself fully to this power.

[TSDMusicND]

I actually don't know. I already saw a lot of hate for it but i already saw a lot of love for it as well

[TSDMusicND]

I think the hate is not because of the song itself but the concept of it for example on the other day I was watching judas music video with my parents and my mom was like Girl... this is disturbing because of the story itself and not because of the song

[Delta]

You mean OVERrated.